- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Arguments for and against social responsibility
Explain the textbook's arguments in favour of social responsibility and the critics' arguments against it, and form a balanced view on a case.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the eight arguments for social responsibility.
- Explain the nine arguments against it.
- Weigh both sides in a given case.
Not everyone agrees that business should take on social responsibility. Supporters say it is good for society and for business; critics say a business should stick to making profit and leave social work to others. A good commerce student should be able to present both sides.
Arguments for social responsibility
- Protection of stakeholders' interests: a business is a coalition of shareholders, customers, employees, suppliers and others, so it should serve all, not owners alone.
- Promotion of society: business is a sub-system of society and draws its inputs from it, so responsible behaviour keeps the relationship going.
- Assessment of social impact: business decisions affect society's interests and values, so it should compensate for harm it causes.
- Organised social power: large corporations hold great power, which may be misused unless balanced by responsibility.
- Legitimacy: it is in the enlightened self-interest of business; improving social life brings better customers, employees and neighbours.
- Competence: managers have proved their ability in solving economic problems, and society expects them to apply it to social problems too.
- Professional conduct: professional managers must show social sensitivity and follow codes of conduct and ethics.
- Public opinion: a good public image is a valuable asset, built by activities such as maintaining parks or running awareness camps.
Arguments against social responsibility
- Lack of conceptual clarity: the idea is vague and has no agreed meaning or scope.
- Dilution of economic goals: business is an economic institution; other goals may weaken its viability.
- Lack of social skill: managers are not trained in social affairs; government and non-governmental agencies handle them better.
- Burden on consumers: social spending raises costs, passed on as higher prices or borne by owners, which critics call 'taxation without representation'.
- Responsibility without power: business has economic, not social, power; letting it into social affairs may impose its own values on society.
- Misuse of resources: managerial time and corporate resources are diverted to social programmes.
- Lack of a yardstick: profit is a clear measure for decisions; adding social goals makes decisions complex and controversial.
- Improper role: the proper role of business is to earn the best return within law and ethics, leaving social service to others.
- Overloading: business already serves society by supplying goods, creating jobs, developing technology and paying taxes.
The debate in brief
-
For
- Serve all stakeholders
- Business is part of society
- Balance power with responsibility
- Good image and legitimacy
-
Against
- Vague concept, no yardstick
- Dilutes profit goal
- Lack of social skill
- Burden on consumers
'Taxation without representation': when a firm spends on social causes and raises prices, customers pay for causes they never voted for. This is the critics' sharpest point.
Worked example 1: the burden-on-consumers argument
Made-up figures: a soap maker sells 10,00,000 cakes a year and decides to spend ₹5,00,000 on a village school. If it passes the whole cost to buyers, the increase per cake = 5,00,000 ÷ 10,00,000 = ₹0.50. Reasoning: critics say each buyer has been made to pay 50 paise for a cause he did not choose. Supporters reply that the amount is small and the firm gains goodwill and better future workers; the firm could also bear part of the cost from profit.
Worked example 2: classify the statement
Made-up statements: (a) 'Nobody can agree what social responsibility means.' (b) 'A big company that can shut a town's only factory must use its power carefully.' (c) 'Our managers know steel, not public health.' Answer: (a) against: lack of conceptual clarity; (b) for: organised social power; (c) against: lack of social skill.
Key takeaways: supporters argue from stakeholders, the business-society link, social impact, power, legitimacy, competence, professional conduct and public opinion; critics argue from vagueness, diluted profit goals, lack of skill, burden on consumers, responsibility without power, diversion of resources, lack of a yardstick, improper role and overloading.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Business is a sub-system of society and draws its inputs from it.' This is an argument:
- against social responsibility: lack of social skill
- for social responsibility: promotion of society
- against social responsibility: overloading
- for social responsibility: lack of yardstick
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook's 'promotion of society' argument says business depends on society for inputs, so responsible behaviour is needed to sustain the relationship.
-
2. Critics say social spending is 'taxation without representation' because:
- the government taxes the firm
- shareholders vote on every expense
- the costs are passed to consumers as higher prices without their say
- workers pay income tax
Show answer
Answer: C. If social costs raise prices, consumers pay for causes they did not choose, which critics compare to being taxed without representation.
-
3. Which is an argument FOR social responsibility?
- Protection of all stakeholders' interests
- Dilution of economic goals
- Lack of a yardstick
- Improper role of business
Show answer
Answer: A. Protecting the interests of shareholders, customers, employees, suppliers and others is an argument in favour. The others are critics' arguments.
-
4. 'Profit gives a clear measure for decisions; social goals make decisions complex and controversial.' This argument is called:
- legitimacy
- competence
- public opinion
- lack of yardstick
Show answer
Answer: D. The lack of yardstick argument says profitability is the common criterion for decisions and adding social goals complicates decision-making.
-
5. A firm sells 4,00,000 units a year and adds ₹2,00,000 of social spending entirely to its prices. The increase per unit is:
- ₹2
- ₹0.50
- ₹0.20
- ₹5
Show answer
Answer: B. Increase per unit = 2,00,000 ÷ 4,00,000 = ₹0.50, that is 50 paise per unit.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.