• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Meaning of insurance and the principles of good faith, insurable interest and indemnity

Explain what insurance is, who the insurer and the insured are, and apply the principles of utmost good faith, insurable interest and indemnity to simple cases.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define insurance and name the two parties to an insurance contract.
  • Explain why co-operation is the basic idea behind insurance.
  • Apply utmost good faith, insurable interest and indemnity to a case, including the idea of a material fact.

Every business lives with uncertainty. A godown may catch fire, a lorry may meet with an accident, goods may be stolen. Nobody can say in advance whether such an event will happen to a particular trader. What can be said is that, out of thousands of traders, a few will suffer such losses every year. Insurance uses this fact: many people pay a small sum into a common fund, and the few who actually suffer a loss are compensated from it. The Tamil Nadu textbook describes insurance as the socialisation of risk, because the burden that would crush one person is spread over many.

Meaning of insurance

Insurance is a contract between two parties. The insurer (also called the assurer or underwriter) is the insurance company that promises to make good the loss arising from the risk covered. The insured (also called the assured) is the person whose risk is covered. In return for the promise, the insured pays a regular sum called the premium. The document containing the terms of the contract is the policy. The textbook also quotes a definition by John Magee that sees insurance as a plan in which many people join together and shift the risk of individuals onto the shoulders of all of them.

How insurance spreads risk

  1. Many people face a similar risk For example, many shopkeepers face the risk of fire.
  2. Each pays a premium The premiums form a common fund held by the insurer.
  3. A few suffer the loss Only some shops actually catch fire in a year.
  4. The fund compensates them The loss of a few is shared by all who paid premiums.
Co-operation is the basic principle of insurance.

Principle 1: utmost good faith

An insurance contract is a contract of utmost good faith (uberrimae fidei). Both parties must be completely honest. The insured must disclose every material fact, that is, any fact that would influence the insurer in deciding whether to accept the risk, what conditions to impose or what premium to charge. The insurer, in turn, must explain the terms of the policy fully. If a material fact is hidden, the insurer may refuse the claim later.

Principle 2: insurable interest

The insured must have an insurable interest in the thing or life insured. This means a money (pecuniary) interest: the insured must gain from the safety of the subject matter and lose financially if it is damaged. A trader has insurable interest in the stock of goods in his own shop; he has none in his neighbour's shop. Without this principle insurance would become a bet on someone else's misfortune.

Principle 3: indemnity

Indemnity means compensation against loss. The insured receives the actual loss, never more, and never more than the sum insured. The aim is to put the insured back in the position he was in before the loss, not to let him profit from it. The textbook points out that indemnity applies to property insurance only, because the loss caused by a person's death cannot be measured in money.

Compensation = the actual loss, subject to the sum insured as the upper limit. Insurance restores; it does not reward.

Worked example 1: applying indemnity

Made-up case: Kavitha insures her bookshop's stock against fire for ₹8,00,000. (a) A fire destroys stock worth ₹3,00,000. She can recover ₹3,00,000, the actual loss, because ₹3,00,000 is below the sum insured. (b) Suppose instead the fire destroys stock worth ₹10,00,000. The actual loss is more than the sum insured, so she can recover only ₹8,00,000, the policy limit. In neither case can she recover more than she lost.

Worked example 2: a hidden material fact

Made-up case: Mr. Selvam takes a fire policy on his small factory but does not tell the insurer that the factory stores large drums of a highly inflammable solvent. A fire later starts in the solvent store. Reasoning: the stored solvent clearly affects the chance of fire and therefore the premium, so it is a material fact. Hiding it breaks utmost good faith, and the insurer can refuse the claim.

Key takeaways: insurance is a contract in which the insurer promises to compensate the insured's loss in return for a premium; it rests on co-operation; the insured must disclose all material facts (utmost good faith), must have a money interest in the subject matter (insurable interest), and receives only the actual loss up to the sum insured (indemnity, for property insurance).

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In an insurance contract, the party who agrees to compensate the loss is called the:

    1. insured
    2. nominee
    3. insurer
    4. assured
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The insurer (also called the assurer or underwriter) promises to make good the loss. The insured or assured is the person whose risk is covered.

  2. 2. Which idea is described as the basic principle behind every insurance contract?

    1. Co-operation among many people who share risk
    2. Subrogation
    3. Profit for the insured
    4. Government guarantee
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Insurance began as a way of distributing risk among a group of people. Many contribute premiums so that the loss of a few is borne by all, which is co-operation.

  3. 3. A shop's stock is insured for ₹4,00,000 and a theft causes a loss of ₹1,20,000. Under the principle of indemnity the shopkeeper can recover:

    1. ₹4,00,000
    2. ₹2,80,000
    3. nothing, as the loss is small
    4. ₹1,20,000
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Indemnity pays the actual loss subject to the sum insured. The loss of ₹1,20,000 is below ₹4,00,000, so ₹1,20,000 is payable.

  4. 4. Ravi wants to insure his friend's car against accident. He cannot, mainly because:

    1. the car is too old
    2. he has no insurable interest in it
    3. indemnity does not apply to cars
    4. cars are covered only by life insurance
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Insurable interest means the insured would lose money if the subject matter were damaged. Ravi does not own the car, so he suffers no financial loss from its damage.

  5. 5. Why does the principle of indemnity not apply to life insurance?

    1. Because the loss caused by a person's death cannot be measured in money
    2. Because life insurance has no premium
    3. Because life policies are never paid
    4. Because the insurer is the government
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Indemnity means paying the exact loss. The value of a human life cannot be measured, so a life policy pays the agreed sum instead of an assessed loss.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery