• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Causa proxima, contribution, subrogation and mitigation

Apply the remaining principles of insurance: identify the proximate cause of a loss, share a claim between insurers in double insurance, and explain subrogation and the duty to reduce loss.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Identify the proximate cause of a loss and decide whether the insurer is liable.
  • Calculate each insurer's share of a claim under the principle of contribution.
  • Explain subrogation and mitigation and how both support indemnity.

The first three principles decide whether a contract is valid and how much is payable. The next four deal with what happens when a loss actually occurs: what caused it, who pays when there are several policies, who owns the damaged property afterwards, and what the insured must do while the loss is happening. Together the seven principles make up the textbook's list of the principles of insurance.

Principle 4: causa proxima (nearest cause)

Causa proxima means the nearest or proximate cause. When a loss results from two or more causes acting together or one after another, the insurer looks at the direct, dominant and most effective cause. If that cause is a risk covered by the policy, the insurer pays; if the cause is not covered, or is only a remote cause, it does not. For instance, a fire policy pays when fire is the proximate cause of damage, but not when goods spoil only because of heat with no fire at all.

Principle 5: contribution

When the same subject matter is insured with more than one insurer, it is double insurance. The insured may claim from any of them, but the total received from all insurers together cannot exceed the actual loss. The insurers then share the loss in the ratio of the sums they insured. Contribution keeps double insurance from becoming a way to profit.

Share of an insurer = (sum insured with that insurer ÷ total sum insured with all insurers) × actual loss.

Principle 6: subrogation

Subrogation means stepping into the shoes of another. Once the insurer has paid the claim, the insured's rights over the damaged property, and any rights to recover from a third party who caused the loss, pass to the insurer. If the insured could keep the salvage and also sell it, he would get more than his loss, which would break the principle of indemnity.

Principle 7: mitigation

Having a policy does not make the insured careless. When a mishap occurs, the insured must take every reasonable step to reduce (mitigate) the loss, acting as a prudent person would if there were no insurance. If the insured does nothing to save the property, the insurer may not pay the full claim.

The seven principles of insurance

  • Before the contract
    • Utmost good faith
    • Insurable interest
  • Measuring the claim
    • Indemnity
    • Causa proxima
  • After the loss
    • Contribution
    • Subrogation
    • Mitigation
Grouping used here to help memory; the textbook lists them in order 1 to 7.

Worked example 1: sharing a claim

Made-up case: a godown is insured against fire with Insurer P for ₹4,00,000 and with Insurer Q for ₹6,00,000. A fire causes an actual loss of ₹2,50,000. Working: total sum insured = 4,00,000 + 6,00,000 = ₹10,00,000. Ratio P : Q = 4 : 6 = 2 : 3. P's share = 2/5 × 2,50,000 = ₹1,00,000. Q's share = 3/5 × 2,50,000 = ₹1,50,000. Check: 1,00,000 + 1,50,000 = ₹2,50,000, exactly the loss and no more.

Worked example 2: subrogation and causa proxima

Made-up case: Farida's insured delivery van is damaged when another driver's truck hits it. The insurer pays her ₹60,000 for repairs and replaces the broken bumper. Reasoning: by subrogation, the broken bumper now belongs to the insurer, and the insurer may also try to recover the ₹60,000 from the negligent truck driver. Farida cannot claim the same loss again from the truck driver. The collision was the proximate cause of damage, and accidental damage was covered, so the insurer was liable.

Key takeaways: the insurer pays only when a covered risk is the proximate cause; in double insurance the insurers contribute in the ratio of sums insured; after paying, the insurer takes over the insured's rights (subrogation); and the insured must try to reduce the loss (mitigation). Contribution and subrogation both protect indemnity.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'Causa proxima' means:

    1. remote cause
    2. nearest cause
    3. joint cause
    4. first cause
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Causa proxima is the nearest, direct and dominant cause of a loss. The insurer is not liable for a remote cause.

  2. 2. A shop is insured with Insurer M for ₹3,00,000 and with Insurer N for ₹1,00,000. The actual loss is ₹80,000. How much does M pay?

    1. ₹20,000
    2. ₹40,000
    3. ₹60,000
    4. ₹80,000
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Total sum insured = ₹4,00,000. M's share = 3,00,000 ÷ 4,00,000 × 80,000 = 3/4 × 80,000 = ₹60,000. N pays the remaining ₹20,000.

  3. 3. After a claim is settled, the damaged goods become the property of the insurer. This follows the principle of:

    1. subrogation
    2. contribution
    3. mitigation
    4. utmost good faith
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Subrogation means the insurer steps into the shoes of the insured after paying, taking over the salvage and any rights against third parties.

  4. 4. A fire breaks out in an insured factory. The owner watches without calling the fire service or moving goods to safety. Which principle has he broken?

    1. Insurable interest
    2. Contribution
    3. Causa proxima
    4. Mitigation
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Mitigation requires the insured to take all reasonable steps to reduce the loss. Doing nothing breaks it, and the insurer may refuse to pay in full.

  5. 5. Which two principles exist mainly to make sure the insured does not receive more than the actual loss?

    1. Utmost good faith and insurable interest
    2. Contribution and subrogation
    3. Causa proxima and mitigation
    4. Insurable interest and mitigation
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Contribution limits the total from several insurers to the actual loss, and subrogation prevents the insured from keeping salvage after being paid. Both support indemnity.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery