• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

From barter to e-commerce: how trade began among the early Tamils

Trace the growth of commerce from barter to a money economy and today's electronic modes, and explain how trade began among the early Tamils, with the words vanigam and pandamattru and the goods used as money.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the journey of commerce from barter to a monetary economy and on to electronic commerce.
  • Explain the meaning of vanigam and the evidence the Tamil textbook gives for early Tamil trade.
  • Name the goods that served as a medium of exchange in the Sangam period.

Every time you pay for a snack with a phone app, you are using the newest stage of a very old activity. People have exchanged things for as long as there have been neighbours with different skills and different surpluses. The Tamil Nadu textbook opens Class 11 Commerce with this history because the problems traders faced centuries ago, such as finding a buyer, agreeing a value, carrying goods safely and getting paid, are the same problems that banks, transport, insurance and advertising solve today. The chapter begins with a couplet from the Thirukkural (Kural 120), which teaches that a merchant should protect the interests of others as carefully as his own: honesty was seen as the base of trade from the start.

The long journey of commerce

Commerce began as an economic activity in the form of barter, the direct exchange of goods for goods. Barter worked reasonably well between neighbouring villages and even regions as long as there was no common medium of exchange. As trade grew and scarce resources had to be exchanged between people and places that needed them, money came to dominate, and the barter economy slowly became a monetary economy, in which money is the medium of exchange for goods and services. Dynasties rose and fell, but trade carried on, both inside the country and between nations.

Over time commerce became a many-sided, organised system with methods such as the monetary system, mail-order business, the hire purchase system and the instalment purchase system. In today's technology-driven society, the textbook notes that commerce is heading towards a cashless system through e-commerce, that is, business carried on through electronic modes such as online trading, mobile banking and e-marketing.

Stages in the growth of commerce

  1. Barter Goods exchanged directly for goods.
  2. Monetary economy Money becomes the medium of exchange.
  3. Organised trading methods Mail order, hire purchase, instalment purchase.
  4. E-commerce Online trading, mobile banking, e-marketing; moving towards cashless trade.
Each stage kept the purpose of exchange but changed how it was done.

How trade began among the early Tamils

According to the textbook, the earliest trading people of India were the people of the Indus Valley. Among the Tamils, the words vaniyam or vanipam are thought to be of Dravidian origin. The early Tamils produced goods on their own lands and exchanged whatever was left over after their own needs, the surplus, and that is how trade came into being. The word Vanigam (trade) is used widely in Sangam literature such as the Purananuru and in the Thirukkural.

There is also hard evidence. Tamil-Brahmi inscriptions found at Alagarmalai, Pugalur, Mangulam and in Sri Lanka show that trade in goods such as gold, oil, ploughs and cloth was going on in the early age. Sangam works mention great traders, their caravans and the security guards who travelled with them, markets and marts, and guilds (associations) of such traders.

Barter in the Sangam age: pandamattru

Trade in the Sangam period was both internal (within the region) and external (with other lands), but it was carried on mainly by barter, which the Tamils called pandamattru. Each group offered what its own landscape produced:

Different regions produced different surpluses, so they depended on one another.
Group (as in the book)What it offered in exchange
Hill tribesHoney, roots and fruits
Pastoral (herding) peopleCattle, milk and milk products

Some goods were accepted so widely that they began to act like money. The textbook says that cattle served as money for a time, that much of the inland trade used salt as a medium of exchange, and that paddy too served as a medium of exchange for a certain period. Barter strengthened the relationship and interdependence of people within the region, while coins came to be used later, mainly for external trade.

Trade begins with surplus: what one group has left over is exchanged for what another group has left over. Barter (pandamattru) came first; money came later, first in external trade.

Worked example 1: placing a method on the timeline

Place each (made-up) situation on the stages of commerce: (a) a hill family gives honey to a herder for a pot of milk; (b) a farmer buys a pump set by paying one-twelfth of the price every month; (c) a student pays a bookseller through a mobile banking app. Reasoning: (a) goods are exchanged directly for goods, so it is barter; (b) paying in fixed parts over time is an instalment or hire-purchase type of method, part of the organised trading stage; (c) payment by an electronic mode belongs to e-commerce, the cashless stage the textbook describes.

Worked example 2: why salt and paddy worked as money

Why would salt or paddy be accepted by almost everyone in the Sangam age? Reasoning: a medium of exchange must be something nearly everybody wants and can store. Every household needs salt and paddy, both can be divided into small quantities, and both keep for some time. So a trader who received salt could pass it on to someone else for what he actually wanted. That is the first step from pure barter towards money.

Key takeaways: commerce moved from barter to a monetary economy, then to organised methods such as hire purchase and instalment buying, and now towards cashless e-commerce; the early Tamils traded their surplus, and the word Vanigam appears in Sangam literature and the Thirukkural; Tamil-Brahmi inscriptions record early trade; Sangam trade was mainly barter (pandamattru), with cattle, salt and paddy serving at times as a medium of exchange and coins used later in external trade.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Tamil word used in the textbook for barter in the Sangam period is:

    1. Vanigam
    2. Angadi
    3. Pandamattru
    4. Peruvali
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Pandamattru is the textbook's term for barter. Vanigam means trade, Angadi is a market place and Peruvali is a main road.

  2. 2. According to the textbook, which of these served as a medium of exchange in much of the inland trade of the Sangam period?

    1. Salt
    2. Silk
    3. Horses
    4. Copper coins only
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The book says most inland trade used salt as a medium of exchange under barter; cattle and paddy also served at times. Coins were used later, mainly in external trade.

  3. 3. Which evidence does the textbook give that trade in gold, oil, ploughs and cloth existed in the early age?

    1. Coins of the Mughal emperors
    2. Tamil-Brahmi inscriptions from places such as Alagarmalai and Mangulam
    3. Records of the East India Company
    4. Travel diaries of Vasco da Gama
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Tamil-Brahmi inscriptions from Alagarmalai, Pugalur, Mangulam and Sri Lanka illustrate early trade in such goods.

  4. 4. Paying for a purchase through a mobile banking app belongs to which stage of commerce described in the chapter?

    1. Barter
    2. Pandamattru
    3. Mail-order business
    4. E-commerce
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Business enabled by electronic modes such as online trading, mobile banking and e-marketing is e-commerce, the cashless direction the textbook describes.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Trade came into existence among the early Tamils. Reason (R): They produced goods on their lands and exchanged their surplus.

    1. A is true but R is false
    2. Both A and R are true and R explains A
    3. A is false but R is true
    4. Both A and R are false
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says the early Tamils bartered their surplus and that is how trade came into existence, so R correctly explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery