- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Early attempts at classification and Mendeleev's periodic table
Trace the classification of elements from Lavoisier, Döbereiner, de Chancourtois, Newlands and Lothar Meyer to Mendeleev's periodic law, his predictions and the anomalies in his table.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why chemists needed to classify the elements.
- Test a Döbereiner triad and state Newlands' law of octaves and its limit.
- State Mendeleev's periodic law and describe how his gaps led to correct predictions.
- Give examples of the anomalies in Mendeleev's table.
Millions of compounds are built from fewer than a hundred naturally occurring elements. Today 118 elements are known, of which those with atomic numbers 1 to 92 occur in nature (according to the textbook). Learning each element separately would be impossible, so chemists looked for patterns that group similar elements together. The search took most of the nineteenth century.
Lavoisier's grouping
In 1789 the French chemist Antoine Lavoisier published one of the first lists of chemical elements. He sorted his 'simple substances' into four groups: acid-making elements (such as sulphur, phosphorus and carbon), gas-like elements (such as oxygen, nitrogen and hydrogen, together with light and heat, which he then counted as substances), metallic elements (such as copper, iron, gold and zinc) and earthy elements (oxides such as lime and magnesia). It was a start, but it was based on a few properties and included things that are not elements.
Döbereiner's triads (1817)
J. W. Döbereiner noticed groups of three elements with similar chemical properties, called triads, in which the atomic weight of the middle element is nearly the arithmetic mean of the other two. Examples are Li, Na, K; Ca, Sr, Ba; Cl, Br, I; and S, Se, Te.
Worked example 1: testing a triad
Sulphur, selenium and tellurium have atomic weights of about 32, 79 and 127.6. Working: mean of the outer two = (32 + 127.6) ÷ 2 = 159.6 ÷ 2 = 79.8, very close to selenium's 79. The idea failed, however, for many elements, and sets such as Fe, Co, Ni have almost the same atomic weights, so no middle value can be picked out. Only a few elements could be grouped this way.
De Chancourtois and Newlands
In 1862 A. E. B. de Chancourtois arranged the elements in order of atomic weight along a helix drawn at 45° on a cylinder whose circumference was 16 units, so one turn meant an increase of 16 in atomic weight. Elements falling on the same vertical line had similar properties. It was the first reasonable attempt at a periodic arrangement, but it drew little attention.
In 1864 J. Newlands proposed the law of octaves: when elements are arranged in increasing atomic weight, every eighth element resembles the first, as the eighth note of a musical scale repeats the first. Sodium resembles lithium, and potassium resembles sodium. The law worked well only for the lighter elements, up to calcium.
Lothar Meyer and Mendeleev
In 1868 Lothar Meyer plotted physical properties such as atomic volume, melting point and boiling point against atomic weight and found a repeating pattern. At about the same time Dmitri Mendeleev independently stated the periodic law: the properties of the elements are periodic functions of their atomic weights. He arranged the roughly 70 elements known in his time in order of increasing atomic weight in vertical columns (groups) and so built the first periodic table.
Mendeleev's periodic law: the properties of the elements are periodic functions of their atomic weights.
Gaps and predictions
Mendeleev's great step was to leave blank spaces where no known element fitted, and to predict the properties of the missing elements. He named two of them eka-aluminium (below aluminium in group III) and eka-silicon (below silicon in group IV). When gallium and germanium were discovered, their atomic weights, densities and the formulas of their oxides and chlorides matched his predictions closely.
| Predicted element | Discovered as | Predicted oxide and chloride | Observed oxide and chloride |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eka-aluminium | Gallium (Ga) | E₂O₃, ECl₃ | Ga₂O₃, GaCl₃ |
| Eka-silicon | Germanium (Ge) | EO₂, ECl₄ | GeO₂, GeCl₄ |
Anomalies in Mendeleev's table
- Some elements with similar properties were put in different groups, and some unlike elements in the same group.
- To keep similar elements together he sometimes placed a heavier element before a lighter one, against his own law: cobalt (58.9) before nickel (58.7), and tellurium (127.6) in group VI before iodine (126.9) in group VII.
- Isotopes, which have different atomic weights but the same properties, have no proper place in a table based on atomic weight.
From triads to the periodic law
- 1817 Döbereiner Triads: middle atomic weight ≈ mean of the other two.
- 1862 de Chancourtois Elements on a helix round a cylinder.
- 1864 Newlands Law of octaves, valid up to calcium.
- 1868-69 Lothar Meyer and Mendeleev Periodic patterns in properties; periodic law and table with gaps.
- 1913 Moseley Atomic number, not atomic weight, is the real basis.
Key takeaways: classification began with Lavoisier's four groups and grew through triads, the helix and octaves. Mendeleev's periodic law was based on atomic weight; his gaps and correct predictions of gallium and germanium made his table convincing, but pairs such as Co-Ni and Te-I broke the atomic-weight order. The cure came from Moseley's work on atomic number.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the triad chlorine (35.5), bromine and iodine (127), what atomic weight does Döbereiner's rule predict for bromine?
- 81.25
- 91.5
- 63.5
- 79.9
Show answer
Answer: A. Mean of the outer two = (35.5 + 127) ÷ 2 = 162.5 ÷ 2 = 81.25, close to bromine's actual value of about 80.
-
2. What does Newlands' law of octaves state?
- Every element has eight isotopes
- Every element has eight valence electrons
- Every eighth element, in order of atomic weight, resembles the first; this works up to calcium
- Elements fall into eight triads
Show answer
Answer: C. Newlands found that properties repeat at every eighth element when arranged by atomic weight, like notes in an octave, but the pattern held only for the lighter elements, up to calcium.
-
3. According to Mendeleev's periodic law, the properties of elements are periodic functions of their
- atomic numbers
- atomic weights
- numbers of neutrons
- densities
Show answer
Answer: B. Mendeleev based his law and table on atomic weights. The modern periodic law, after Moseley, uses atomic numbers instead.
-
4. Which element turned out to be Mendeleev's eka-silicon?
- Gallium
- Scandium
- Tin
- Germanium
Show answer
Answer: D. Eka-silicon, the gap below silicon in group IV, was filled by germanium, whose oxide GeO₂ and chloride GeCl₄ matched the predicted EO₂ and ECl₄. Gallium was eka-aluminium.
-
5. Which placement in Mendeleev's table went against his own periodic law?
- Sodium placed after neon
- Fluorine placed before neon
- Tellurium (127.6) placed before iodine (126.9)
- Calcium placed after potassium
Show answer
Answer: C. Tellurium is heavier than iodine but was placed before it so that each sat with similar elements (Te with S and Se, I with Cl and Br). This broke the order of increasing atomic weight.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.