• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Barter system and the hindrances of commerce

State the conditions and constraints of barter, explain how money solved them, define commerce and show how business removes the six hindrances of person, place, time, risk, knowledge and finance.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the three conditions for barter and its four constraints.
  • Explain why the invention of money solved the problems of barter.
  • Define commerce and explain how business removes the hindrances of person, place, time, risk, knowledge and finance.

Imagine trying to buy a notebook today with a bag of groundnuts. You would have to find a shopkeeper who wants groundnuts, agree how many groundnuts a notebook is worth, and carry the bag to the shop yourself. This is barter, and its difficulties explain why money was invented. Even with money, many other obstacles stand between a factory and a buyer. This lesson covers both: the barter system and the hindrances that commerce removes.

Conditions for barter

Before money, goods were exchanged for goods. The textbook says barter worked only when three conditions were met:

  1. Each party must have a surplus stock to trade.
  2. Each must badly need the other's goods: a double coincidence of wants.
  3. Buyer and seller must meet personally to make the exchange.

Constraints of barter

  1. Lack of double coincidence of wants: if A has surplus groundnuts and B has surplus rice, the exchange happens only if A wants rice and B wants groundnuts at the same time.
  2. No common measure of value: there was no accepted yardstick for comparing the values of all articles, so it was hard to decide how much of one good equals another.
  3. Lack of direct contact between producer and consumer: in many cases buyers and sellers could not meet face to face.
  4. Lack of surplus stock: without a surplus on both sides, no barter could take place.

The invention of money as a medium of exchange removed these constraints: a seller can accept money from anyone and spend it with anyone else, and prices give a common measure of value. Other obstacles to moving goods from the place of production to the place of consumption remained, such as place, time, risk, knowledge and finance, and these are handled by commerce.

What commerce means

Industry produces goods and services to satisfy human wants; commerce gets them from where they are produced to the people who want them. It is the link between producer and consumer. The textbook quotes a definition of commerce as the organised system for the exchange of goods and services between members of the industrial world. Commerce includes all forms of trade (wholesale, retail, import and export) and the services that aid trade, such as banking, transport, warehousing, insurance and advertising. Business, in turn, consists of all industry and commerce.

Hindrances removed by business

The six hindrances of commerce, as listed in the textbook.
HindranceThe problemRemoved by
PersonManufacturers do not know who and where the consumers areMiddlemen: wholesalers, agents and retailers (the retailer knows consumers' tastes and location)
PlaceGoods are made in one centre but consumers are spread everywhereTransport by rail, road, air and sea
TimeGoods are produced ahead of demand but wanted laterWarehouses in regional centres
Risk of lossFire, theft, floods and accidents can cause heavy lossInsurance
KnowledgePeople do not know about new products and their usesAdvertising and communication
FinanceProducers and traders may lack funds when neededBanks and other financial institutions

Commerce

  • Trade
    • Wholesale
    • Retail
    • Import
    • Export
  • Aids to trade
    • Transport (place)
    • Warehousing (time)
    • Insurance (risk)
    • Advertising and communication (knowledge)
    • Banking (finance)
Trade removes the hindrance of person; each aid to trade removes another hindrance.

Person - middlemen; place - transport; time - warehousing; risk - insurance; knowledge - advertising; finance - banking.

Worked example 1: why barter fails

Kumar (made-up) has surplus mangoes and wants cloth. Selvi has surplus cloth but wants salt. Raju has surplus salt and wants mangoes. Reasoning: no pair has a double coincidence of wants: Kumar wants Selvi's cloth, but Selvi does not want mangoes. A chain of three swaps could work, but only if all three meet, agree values and trust one another. With money, Kumar sells mangoes to Raju, pays Selvi for cloth, and Selvi buys salt from Raju, each deal separate and simple.

Worked example 2: matching hindrance to aid

A made-up rice mill in Thanjavur faces these problems: (a) it does not know shopkeepers in Coimbatore; (b) the harvest comes in once, but rice is bought all year; (c) the godown might catch fire; (d) it needs money to pay farmers before sales. Working: (a) hindrance of person, removed by wholesalers and retailers; (b) hindrance of time, removed by warehousing; (c) hindrance of risk, removed by insurance; (d) hindrance of finance, removed by bank loans. Carrying rice to Coimbatore would add the hindrance of place, removed by transport.

Key takeaways: barter needs surplus, double coincidence of wants and personal meeting; its constraints are lack of double coincidence, no common measure of value, lack of direct contact and lack of surplus; money solved these; commerce is the organised system of exchange, covering trade and its aids; business removes the hindrances of person, place, time, risk, knowledge and finance.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The hindrance of place is removed by:

    1. insurance
    2. warehousing
    3. transport
    4. advertising
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Goods are produced in one centre but consumers are spread out; rail, road, air and sea transport carry products to them.

  2. 2. A has surplus groundnuts and B has surplus rice, but A does not want rice. Which constraint of barter stops the exchange?

    1. Lack of double coincidence of wants
    2. Lack of surplus stock
    3. Lack of a warehouse
    4. Lack of insurance
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both have surplus, so the problem is that their wants do not match. Barter needs each party to want what the other has.

  3. 3. Storing goods in warehouses in regional centres removes the hindrance of:

    1. person
    2. finance
    3. knowledge
    4. time
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Goods are produced in anticipation of demand and stored so they reach consumers at the right time: that is the hindrance of time.

  4. 4. Which of these is NOT one of the constraints of barter listed in the textbook?

    1. No common measure of value
    2. Lack of double coincidence of wants
    3. High rate of customs duty
    4. Lack of surplus stock
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The four constraints are lack of double coincidence of wants, no common measure of value, lack of direct contact between producer and consumer, and lack of surplus stock. Customs duty is not one of them.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The retailer helps remove the hindrance of person. Reason (R): The retailer knows the tastes, preferences and location of consumers.

    1. A is false but R is true
    2. Both A and R are false
    3. A is true but R is false
    4. Both A and R are true and R explains A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Manufacturers do not know their consumers; the retailer, who does, links them through the chain of middlemen. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery