• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Kinds of social responsibility: economic, legal, ethical and discretionary

Describe the four kinds of social responsibility in the textbook, explain how much choice each involves, and classify business actions into the right kind.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Name and explain the four kinds of social responsibility.
  • Explain the amount of choice (discretion) involved in each.
  • Classify given actions into the correct kind.

Social responsibility is not one single duty. The textbook divides it into four kinds. They range from what a business must do simply to exist, to what it is required to do by law, to what society expects without any law, to what it chooses to do purely of its own free will.

1. Economic responsibility

A business is first an economic unit. Its primary social responsibility is to produce the goods and services society wants and sell them at a profit. A business that fails at this cannot pay workers, suppliers, lenders or taxes, and cannot do any good at all. There is little discretion here: every business must perform it.

2. Legal responsibility

Every business must operate within the laws of the land. Since laws are made for the good of society, a law-abiding enterprise is also a socially responsible one. Examples include following rules on safety, pollution, labelling, weights and measures, and paying taxes honestly.

3. Ethical responsibility

This is behaviour that society expects but that is not written into law. The textbook's illustration is respecting people's religious sentiments and dignity when advertising a product. There is an element of voluntary action: no court will punish the firm, but society will judge it.

4. Discretionary responsibility

This is a purely voluntary obligation that a business takes on by its own choice, such as donating to educational institutions or helping people affected by floods or earthquakes. The textbook also mentions here the management's duty to safeguard invested capital by avoiding speculation and choosing sound ventures.

From required to voluntary

  1. Economic Must do: produce wanted goods and earn profit.
  2. Legal Required by law.
  3. Ethical Expected by society, not written in law.
  4. Discretionary Purely voluntary, by the firm's own choice.
Discretion (freedom of choice) increases from left to right.
KindSource of the dutyExample
EconomicThe nature of businessSelling good-quality bicycles at a profit
LegalLaws of the landFitting fire-safety equipment required by rules
EthicalSociety's expectationsNot using a sacred symbol to sell shoes
DiscretionaryThe firm's own choiceFunding a library in a village school

Economic: must. Legal: required. Ethical: expected. Discretionary: chosen.

Worked example 1: classify the actions

Made-up actions of a cement company: (a) it pays GST on its sales; (b) it sends trucks and food to a flood-hit district; (c) it refuses to advertise using a misleading 'doctor recommended' claim, though no rule stops it; (d) it improves its kilns to cut costs and stay profitable. Answer: (a) legal; (b) discretionary; (c) ethical; (d) economic.

Worked example 2: why economic comes first

Made-up figures: a firm earns revenue of ₹50 lakh and has costs of ₹46 lakh, so profit = 50 − 46 = ₹4 lakh. It plans to spend ₹1 lakh on a health camp. If costs rise to ₹52 lakh, profit becomes 50 − 52 = −₹2 lakh, a loss. Reasoning: with a loss, the firm can neither fund the camp nor pay its other obligations for long. This shows why the textbook calls economic responsibility the primary one: the other kinds depend on the firm staying viable.

Key takeaways: the four kinds are economic (produce and sell at a profit; little discretion), legal (obey the laws), ethical (meet society's unwritten expectations; partly voluntary) and discretionary (purely voluntary acts such as donations and disaster relief).

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which kind of social responsibility involves the least discretion?

    1. Discretionary
    2. Ethical
    3. Economic
    4. Charitable
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Economic responsibility, producing what society wants and selling it at a profit, must be performed by every business, so there is little discretion.

  2. 2. Respecting people's religious sentiments in advertisements, though no law requires it, is an example of:

    1. ethical responsibility
    2. legal responsibility
    3. economic responsibility
    4. no responsibility
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook gives this as its example of ethical responsibility: behaviour society expects that is not codified in law.

  3. 3. A company donates money to a school library of its own free will. This is:

    1. legal responsibility
    2. economic responsibility
    3. ethical responsibility
    4. discretionary responsibility
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Charitable contributions to educational institutions are a purely voluntary obligation, which the textbook calls discretionary responsibility.

  4. 4. Installing pollution-control equipment because the law requires it is mainly:

    1. discretionary responsibility
    2. legal responsibility
    3. ethical responsibility
    4. trusteeship
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Acting because the law of the land requires it is legal responsibility. Doing more than the law requires could be ethical or discretionary.

  5. 5. Arrange from least voluntary to most voluntary:

    1. Discretionary, ethical, legal, economic
    2. Legal, economic, discretionary, ethical
    3. Economic, legal, ethical, discretionary
    4. Ethical, legal, economic, discretionary
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Economic is basic to every business, legal is required by law, ethical is expected but not compulsory, and discretionary is purely voluntary.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery