Four definitions, four stages of growth
- Wealth: Adam Smith Classical era; book published 1776.
- Welfare: Alfred Marshall Neo-classical era; book published 1890.
- Scarcity: Lionel Robbins The New Age; book published 1932.
- Growth: Paul Samuelson Modern Age; book published 1948.
Smith and Marshall side by side
-
Smith: wealth
- Economics is the science of wealth
- Self-interest and the invisible hand
- Wealth treated as an end
- Called a dismal science by critics
-
Marshall: welfare
- Study of mankind in the ordinary business of life
- Wealth is a means to welfare
- Social science of ordinary people
- Criticised for material things only
Smith put wealth at the centre; Marshall put man and his welfare at the centre, treating wealth as a means.
Key takeaways: economics means household management in its Greek root; the many definitions mark a growing science. Smith defined it as the science of wealth (self-interest, invisible hand, division of labour). Marshall shifted the focus to human welfare and called it a social science, but his definition leaves out services and leans on a vague idea of welfare.