• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Scarcity and growth definitions, and the scope of economics

State and assess Robbins' scarcity definition and Samuelson's growth definition, describe the subject-matter of economics, and tell whether it is an art or a science, positive or normative.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain ends, scarce means and alternative uses in Robbins' definition and its criticisms.
  • Show how Samuelson's definition adds time, barter and society, and why the textbook finds it most satisfactory.
  • Describe the subject-matter of economics and tell positive statements from normative ones.

The welfare definition still left out services and depended on a vague idea. In the 20th century two definitions moved the focus to a problem every person and every society faces: wants are many, means are few. This lesson covers them, then asks what economics includes and what kind of science it is.

Scarcity definition: Lionel Robbins (the New Age)

Lionel Robbins, in An Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science (1932), defined economics as the science that studies human behaviour as a relationship between ends and scarce means which have alternative uses.

  • Ends are human wants, and they are unlimited.
  • Means (resources) are scarce. Scarcity is relative: supply is limited only in relation to demand.
  • Means have alternative uses, so a person ranks his wants and satisfies the most urgent first. Economics thus becomes a science of choice.

Criticism. (a) Robbins draws no line between goods that help welfare and those that do not: rice and an alcoholic drink both use scarce resources, yet only rice promotes welfare. Robbins replies that economics is neutral between ends. (b) He reduces economics to resource allocation and price, ignoring macro questions such as how national income is generated. (c) His definition does not cover economic growth and development.

Growth definition: Paul Samuelson (Modern Age)

Paul Samuelson, in Economics: An Introductory Analysis (1948), described economics as the study of how people and society choose, with or without money, to employ scarce productive resources that could have alternative uses, to produce commodities over time and distribute them for consumption now and in the future among people and groups in society.

  • Like Robbins, he accepts scarce means, unlimited ends and alternative uses.
  • He adds time, which makes the definition dynamic and brings in the theory of economic growth.
  • 'With or without money' means it also applies to a barter economy.
  • It covers production, distribution and consumption.
  • He treats economics as a social science, whereas Robbins treats it as a science of individual behaviour.

Of the four, the Tamil Nadu textbook regards Samuelson's growth definition as the most satisfactory.

The four definitions in one view
DefinitionKey wordMain gap pointed out
Smith (1776)WealthIgnores human welfare
Marshall (1890)WelfareMaterial things only; welfare vague
Robbins (1932)Scarcity and choiceNo growth; neutral even to harmful goods
Samuelson (1948)Growth over timeTaken as most satisfactory

Subject-matter of economics

The scope of economics means its subject-matter and whether it is an art or a science, positive or normative. Economics studies the behaviour of economic agents (individuals and groups): consumption and production of goods and services and the distribution of income among factors of production. It studies rational, normal people in the ordinary business of life within existing social, legal and institutional arrangements, and leaves out abnormal behaviour and socially unacceptable activities. Scarcity, the gap between what people want and what they can get, could be met by wanting less or getting more; economics mostly studies getting more. Because people's actions affect one another, economics is a social science. Activities not related to wealth, such as playing cricket for pleasure or a mother caring for her child, are non-economic and are left out.

Art or science?

Art is the practical use of knowledge to reach goals; economics guides us towards solutions of economic problems, and Pigou and Marshall saw it as an art. Science is a systematised body of knowledge that collects, classifies and analyses facts, finds cause-and-effect links and tests them; Robbins, Jordan and Robertson saw economics as a science. The textbook concludes that economics is both, the two being complementary.

Positive and normative economics

Positive versus normative

  • Positive: what is
    • Based on facts; can be tested
    • Explains cause and effect
    • Descriptive and objective
    • Uses is, was, will be
  • Normative: what ought to be
    • Based on value judgements
    • Cannot be proved true or false
    • Prescriptive and subjective
    • Uses ought to, should

Worked example 1: sorting statements

Statement (made up)Test word or ideaType
When the price of tea rises, people buy less tea.Can be checked against factsPositive
The government should give free bicycles to all students.'should': a value judgementNormative
Higher rainfall raised paddy output in a district.Cause and effect, testablePositive
Income gaps between rich and poor ought to be narrowed.'ought to'Normative

Worked example 2: Robbins or Samuelson?

A village with no money trades rice for cloth and decides how much seed to save for next year's crop. Step 1: there is no money, so the definition must allow barter: Samuelson says 'with or without money'. Step 2: saving seed for next year is a choice over time, about future consumption: again Samuelson. Step 3: Robbins would see the choice between rice and cloth but not the growth over time. Conclusion: Samuelson's definition describes this village better.

Robbins: ends, scarce means, alternative uses, so choice. Samuelson: the same choice, made over time, for society, with or without money.

— Remember

Key takeaways: Robbins made economics a science of choice but left out growth and welfare differences. Samuelson added time, barter and society, and the textbook finds his definition most satisfactory. Economics studies rational people's wealth-related activities; it is both an art and a science, and both positive (what is) and normative (what ought to be).

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Robbins defines economics as a relationship between:

    1. wealth and welfare
    2. ends and scarce means having alternative uses
    3. income and employment
    4. money and prices
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Robbins' definition speaks of human behaviour as a relationship between ends (wants) and scarce means with alternative uses.

  2. 2. Which feature makes Samuelson's definition dynamic?

    1. It includes the element of time
    2. It deals with material welfare
    3. It is neutral between ends
    4. It studies only individuals
    Show answer

    Answer: A. By speaking of production over time and consumption now and in the future, Samuelson brings in time, so his definition covers growth.

  3. 3. 'Economics is neutral between ends' is the reply of:

    1. Adam Smith
    2. Alfred Marshall
    3. Lionel Robbins
    4. Paul Samuelson
    Show answer

    Answer: C. When critics said Robbins treated rice and liquor alike, his answer was that economics does not judge ends; it is neutral between them.

  4. 4. Which statement is normative?

    1. An increase in money supply tends to raise prices.
    2. More fertiliser use raised wheat output.
    3. Luxury car production should be taxed more heavily.
    4. Death rates fell as health care spread.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 'Should' signals a value judgement that cannot be proved by facts. The other three describe cause and effect that can be tested.

  5. 5. Which of these is a non-economic activity?

    1. A cricketer paid to play a match
    2. A mother caring for her own child
    3. A tailor stitching shirts for sale
    4. A nurse working in a hospital for a salary
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A mother's care for her child is done out of love, not for wealth, so it is non-economic. The others earn income.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery