- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Meaning of economics, its nature, and the wealth and welfare definitions
Explain where the word economics comes from, why it has many definitions, and state and criticise Adam Smith's wealth definition and Alfred Marshall's welfare definition.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Give the Greek origin of the word economics and say who renamed political economy as economics.
- Explain why a growing social science has many definitions, and name the four stages the Tamil Nadu textbook uses.
- State the main ideas of Adam Smith's wealth definition and Alfred Marshall's welfare definition, with their criticisms.
Before studying any subject seriously, it helps to know what its name means, what it covers and how its thinkers have described it. Economics has been described in many ways over two and a half centuries. Each description reflects the problems people cared about at that time. This lesson begins that story with the two oldest definitions in the chapter.
Where the word comes from
The word economics goes back to the Ancient Greek oikonomikos: oikos means household and nemein means management (also custom or law). So the word originally meant management of households. For a long time the subject was called Political Economy; the Tamil Nadu textbook notes that Alfred Marshall popularised the new name Economics in the late 19th century.
Nature of economics: why so many definitions?
The nature of a subject means what it contains and why. We understand the nature of economics by studying the definitions given by leading economists. There are so many of them that J. M. Keynes remarked that political economy had almost strangled itself with definitions. The textbook takes a positive view: many definitions are a sign that the science is growing, and that scholars are free to look at it afresh. Each definition stresses one idea that was important at its stage of growth.
Four definitions, four stages of growth
- Wealth: Adam Smith Classical era; book published 1776.
- Welfare: Alfred Marshall Neo-classical era; book published 1890.
- Scarcity: Lionel Robbins The New Age; book published 1932.
- Growth: Paul Samuelson Modern Age; book published 1948.
Wealth definition: Adam Smith (classical era)
Adam Smith (1723-1790) wrote An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776) and called economics the science of wealth. His main ideas, in brief:
- Economics explains how a nation's wealth is created and increased.
- Every person is moved by self-interest, working for his own gain; in doing so he is guided, as if by an invisible hand, towards what also benefits society.
- Division of labour raises the quantity of output.
- Strong competition improves products, and an active supply side brings goods to consumers at the lowest price.
The publication of The Wealth of Nations is often called the effective birth of economics as a separate discipline.
Criticism. Smith's economics is about wealth-getting and wealth-spending, and it treats material wealth as an end in itself, leaving out human welfare. His definition came at a time when religious and spiritual values were held high, so critics such as Carlyle and Ruskin called economics a dismal science that taught selfishness.
Welfare definition: Alfred Marshall (neo-classical era)
Alfred Marshall (1842-1924), in Principles of Economics (1890), described economics as a study of mankind in the ordinary business of life: the part of individual and social action most closely connected with getting and using the material requisites of well-being. So it is a study of wealth on one side and, more importantly, a study of man on the other.
- Wealth is not the be-all and end-all; people seek welfare, and wealth is a means to it.
- Economics deals with ordinary people who are moved by affection and duty too, not only by the wish for the most money.
- Economics is a social science: it studies people living in society who influence one another.
Criticism. (a) Marshall counts only material things, leaving out immaterial services such as those of a doctor or teacher, which also add to welfare. (b) In his theory of wages the reward for such services is ignored. (c) Welfare is not clearly defined; it differs from person to person, place to place and time to time. Goods like liquor that do not promote welfare still command a price and so belong to economics. (d) Welfare depends not only on wealth but also on political, social and cultural conditions.
Smith and Marshall side by side
-
Smith: wealth
- Economics is the science of wealth
- Self-interest and the invisible hand
- Wealth treated as an end
- Called a dismal science by critics
-
Marshall: welfare
- Study of mankind in the ordinary business of life
- Wealth is a means to welfare
- Social science of ordinary people
- Criticised for material things only
Smith put wealth at the centre; Marshall put man and his welfare at the centre, treating wealth as a means.
Worked example 1: is it inside Marshall's definition?
Classify, using Marshall's idea of material requisites of well-being: (i) a farmer selling rice, (ii) a teacher's lessons, (iii) a shop selling cotton cloth. Step 1: ask whether the thing is material. Rice and cloth are material goods, so (i) and (iii) fall inside. Step 2: a teacher's lesson is a service, not a material thing, so Marshall's wording leaves it out. Conclusion: this gap is exactly the first criticism of the welfare definition: services clearly raise welfare, yet the definition does not cover them.
Worked example 2: the liquor puzzle
A shop sells bottles of liquor for a price. Step 1: does it promote welfare? Most would say no, so a strict welfare definition would leave it out. Step 2: but it uses scarce resources and is bought and sold for money, which is economic activity. Conclusion: the welfare test cannot decide what is economic, which shows why welfare is a weak basis for a definition.
Key takeaways: economics means household management in its Greek root; the many definitions mark a growing science. Smith defined it as the science of wealth (self-interest, invisible hand, division of labour). Marshall shifted the focus to human welfare and called it a social science, but his definition leaves out services and leans on a vague idea of welfare.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Greek word oikos, from which economics comes, means:
- market
- household
- wealth
- law
Show answer
Answer: B. Oikonomikos combines oikos (household) and nemein (management), so economics first meant management of households.
-
2. 'Economics is the science of wealth' is associated with:
- Alfred Marshall
- Lionel Robbins
- Paul Samuelson
- Adam Smith
Show answer
Answer: D. Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations (1776) treated economics as the science of wealth: how a nation's wealth is created and increased.
-
3. Which idea belongs to Adam Smith's view of the economy?
- Ends are neutral
- The invisible hand guiding self-interest
- Economics is dynamic because it includes time
- Utility is measured in utils
Show answer
Answer: B. Smith held that each person pursues his own gain and is led by an invisible hand. Neutrality between ends is Robbins; the time element is Samuelson.
-
4. A major criticism of Marshall's welfare definition is that it:
- ignores immaterial services such as a doctor's
- treats economics as a science of choice
- uses the term invisible hand
- covers economic growth
Show answer
Answer: A. Marshall spoke of material requisites of well-being, so services, which also add to welfare, are left out.
-
5. Assertion (A): Critics called economics a dismal science in Smith's time. Reason (R): It was seen as teaching selfishness when spiritual values were held high.
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- A is true, R is false
- A is false, R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true, and R is the reason: an economics built on self-interest seemed unethical to critics such as Carlyle and Ruskin.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.