- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Classification of contracts: validity, formation and performance
Classify contracts by validity (valid, void, voidable, illegal, unenforceable), by formation (express, implied, quasi, tacit) and by performance (executed, executory, unilateral, bilateral).
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish valid, void, voidable, illegal and unenforceable contracts.
- Explain express, implied, quasi and tacit contracts with examples.
- Classify a contract as executed, executory, unilateral or bilateral.
Not every contract looks the same. Some are spoken, some are understood from conduct, some are created by law itself; some are finished, others are still waiting to be performed. The textbook groups contracts on three bases. Knowing the groups lets you name a contract quickly and predict how the law will treat it.
Classification of contracts
-
On the basis of validity
- Valid
- Void
- Voidable
- Illegal
- Unenforceable
-
On the basis of formation
- Express
- Implied
- Quasi
- Tacit
-
On the basis of performance
- Executed
- Executory
- Unilateral
- Bilateral
I. On the basis of validity
- Valid contract: has every essential of a valid contract, so it is fully enforceable.
- Void contract (Section 2(j)): a contract that ceases to be enforceable by law. A valid contract may later become void, for instance when its performance becomes impossible.
- Voidable contract (Section 2(i)): enforceable at the option of one or more parties but not at the option of the other. It results when consent is caused by coercion, undue influence, fraud or misrepresentation; the injured party may affirm it or set it aside.
- Illegal contract: forbidden by law, such as one immoral or opposed to public policy. All illegal agreements are void, but not all void agreements are illegal. Parties to an illegal agreement may be punished; parties to a merely void agreement are not. An illegal agreement is void from the very beginning.
- Unenforceable contract: valid in substance but cannot be enforced because of a technical defect, such as absence of required writing or the expiry of the time limit for a suit. If the parties perform it, it stands, but a court will not compel them.
II. On the basis of formation
- Express contract (Section 9): proposal and acceptance are made in words, spoken or written.
- Implied contract: made by conduct rather than words. Getting into a public bus implies a promise to pay the fare.
- Quasi contract: not really a contract but an obligation imposed by law, on the principle that no one should be allowed to enrich himself unjustly at the expense of another. Example: a trader who receives goods delivered to him by mistake must return them or pay for them.
- Tacit contract: inferred from the conduct of the parties, as when cash is drawn from an ATM or goods are sold by the fall of the hammer at an auction.
III. On the basis of performance
- Executed contract: both parties have fully performed their obligations.
- Executory contract: both parties have still to perform.
- Unilateral contract: one party has performed and only the other's obligation is outstanding.
- Bilateral contract: both parties commit to perform their respective promises; there are promises on both sides.
| Point | Void agreement | Illegal agreement |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Wider: every illegal agreement is void | Narrower: not every void agreement is illegal |
| Punishment | No punishment to the parties | Parties may be punished |
| From when | May be valid at first and become void later | Void from the very beginning |
Worked example 1: name the contract
(a) Deepa (made-up) pays ₹45,000 and the dealer hands over a scooter on the spot. (b) Deepa agrees today to pay on 15 June; the dealer agrees to deliver on 20 June. (c) Deepa pays ₹45,000 today; delivery is next week. Answers: (a) both have performed: executed. (b) both still to perform: executory. (c) Deepa has performed, the dealer has not: unilateral in the textbook's sense.
Worked example 2: void, voidable or illegal?
(a) Two persons agree to trade in banned drugs. (b) A buyer is tricked by a false statement that a used car has never had an accident. Reasoning: (a) the object is forbidden by law, so the agreement is illegal and therefore void from the start, and the parties may be punished. (b) consent was caused by fraud, so the contract is voidable at the option of the buyer; until he avoids it, it stays in force.
Key takeaways: by validity, contracts are valid, void, voidable, illegal or unenforceable; by formation, express, implied, quasi (imposed by law against unjust enrichment) or tacit; by performance, executed, executory, unilateral or bilateral.
Check your understanding
-
1. A contract enforceable at the option of one party but not the other is:
- void
- illegal
- voidable
- executed
Show answer
Answer: C. Section 2(i) defines a voidable contract this way. It arises from coercion, undue influence, fraud or misrepresentation.
-
2. A quasi contract is based on the principle that:
- no person should enrich himself unjustly at another's expense
- all contracts must be in writing
- a minor's agreement is void
- acceptance must be absolute
Show answer
Answer: A. A quasi contract is an obligation imposed by law, not made by agreement, to prevent unjust enrichment.
-
3. Drawing cash from an ATM is given in the textbook as an example of:
- a quasi contract
- an executory contract
- an illegal contract
- a tacit contract
Show answer
Answer: D. A tacit contract is inferred from conduct, such as using an ATM or a sale by the fall of the hammer at an auction.
-
4. Which statement about void and illegal agreements is correct?
- All void agreements are illegal
- All illegal agreements are void
- Parties to a void agreement are always punished
- Illegal agreements are valid until a court says otherwise
Show answer
Answer: B. Illegal agreements are void from the beginning, but a void agreement need not be illegal. Only illegal agreements attract punishment.
-
5. A contract in which both parties have still to perform their promises is:
- executed
- unilateral
- executory
- tacit
Show answer
Answer: C. An executory contract is one where the obligations on both sides are yet to be performed.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.