- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Indirect tax and how it differs from direct tax
Explain the meaning of indirect tax with examples, and compare direct and indirect taxes on meaning, incidence and impact, evasion, inflation, shiftability and examples.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define indirect tax and give examples.
- Explain 'incidence' and 'impact' of a tax and why an indirect tax can be shifted.
- Compare direct and indirect taxes on the six bases in the textbook.
Every time we buy a packet of biscuits or pay a mobile bill, part of what we pay is tax, even though we never fill in a tax form. That is an indirect tax. Chapter 32 dealt with direct taxes such as income tax; this chapter turns to indirect taxes, and above all to the Goods and Services Tax (GST). As in the previous chapter, rates and limits are given only as the textbook states them; they are changed by law and are not current rates.
Meaning of indirect tax
An indirect tax is levied on goods and services. It is collected from the buyers by the sellers and paid by the sellers to the Government. It is called indirect because the buyer, who finally bears it, does not pay it to the Government himself; it reaches the Government indirectly through the seller. The textbook's examples are GST and excise duty; customs duty on imports is another tax of this kind named among the chapter's key terms.
How the tax reaches the Government
-
Direct tax (for example, income tax)
- The taxpayer earns income
- The taxpayer pays the tax himself to the Government
- The burden stays with him
-
Indirect tax (for example, GST)
- The consumer pays the tax as part of the price
- The seller collects it
- The seller pays it to the Government
Incidence, impact and shifting
Two words help here. The impact of a tax is on the person who first pays it to the Government. The incidence is on the person who finally bears its burden. For a direct tax, both fall on the same person. For an indirect tax, the impact is on the seller but the incidence is on the consumer, because the seller shifts the tax forward in the price.
| Basis | Direct taxes | Indirect taxes |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Levied on the income or wealth of a person and paid by that person to the Government | Levied on goods or services, collected from buyers by the seller and paid by the seller |
| Incidence and impact | Fall on the same person | Fall on different persons: imposed on the seller, borne by the consumer |
| Evasion | Tax evasion is possible | Tax evasion is more difficult |
| Inflation | Helps in reducing inflation | Contributes to inflation |
| Shiftability | Cannot be shifted to others | Can be shifted to others |
| Examples | Income tax, wealth tax | GST, excise duty |
On evasion and inflation, these are the textbook's judgements. The reasoning behind them: an indirect tax is collected at the point of sale, inside the price, so it is harder to avoid; and because it raises prices, it can add to inflation, whereas a direct tax reduces people's spending power and so can help restrain rising prices.
Direct tax: impact and incidence on the same person, cannot be shifted. Indirect tax: impact on the seller, incidence on the buyer, can be shifted.
Worked example 1: tracing impact and incidence
A stationery shop sells a school bag priced ₹800 before tax. Suppose (made-up rate) an indirect tax of 5% applies. Working: tax = 5% of ₹800 = 0.05 × 800 = ₹40; the buyer pays ₹800 + ₹40 = ₹840. The shop sends ₹40 to the Government. Impact: on the shop, which pays the Government. Incidence: on the buyer, who bore the ₹40 in the price. The tax has been shifted.
Worked example 2: classify each tax
(a) A doctor pays tax on her annual fee income. (b) A family pays tax included in a restaurant bill. (c) A factory pays duty on goods manufactured and includes it in its selling price. Answers: (a) direct: levied on income and paid by the earner, cannot be shifted. (b) indirect: on a service, collected by the restaurant. (c) indirect: excise duty, passed on to buyers in the price.
Key takeaways: an indirect tax is levied on goods and services, collected from buyers by sellers and paid by sellers to the Government; its impact and incidence fall on different persons and it can be shifted; the textbook also says direct taxes can be evaded more easily and help reduce inflation, while indirect taxes are harder to evade and add to inflation.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these is an indirect tax?
- Income tax
- Wealth tax
- GST
- Capital gains tax
Show answer
Answer: C. GST is levied on goods and services and collected by sellers from buyers, so it is indirect. The other three are direct taxes.
-
2. For an indirect tax, the incidence falls on:
- the consumer who finally bears it
- the Government
- the seller only
- the bank
Show answer
Answer: A. The seller pays the tax to the Government (impact) but recovers it from the buyer in the price, so the final burden (incidence) is on the consumer.
-
3. According to the textbook, which statement is correct?
- Direct taxes can be shifted to others
- Indirect taxes help reduce inflation
- Tax evasion is impossible for direct taxes
- Indirect taxes can be shifted to others
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook's comparison says indirect taxes can be shifted, direct taxes cannot; it also says indirect taxes contribute to inflation and direct taxes can be evaded.
-
4. A pen costs ₹150 before tax and a made-up 12% indirect tax applies. The buyer pays:
- ₹162
- ₹168
- ₹150
- ₹138
Show answer
Answer: B. Tax = 12% of ₹150 = 0.12 × 150 = ₹18. Price paid = ₹150 + ₹18 = ₹168.
-
5. For a direct tax, the impact and incidence:
- fall on different persons
- fall on the Government
- fall on the same person
- fall on the seller only
Show answer
Answer: C. A direct tax is imposed on and paid by the same person, so its impact and incidence coincide.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.