• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Arguments for and against social responsibility

Explain the textbook's arguments in favour of social responsibility and the critics' arguments against it, and form a balanced view on a case.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the eight arguments for social responsibility.
  • Explain the nine arguments against it.
  • Weigh both sides in a given case.

Not everyone agrees that business should take on social responsibility. Supporters say it is good for society and for business; critics say a business should stick to making profit and leave social work to others. A good commerce student should be able to present both sides.

Arguments for social responsibility

  1. Protection of stakeholders' interests: a business is a coalition of shareholders, customers, employees, suppliers and others, so it should serve all, not owners alone.
  2. Promotion of society: business is a sub-system of society and draws its inputs from it, so responsible behaviour keeps the relationship going.
  3. Assessment of social impact: business decisions affect society's interests and values, so it should compensate for harm it causes.
  4. Organised social power: large corporations hold great power, which may be misused unless balanced by responsibility.
  5. Legitimacy: it is in the enlightened self-interest of business; improving social life brings better customers, employees and neighbours.
  6. Competence: managers have proved their ability in solving economic problems, and society expects them to apply it to social problems too.
  7. Professional conduct: professional managers must show social sensitivity and follow codes of conduct and ethics.
  8. Public opinion: a good public image is a valuable asset, built by activities such as maintaining parks or running awareness camps.

Arguments against social responsibility

  1. Lack of conceptual clarity: the idea is vague and has no agreed meaning or scope.
  2. Dilution of economic goals: business is an economic institution; other goals may weaken its viability.
  3. Lack of social skill: managers are not trained in social affairs; government and non-governmental agencies handle them better.
  4. Burden on consumers: social spending raises costs, passed on as higher prices or borne by owners, which critics call 'taxation without representation'.
  5. Responsibility without power: business has economic, not social, power; letting it into social affairs may impose its own values on society.
  6. Misuse of resources: managerial time and corporate resources are diverted to social programmes.
  7. Lack of a yardstick: profit is a clear measure for decisions; adding social goals makes decisions complex and controversial.
  8. Improper role: the proper role of business is to earn the best return within law and ethics, leaving social service to others.
  9. Overloading: business already serves society by supplying goods, creating jobs, developing technology and paying taxes.

The debate in brief

  • For
    • Serve all stakeholders
    • Business is part of society
    • Balance power with responsibility
    • Good image and legitimacy
  • Against
    • Vague concept, no yardstick
    • Dilutes profit goal
    • Lack of social skill
    • Burden on consumers

'Taxation without representation': when a firm spends on social causes and raises prices, customers pay for causes they never voted for. This is the critics' sharpest point.

Worked example 1: the burden-on-consumers argument

Made-up figures: a soap maker sells 10,00,000 cakes a year and decides to spend ₹5,00,000 on a village school. If it passes the whole cost to buyers, the increase per cake = 5,00,000 ÷ 10,00,000 = ₹0.50. Reasoning: critics say each buyer has been made to pay 50 paise for a cause he did not choose. Supporters reply that the amount is small and the firm gains goodwill and better future workers; the firm could also bear part of the cost from profit.

Worked example 2: classify the statement

Made-up statements: (a) 'Nobody can agree what social responsibility means.' (b) 'A big company that can shut a town's only factory must use its power carefully.' (c) 'Our managers know steel, not public health.' Answer: (a) against: lack of conceptual clarity; (b) for: organised social power; (c) against: lack of social skill.

Key takeaways: supporters argue from stakeholders, the business-society link, social impact, power, legitimacy, competence, professional conduct and public opinion; critics argue from vagueness, diluted profit goals, lack of skill, burden on consumers, responsibility without power, diversion of resources, lack of a yardstick, improper role and overloading.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'Business is a sub-system of society and draws its inputs from it.' This is an argument:

    1. against social responsibility: lack of social skill
    2. for social responsibility: promotion of society
    3. against social responsibility: overloading
    4. for social responsibility: lack of yardstick
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook's 'promotion of society' argument says business depends on society for inputs, so responsible behaviour is needed to sustain the relationship.

  2. 2. Critics say social spending is 'taxation without representation' because:

    1. the government taxes the firm
    2. shareholders vote on every expense
    3. the costs are passed to consumers as higher prices without their say
    4. workers pay income tax
    Show answer

    Answer: C. If social costs raise prices, consumers pay for causes they did not choose, which critics compare to being taxed without representation.

  3. 3. Which is an argument FOR social responsibility?

    1. Protection of all stakeholders' interests
    2. Dilution of economic goals
    3. Lack of a yardstick
    4. Improper role of business
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Protecting the interests of shareholders, customers, employees, suppliers and others is an argument in favour. The others are critics' arguments.

  4. 4. 'Profit gives a clear measure for decisions; social goals make decisions complex and controversial.' This argument is called:

    1. legitimacy
    2. competence
    3. public opinion
    4. lack of yardstick
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The lack of yardstick argument says profitability is the common criterion for decisions and adding social goals complicates decision-making.

  5. 5. A firm sells 4,00,000 units a year and adds ₹2,00,000 of social spending entirely to its prices. The increase per unit is:

    1. ₹2
    2. ₹0.50
    3. ₹0.20
    4. ₹5
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Increase per unit = 2,00,000 ÷ 4,00,000 = ₹0.50, that is 50 paise per unit.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery