• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

The law of equi-marginal utility and consumer's surplus

Use MU ÷ price to find a consumer's equilibrium between two goods, and measure consumer's surplus as TU − (P × Q) from a schedule.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the law of equi-marginal utility and its condition MUₐ/Pₐ = MUᵦ/Pᵦ.
  • Find the best combination of two goods from a utility schedule and a given income.
  • Define consumer's surplus, measure it from a table and give its assumptions and criticisms.

The law of diminishing marginal utility deals with one good. Real consumers buy many goods with a limited income. How should they split their money? And why do they often feel they got more than they paid for? This lesson answers both questions.

The law of equi-marginal utility

This law extends the law of DMU to several goods. It is also called the law of substitution, the law of consumer's equilibrium, Gossen's second law and the law of maximum satisfaction. Marshall's idea: a person with something that has several uses will spread it so that its marginal utility is the same in every use; if one use gave more, he would gain by shifting some of it there.

Equilibrium: MUₐ ÷ Pₐ = MUᵦ ÷ Pᵦ = K, where K is the constant marginal utility of money, and the whole income is spent.

— Condition to remember

Assumptions: the consumer is rational; utility is cardinally measurable; MU of money is constant; income is given; there is perfect competition; prices are given; and the law of DMU operates. If MUₐ/Pₐ is less than MUᵦ/Pᵦ, the consumer moves money from A to B until the two are equal, which is why it is called the law of substitution.

Worked example 1: mangoes and bananas (made-up utils)

Income ₹24. Price of a mango ₹4, price of a banana ₹2.

UnitMU of mangoMU ÷ 4MU of bananaMU ÷ 2
140102010
2328168
3246126
416484
58242

Step 1: find where MU per rupee is equal and the money is used up. MU ÷ P equals 4 at the 4th mango and 4th banana. Step 2: cost = 4 × ₹4 + 4 × ₹2 = 16 + 8 = ₹24, exactly the income. Step 3: total utility = (40 + 32 + 24 + 16) + (20 + 16 + 12 + 8) = 112 + 56 = 168 utils. Check another split: 5 mangoes and 2 bananas also cost 20 + 4 = ₹24 but give (112 + 8) + (20 + 16) = 120 + 36 = 156 utils, which is less. So 4 mangoes and 4 bananas is the equilibrium.

Criticisms: utility can be felt but not measured; the law does not apply well to durable goods bought once in a long while.

Consumer's surplus

The idea came from classical economists, was developed by the French engineer-economist Jules Dupuit (1844) and by Jevons, and was refined by Marshall. Marshall's idea: the excess of the price a person would be willing to pay rather than go without a thing, over the price he actually pays, measures his surplus satisfaction.

Consumer's surplus = potential price − actual price = TU − (P × Q).

— Formula

Assumptions: utility can be measured; MU of money is constant; the good has no substitutes; tastes, income and character do not change; and the utility of one good does not depend on others. It is based on the law of DMU.

Worked example 2: buying guavas (made-up figures)

GuavaWilling to pay (₹)Actual price (₹)Surplus (₹)
1st502050 − 20 = 30
2nd402040 − 20 = 20
3rd302030 − 20 = 10
4th202020 − 20 = 0
Total1408060

The buyer stops at the 4th guava, where willingness to pay equals the price. By formula: TU (potential) = 50 + 40 + 30 + 20 = ₹140; P × Q = 20 × 4 = ₹80; surplus = 140 − 80 = ₹60. Check: the column of surpluses adds to 30 + 20 + 10 + 0 = 60.

On a diagram with quantity on the x-axis and price on the y-axis, the downward-sloping MU (demand) curve shows willingness to pay. At price OP the consumer buys OQ. The area under the curve up to OQ is the potential payment; the rectangle OP × OQ is the actual payment; the triangle between them, above the price line, is consumer's surplus. A lower price makes this triangle larger: price and consumer's surplus are inversely related.

How consumer's surplus arises

  1. Diminishing MU Each extra unit is worth less to the buyer.
  2. One market price Every unit is bought at the same price.
  3. Buy till MU = price The last unit is worth just its price.
  4. Earlier units worth more Their extra worth is the surplus.

Criticisms: utility cannot be measured; the MU of money does not really stay constant; and the potential price is in the consumer's mind, known only to himself.

Key takeaways: a consumer with two goods is in equilibrium when MU per rupee is the same for both and the income is used up. Consumer's surplus is what a buyer would pay minus what he does pay, TU − P × Q, and it grows as price falls.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The law of equi-marginal utility is also called:

    1. the law of demand
    2. the law of variable proportions
    3. the law of substitution
    4. Engel's law
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The consumer substitutes spending on the good with higher MU per rupee for the one with lower, so it is called the law of substitution (also Gossen's second law).

  2. 2. Made up: MU of tea is 30 at ₹10 a cup; MU of a samosa is 30 at ₹15. To gain satisfaction the consumer should:

    1. spend more on tea and less on samosas
    2. spend more on samosas
    3. stop buying both
    4. keep spending unchanged
    Show answer

    Answer: A. MU per rupee: tea 30 ÷ 10 = 3; samosa 30 ÷ 15 = 2. A rupee gives more utility on tea, so money should shift towards tea until the ratios are equal.

  3. 3. Made up: a buyer is willing to pay ₹90, ₹70 and ₹50 for three units, and the price is ₹50. Consumer's surplus is:

    1. ₹210
    2. ₹150
    3. ₹40
    4. ₹60
    Show answer

    Answer: D. TU = 90 + 70 + 50 = ₹210. Actual payment = 50 × 3 = ₹150. Surplus = 210 − 150 = ₹60. Unit by unit: 40 + 20 + 0 = 60.

  4. 4. If the market price falls, consumer's surplus:

    1. rises
    2. falls
    3. stays the same
    4. becomes negative
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A lower price raises the gap between willingness to pay and actual payment, and more units are bought, so the surplus triangle grows.

  5. 5. Which is a criticism of consumer's surplus?

    1. It ignores diminishing marginal utility
    2. The potential price is known only to the consumer himself
    3. It applies only to monopoly
    4. It assumes many substitutes
    Show answer

    Answer: B. What a person would be willing to pay is in his own mind, so it cannot be observed by others; this is one of the textbook's criticisms.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery