• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Essentials of a valid contract (2): capacity, certainty, possibility and formalities

Explain the remaining essentials of a valid contract: capacity of parties, certainty of terms, possibility of performance, not being declared void and legal formalities, and compare contract with agreement.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State who is competent to contract under Section 11 and who is not.
  • Explain certainty of terms (Section 29) and possibility of performance (Section 56).
  • Explain legal formalities and prove that all contracts are agreements but not all agreements are contracts.

Lesson 3 covered the first five essentials. An agreement can pass all of them and still fail if, say, one party is a minor or the terms are vague. This lesson completes the list of ten and ends with the comparison of contract and agreement that the textbook asks for.

6. Capacity of parties (Section 11)

The parties must have the legal ability to contract. Every person is competent who (i) has attained the age of majority under the law he is subject to, (ii) is of sound mind, and (iii) is not disqualified by any law. The textbook names persons who cannot contract: alien enemies, foreign sovereigns and accredited representatives of a foreign state, insolvents and convicts. An agreement with a minor is void.

7. Certainty of terms (Section 29)

The meaning of the agreement must be certain or capable of being made certain. If a person who owns several houses says only 'I will sell you my house', no court can tell which house is meant, so the agreement fails for uncertainty.

8. Possibility of performance (Section 56)

An agreement to do an act that is impossible in itself is void. A promise to bring a dead person back to life, or to run from Chennai to Madurai in ten minutes, can never be performed, so the law will not enforce it.

9. Not expressly declared void

The law itself declares some agreements void or illegal. Even if every other essential is present, such an agreement cannot become a contract.

10. Necessary legal formalities

A contract may be oral or written. But where a law requires a particular contract to be written, registered or attested, those formalities must be completed, or the contract is not enforceable. The textbook's example: a promise to pay a time-barred debt must be in writing.

Ten essentials of a valid contract

  • About the agreement
    • Offer and acceptance
    • Intention to create legal relationship
    • Certainty of terms
    • Possibility of performance
  • About the parties
    • Capacity of parties
    • Free consent
  • About legality
    • Lawful consideration
    • Lawful object
    • Not expressly declared void
    • Legal formalities
As listed in the Tamil Nadu textbook.

All contracts are agreements, but not all agreements are contracts

Agreements fall into two groups: those enforceable by law, where every essential is present (these are contracts), and those not enforceable, where some essential is missing. So 'agreement' is the wider word.

Contract and agreement compared (bases from the textbook)
BasisContractAgreement
DefinitionAn agreement enforceable by lawEvery promise or set of promises forming consideration for each other
EnforceabilityAlways enforceableNot every agreement is enforceable
Inter-relationshipIncludes an agreementDoes not necessarily include a contract
ValidityOnly legal agreements are contractsMay be legal or illegal
Legal obligationAlways creates a legal obligationNeed not create a legal obligation

Every contract is an agreement; an agreement becomes a contract only when all the essentials are present.

Worked example 1: checking capacity

Arjun, aged 16 (made-up), agrees to buy a used laptop from Nisha, aged 25, for ₹12,000. Step 1: offer, acceptance and consideration are present. Step 2: check capacity under Section 11: Arjun has not attained majority. Conclusion: the agreement is void; it is not a contract, whatever the price.

Worked example 2: the time-barred debt

Prakash (made-up) owed Latha ₹10,000 many years ago, and the period for recovering it through court has expired. He now says, 'I will pay you next month.' Reasoning: a promise to pay a time-barred debt is enforceable only if it is in writing (and signed). An oral promise alone cannot be enforced. If Prakash signs a written promise, the formality is met and Latha can enforce it.

Key takeaways: parties must be of majority age, sound mind and not disqualified; terms must be certain; performance must be possible; the agreement must not be declared void; required formalities must be followed; all contracts are agreements, but only agreements with every essential are contracts.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. X owns four cars and tells Y, 'I agree to sell you my car.' The agreement fails for lack of:

    1. free consent
    2. certainty of terms
    3. capacity
    4. lawful object
    Show answer

    Answer: B. No one can tell which of the four cars is meant, so the terms are not certain (Section 29).

  2. 2. Which of these persons is competent to contract under Section 11?

    1. A minor
    2. A person of unsound mind
    3. An adult of sound mind not disqualified by law
    4. An alien enemy
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Competence needs majority, sound mind and no legal disqualification. The other three lack one of these.

  3. 3. An agreement to discover a new planet for a fee is void because:

    1. the act is impossible in itself
    2. it is not written
    3. there is no consideration
    4. it lacks free consent
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Section 56 makes an agreement to do an act impossible in itself void. A fee is consideration, so that is not the problem.

  4. 4. A promise to pay a time-barred debt is enforceable only if it is:

    1. made before witnesses orally
    2. made by a minor
    3. made at a bank
    4. in writing
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook gives this as an example of a legal formality: such a promise must be in writing.

  5. 5. Which statement is correct?

    1. All agreements are contracts
    2. All contracts are agreements, but not all agreements are contracts
    3. Contracts may be illegal
    4. Agreements always create legal obligations
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A contract is an agreement plus enforceability. Agreements missing an essential are not contracts, so agreement is the wider term.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery