• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

Indifference curve analysis and consumer equilibrium

Explain the ordinal approach, build an indifference schedule and curve, work out the diminishing marginal rate of substitution, state the properties of indifference curves, and find consumer equilibrium with a budget line.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Trace the ordinal approach from Edgeworth and Pareto to Hicks and Allen and state its assumptions.
  • Read an indifference schedule, draw the curve and map, and calculate MRSₓᵧ = ΔY/ΔX.
  • State four properties of indifference curves, draw a budget line, and use MRSₓᵧ = Pₓ/Pᵧ for equilibrium.

The cardinal approach needed utility to be counted in utils, which critics found unrealistic. The ordinal approach asks only that a consumer can rank combinations: better, worse or just as good. From that simple idea comes a powerful tool, the indifference curve.

From cardinal to ordinal

F. Y. Edgeworth and Vilfredo Pareto criticised the cardinal approach: utility cannot be measured absolutely but can be compared or ranked (I, II, III). Edgeworth developed the indifference curve idea in 1881; Pareto modified it in 1906; J. R. Hicks and R. G. D. Allen refined it in 1934; and Hicks gave it final shape in Value and Capital (1939). Ranking combinations in order of satisfaction gives the consumer's scale of preference.

Assumptions: the consumer is rational and seeks maximum satisfaction; utility is ordinal, not cardinal; the marginal rate of substitution diminishes; and the consumer is consistent (transitivity: if A is preferred to B and B to C, then A is preferred to C).

Indifference schedule, curve and map

An indifference schedule lists combinations of two goods that give the same satisfaction, so the consumer is indifferent among them. Plotting and joining them gives an indifference curve (also called an iso-utility or equal-satisfaction curve). A set of such curves is an indifference map: a higher curve means higher satisfaction.

Worked example 1: schedule and MRS (made-up figures)

One consumer's equally satisfying combinations
CombinationPens (X)Notebooks (Y)ΔY given upΔX gainedMRSₓᵧ = ΔY/ΔX
A118---
B21318 − 13 = 515
C3913 − 9 = 414
D469 − 6 = 313
E546 − 4 = 212

The marginal rate of substitution of X for Y (MRSₓᵧ), in Leftwich's sense, is the largest amount of Y the consumer will give up for one more unit of X while staying on the same curve. Strictly MRSₓᵧ = −ΔY/ΔX, but the minus sign is ignored. Here it falls 5, 4, 3, 2: as the consumer has more pens and fewer notebooks, each extra pen is worth fewer notebooks. This is the diminishing MRS.

Properties of indifference curves

  • Negative slope: to stay equally satisfied, having more X means having less Y. A flat, vertical or upward-sloping line cannot be an indifference curve, because one point on it would clearly be better.
  • Convex to the origin: because MRS diminishes along the curve.
  • Cannot intersect: if two curves crossed at C, C would be as good as A on one curve and as good as B on the other, making A equal to B, although one lies on a higher curve. That is a contradiction.
  • Do not touch either axis: every combination on a curve contains some of both goods.

Budget line

The budget line (price line) joins all combinations of two goods a consumer can buy with a given income at given prices. It is a downward-sloping straight line. If income is C and the line meets the y-axis at A and the x-axis at B, then OA = C ÷ Pᵧ and OB = C ÷ Pₓ. Its slope equals Pₓ/Pᵧ.

Worked example 2: budget line and equilibrium (made-up figures)

Income ₹60; price of a pen (X) ₹6; price of a notebook (Y) ₹3. Step 1: all on pens: 60 ÷ 6 = 10 pens (point B). All on notebooks: 60 ÷ 3 = 20 notebooks (point A). Step 2: slope = Pₓ/Pᵧ = 6 ÷ 3 = 2: one pen costs the same as two notebooks. Step 3: the consumer reaches equilibrium where the budget line is tangent to the highest attainable indifference curve, so that MRSₓᵧ = Pₓ/Pᵧ = 2. Step 4: if, on the consumer's highest reachable curve, MRS falls to 2 at 6 pens and 8 notebooks, check the cost: 6 × 6 + 8 × 3 = 36 + 24 = ₹60, the whole income. That is the equilibrium.

Finding the consumer's equilibrium

  1. Indifference map Shows what the consumer prefers.
  2. Budget line Shows what the consumer can afford.
  3. Highest curve touched Move outward until a curve just touches the line.
  4. Point of tangency MRSₓᵧ = Pₓ/Pᵧ; all income spent.

Consumer equilibrium (ordinal): the budget line is tangent to the highest indifference curve, so MRSₓᵧ = Pₓ/Pᵧ.

— Remember

If MRS were greater than the price ratio, the consumer values one more pen at more notebooks than the market charges, so he buys more pens; MRS then falls until it equals the price ratio.

Key takeaways: the ordinal approach ranks combinations instead of measuring utility. An indifference curve shows equally satisfying combinations; MRS = ΔY/ΔX diminishes, so curves are convex, slope downward, never cross and never touch the axes. With a budget line, equilibrium is at tangency, where MRSₓᵧ = Pₓ/Pᵧ.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who gave the indifference curve analysis its final shape in Value and Capital (1939)?

    1. J. R. Hicks
    2. Vilfredo Pareto
    3. F. Y. Edgeworth
    4. Alfred Marshall
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Edgeworth began (1881), Pareto modified (1906), Hicks and Allen refined (1934), and Hicks finished it in Value and Capital (1939).

  2. 2. Made up: moving along an indifference curve, a consumer gives up 6 units of Y to get 2 more of X. MRSₓᵧ is:

    1. 12
    2. 8
    3. 3
    4. 1/3
    Show answer

    Answer: C. MRSₓᵧ = ΔY/ΔX = 6 ÷ 2 = 3 units of Y per unit of X (sign ignored).

  3. 3. Indifference curves are convex to the origin because:

    1. income is fixed
    2. the marginal rate of substitution diminishes
    3. prices are equal
    4. utility is measured in utils
    Show answer

    Answer: B. As X increases along the curve, the consumer gives up less and less Y for each extra X; this diminishing MRS bends the curve towards the origin.

  4. 4. Made up: income ₹120, Pₓ = ₹10, Pᵧ = ₹4. Where does the budget line meet the y-axis?

    1. 12 units of Y
    2. 40 units of Y
    3. 4 units of Y
    4. 30 units of Y
    Show answer

    Answer: D. On the y-axis all income is spent on Y: 120 ÷ 4 = 30 units. 12 is the x-axis intercept (120 ÷ 10).

  5. 5. At consumer equilibrium in indifference curve analysis:

    1. MRSₓᵧ = Pₓ/Pᵧ
    2. MRSₓᵧ is zero
    3. the budget line cuts the lowest curve
    4. total utility is maximum in utils
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Equilibrium is where the budget line is tangent to the highest attainable indifference curve; there the slope of the curve (MRSₓᵧ) equals the slope of the line (Pₓ/Pᵧ).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery