- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Islamic, Parsi and Sikh reform movements
Describe the Aligarh, Ahmadiya, Deoband, Nadwat al-'ulama and Farangi Mahal movements among Muslims, and the reform movements of the Parsis and Sikhs.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why reform movements arose among Muslims after 1857 and describe Syed Ahmad Khan's Aligarh Movement.
- Compare Aligarh with the Deoband and Ahmadiya movements and the Nadwa and Farangi Mahal schools.
- Describe the Parsi Rahnumai Mazdayasnan Sabha and the Sikh Singh Sabha and Akali movements.
Reform was not confined to Hindu society. Muslims, Parsis and Sikhs each produced movements that tried to meet the challenge of modern education and missionary activity while keeping their faith.
Why Muslim reform movements arose
The book explains that after the revolt of 1857 and its brutal suppression, the British viewed Muslims with suspicion, and Muslims themselves withdrew and did not use the opportunities of colonial modernity, so they lagged behind in education and employment. A few decades later reform movements appeared to address this.
The Aligarh Movement (1875)
Syed Ahmad Khan started the Aligarh Movement to reconcile Western scientific education with the teachings of the Quran. It aimed to spread modern education among Muslims without weakening their faith, and social reform on purdah, polygamy and divorce. His journal Tahdhib-ul-Akhlaq (Improvement of Manners and Morals) carried his ideas, and he favoured English as the medium of instruction.
Syed Ahmad Khan's educational steps (from the textbook)
- 1864 Scientific Society to translate Western science into Urdu; a modern school at Ghazipur.
- 1868 Education committees in several districts.
- 1869-70 Visit to Europe; plans for a major college.
- 1875 Modern school at Aligarh.
- 1877 Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College, later the Muslim University.
- 1886 Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental Educational Conference.
He rejected blind adherence to religious law and asked that the Quran be reinterpreted in the light of reason. Orthodox theologians attacked him fiercely. The Aligarh college became the nursery of Muslim political and intellectual leaders.
Other Muslim movements
The Ahmadiya movement, founded by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad in 1889, stressed the original principles of the Quran and defended Islam against the Arya Samaj and Christian missionaries. It became controversial when he claimed to be a Messiah, which mainstream Islam considered heretical; in social matters it was conservative.
The Deoband movement was organised by orthodox ulema as a revivalist movement to spread the pure teachings of the Quran and Hadis and to train religious leaders. Its seminary at Deoband (Saharanpur district) was founded in 1866-67 by Muhammad Qasim Nanotavi and Rashid Ahmad Gangohi. Unlike Aligarh, which sought Muslim welfare through Western education and support for the British government, Deoband aimed at religious regeneration within classical Islamic tradition, and became honoured across the Islamic world.
The Nadwat al-'ulama, founded at Lucknow in 1894 by the historian Shibli Nu'mani and others, was less conservative than Deoband and offered an enlightened interpretation of religion against the agnosticism that followed Western education. The much older Farangi Mahal school, also in Lucknow, accepted Sufism as a valid field of study.
| Movement or school | Founded | Leader(s) | Approach |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aligarh | 1875 | Syed Ahmad Khan | Modern, English education; reason-based reinterpretation |
| Deoband | 1866-67 | Qasim Nanotavi, Rashid Ahmad Gangohi | Revivalist; classical tradition; training ulema |
| Ahmadiya | 1889 | Mirza Ghulam Ahmad | Defence of Islam; socially conservative; controversial claims |
| Nadwat al-'ulama | 1894, Lucknow | Shibli Nu'mani | Between tradition and the modern age |
Parsi reform
The Zoroastrians (Parsis), who had migrated from Persia to India's west coast in the tenth century, flourished as traders. In 1851 English-educated Parsis founded the Rahnumai Mazdayasnan Sabha (Religious Reform Association) to regenerate Parsi society and restore Zoroastrianism to its purity. Its leaders included Naoroji Furdonji, Dadabhai Naoroji, K. R. Cama and S. S. Bengalee, and its newspaper was Rast Goftar (Truth Teller). It reformed rituals and worked for women's education, removal of purdah and a higher age of marriage. The book says the Parsis became the most westernised section of Indian society and played a key role in the national movement and in industry.
Sikh reform
The Singh Sabha Movement (1873) sought to bring modern Western education to Sikhs and to counter the proselytising of Christian missionaries and Hindu revivalists; it set up a network of Khalsa schools across Punjab. Its offshoot, the Akali movement, worked to free Sikh gurdwaras from the control of the Udasi mahants, which it saw as corrupt. The book says the government passed a Sikh Gurdwara Act in 1922, amended in 1925, giving control to the Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee (SGPC).
Worked example 1: Aligarh or Deoband?
Question: a seminary trains religious scholars in classical Islamic learning and argues against missionaries; a college teaches Western science in English. Which is which? Working: training ulema in classical tradition is Deoband's aim; Western science in English to prepare Muslims for modern careers is Aligarh's aim. Answer: the seminary is Deoband, the college Aligarh (the Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College).
Worked example 2: a common thread
Question: what did the Arya Samaj, the Ahmadiyas, Deoband and the Singh Sabha have in common, according to the book? Working: each defended its own faith against others' proselytising: the Ahmadiyas and Deoband argued against the Arya Samaj and Christian missionaries, and the Singh Sabha countered missionaries and Hindu revivalists. Answer: competition among faiths, as well as Western ideas, pushed communities to organise and reform.
Aligarh 1875 (Syed Ahmad Khan; MAO College 1877). Deoband 1866-67 (Nanotavi, Gangohi). Ahmadiya 1889 (Mirza Ghulam Ahmad). Nadwa 1894 (Shibli). Parsi Rahnumai Mazdayasnan Sabha 1851 (Rast Goftar). Singh Sabha 1873; Akali movement and SGPC.
Key takeaways: after 1857 Muslims lagged in education; Syed Ahmad Khan's Aligarh Movement promoted modern English education and rational interpretation, while Deoband revived classical learning and the Ahmadiyas defended Islam but proved controversial. Parsi reformers modernised their community's rituals and women's position. The Singh Sabha spread education among Sikhs, and the Akali movement won control of gurdwaras for the SGPC.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, why did Indian Muslims lag behind in education after 1857?
- The British closed all Muslim schools
- They were viewed with suspicion and withdrew from the opportunities of colonial modernity
- They migrated to Persia
- They joined the Arya Samaj
Show answer
Answer: B. The book says the British suspected Muslims after the revolt, and Muslims withdrew and did not use the opportunities opened by colonial modernity.
-
2. Syed Ahmad Khan's school at Aligarh developed into:
- the Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College
- the Deoband seminary
- the Nadwat al-'ulama
- the Farangi Mahal
Show answer
Answer: A. His 1875 school at Aligarh became the Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College (1877), which later became the Muslim University.
-
3. How did the Deoband movement differ from the Aligarh Movement?
- Deoband promoted English education
- Deoband supported the British government
- Deoband aimed at religious regeneration within classical Islamic tradition
- Deoband was founded by Syed Ahmad Khan
Show answer
Answer: C. Aligarh worked for Muslim welfare through Western education and support of the government; Deoband sought religious regeneration and adhered to classical tradition.
-
4. The Parsi newspaper Rast Goftar was associated with:
- the Singh Sabha
- the Ahmadiya movement
- the Theosophical Society
- the Rahnumai Mazdayasnan Sabha
Show answer
Answer: D. The message of the Parsi Religious Reform Association, founded in 1851, was spread by Rast Goftar (Truth Teller).
-
5. The Akali movement aimed to:
- free Sikh gurdwaras from the control of the Udasi mahants
- start Khalsa schools in Bengal
- convert Hindus to Sikhism
- oppose the Aligarh Movement
Show answer
Answer: A. An offshoot of the Singh Sabha, the Akali movement worked to liberate gurdwaras from the Udasi mahants; control passed to the SGPC.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.