- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Objectives, benefits and disadvantages of GST
Explain the objectives of GST, how input tax credit removes the cascading effect, the benefits the textbook lists for the country, business and consumers, and the criticisms it reports.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the objectives of GST as given in the textbook.
- Explain the cascading effect and show with numbers how input tax credit removes it.
- List benefits of GST to the country, business and consumers, and the criticisms the textbook reports.
Any big reform is judged by what it set out to do and by what happened. The Tamil Nadu textbook presents both sides of GST: its aims and benefits, and the criticisms raised against it. Board answers expect both lists, written in a balanced way.
Objectives of GST
- To create a common national market with uniform tax: the textbook's slogan is 'One Nation, One Tax, One Market'.
- To eliminate the cascading effect of taxes by allowing set-off of taxes paid earlier as input tax credit.
- To boost exports by refunding GST paid on inputs, so that exports carry no tax.
- To widen the tax base by bringing more taxpayers in and to increase tax revenue.
- To simplify tax returns through common forms and fewer visits to tax offices.
- To provide online payment and filing through the Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN), the information technology system created for GST.
Cascading effect and input tax credit
The cascading effect means 'tax on tax': when each stage is taxed on a price that already includes earlier tax, the tax keeps piling up. Input tax credit solves this: a business subtracts the tax it paid on its purchases from the tax it collects on its sales, and pays only the difference.
Worked example 1: with and without input tax credit
Made-up rate 10%. A manufacturer sells goods worth ₹100 to a retailer, who adds a margin of ₹20. Without credit: manufacturer charges 10% of 100 = ₹10, so the retailer pays ₹110. The retailer adds ₹20, giving ₹130, and charges 10% of 130 = ₹13. Consumer pays ₹143. Total tax = 10 + 13 = ₹23: the manufacturer's ₹100 of value has been taxed twice (₹10 + ₹10), ₹1 is tax on the earlier ₹10 tax, and only ₹2 is tax on the retailer's own margin. With credit: the retailer's value is 100 + 20 = ₹120; tax charged = 10% of 120 = ₹12; credit for the ₹10 already paid, so it pays only 12 − 10 = ₹2. Consumer pays 120 + 12 = ₹132. Total tax = 10 + 2 = ₹12 = 10% of the final value. Saving to the consumer: 143 − 132 = ₹11.
Benefits of GST (as listed in the textbook)
Benefits of GST
-
To the country
- A unified national market that can attract investment
- Parity between imported and Indian goods through IGST
- Growth in manufacturing, exports and employment
- More taxpayers and revenue
- Less tax evasion and rate arbitrage between states
-
To business
- Simpler system: the textbook says 17 taxes were replaced
- Input tax credit lowers cost and supports Make in India
- Common procedures and classification bring certainty
- GSTN portal reduces paperwork and contact with officials
- Uniform prices make expansion to all states easier
-
To consumers
- Input tax credit can lower prices
- Small retailers exempted, so purchases from them may cost less
Disadvantages of GST (criticisms reported in the textbook)
- Some economists predicted that GST would raise the cost of new homes and reduce demand in the real estate market.
- Critics said CGST and SGST were only new names for older taxes such as central excise, service tax, VAT and CST, so the number of tax layers was not really reduced.
- Some retail products, such as garments, were expected to become costlier where earlier tax had been low.
- The aviation industry was expected to face a higher tax on airfares.
- Moving to a new system involved teething troubles and learning for everyone involved.
These were criticisms and predictions made around the time GST was introduced, as the textbook reports them; they are not measured results.
Input tax credit: tax payable = tax on sales − tax already paid on purchases. It removes tax on tax.
Worked example 2: computing tax payable after credit
A wholesaler (made-up) paid ₹3,600 GST on its purchases in a month and collected ₹5,400 GST on its sales. Tax payable = 5,400 − 3,600 = ₹1,800. Check: 3,600 + 1,800 = 5,400, so the Government receives in all exactly the tax on the wholesaler's sales, and no tax is charged twice.
Key takeaways: GST aims at one common market, no cascading, tax-free exports, a wider tax base, simpler returns and online processes through GSTN; input tax credit means each business pays only the tax on its own value addition; the textbook lists benefits for the country, business and consumers, and reports criticisms about real estate, tax layers, some prices, aviation and transition troubles.
Check your understanding
-
1. The 'cascading effect' of taxes means:
- tax charged only once
- tax being charged on an amount that already includes earlier tax
- tax refunded on exports
- tax shared between Centre and States
Show answer
Answer: B. Cascading is tax on tax: each stage is taxed on a price that includes previous tax. Input tax credit removes it.
-
2. GST paid on purchases ₹2,000; GST collected on sales ₹3,500. Tax payable after input tax credit is:
- ₹5,500
- ₹3,500
- ₹2,000
- ₹1,500
Show answer
Answer: D. Tax payable = tax on sales − input tax credit = ₹3,500 − ₹2,000 = ₹1,500.
-
3. The slogan the textbook links with the first objective of GST is:
- One Nation, One Tax, One Market
- Make in India
- Digital India
- Swachh Bharat
Show answer
Answer: A. The foremost objective is a common market with uniform tax: 'One Nation, One Tax, One Market'.
-
4. The IT system created for the operation of GST is:
- CBDT
- GST Council
- GSTN
- CBIC
Show answer
Answer: C. The Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN) is the IT system for registration, returns and payments under GST.
-
5. Which of these is a criticism of GST reported in the textbook?
- It refunds tax on exports
- It allows input tax credit
- It creates a common market
- CGST and SGST are only new names for older taxes
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook reports the criticism that CGST and SGST simply renamed older taxes like excise, service tax, VAT and CST. The other three are objectives or benefits.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.