- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The Indian Renaissance and the Brahmo Samaj
Explain the ideas behind nineteenth-century reform, the difference between reformist and revivalist movements, and the work of Raja Rammohan Roy and the Brahmo Samaj, including its Tamil Nadu followers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Name the new ideas and conditions that produced what is called the Indian Renaissance.
- Distinguish reformist from revivalist movements and explain why social reform was tied to religion.
- Describe Rammohan Roy's campaign against sati and the growth and divisions of the Brahmo Samaj.
By the early nineteenth century a small English-educated group had grown up in India, close to British administration and trade, and Christian missionaries were active. Bengal, the first province to feel British influence, was where many reform ideas began. The Tamil textbook names the new ideas that challenged older knowledge: rationalism as a basis for ethics, the idea of human progress, and the natural rights of the Enlightenment. Together these led to what has been called the Indian Renaissance, and the spread of printing carried the ideas far.
A self-serving picture, and an Indian response
The British described Indian society as trapped in superstition, idolatry and caste, with women badly treated and sati especially condemned, and claimed that only British intervention could change it. The book calls this a self-serving argument made by missionaries and Utilitarians (followers of the idea of the greatest happiness of the greatest number) to justify British rule. It reminds us that India was vast and varied, and that Indian reformers had fought social evils through the ages; the British presence posed a new challenge to which Indians responded with their own movements.
What united the reform movements
New economic forces, education, nationalism, Western ideas and awareness of change in Europe strengthened the urge to reform. The book identifies three ideas that gave the movements unity: rationalism, religious universalism and humanism. They judged customs by social utility. Rammohan Roy rejected the infallibility of the Vedas; Syed Ahmad Khan held that religious tenets could change; and Keshab Chandra Sen argued that all the world's established religions are true.
Two kinds of reform movement
-
Reformist
- Relied more on reason and conscience
- Questioned tradition strongly
- Example: Brahmo Samaj
-
Revivalist
- Relied more on tradition and a return to a pure past
- Sought to restore original scriptures
- Example: Arya Samaj
Social and religious reform went together because practices such as caste and gender inequality drew their legitimacy from religion. At first the movements had a narrow base in the upper and middle strata; later they spread to lower strata. Public debates, tracts and journals spread new ideas. Bodies such as the Social Conference, the Servants of India and Christian missions helped, and in the twentieth century the national movement led social reform.
Raja Rammohan Roy and the Brahmo Samaj (1828)
Raja Rammohan Roy, whom the book's exercises call the father of the Indian Renaissance, was a retired Company servant who knew many languages, including Persian and Sanskrit. He founded the Brahmo Samaj in August 1828, devoted to the worship of one eternal Being, the author and preserver of the universe. He aimed to purify Hinduism and preach monotheism, drawing authority from the Vedas, stressed human dignity, and opposed idolatry and sati. In an 1818 tract written as a conversation between a supporter and an opponent of widow burning, he used sacred texts to show that no religion sanctioned it. His campaign bore fruit in the law of 1829 that made sati a crime. He went to Europe and died at Bristol (in 1833).
The Brahmo Samaj's programme (as listed in the textbook)
-
Religion
- Against polytheism and idol worship
- Against belief in divine incarnations (avatars)
-
Society
- Against caste, dogma and superstition
- For abolishing child marriage, purdah and sati
- For widow remarriage
After Rammohan's death the Samaj declined until Devendranath Tagore, father of Rabindranath Tagore, revived it; Keshab Chandra Sen carried it forward from 1857. According to the textbook it had 54 branches in 1865, most of them in Bengal. It then split. (The book names the two parts as Devendranath's 'Brahmo Samaj of India' and Keshab's 'Sadharan Brahmo Samaj'; in the usual account, Keshab's group formed the Brahmo Samaj of India in 1866, Devendranath's became the Adi Brahmo Samaj, and the Sadharan Brahmo Samaj was formed in 1878 by members who left Keshab.) It faced opposition from orthodox bodies such as the Hindu Dharma Sabha, while Ishwarchandra Vidyasagar argued for similar reforms from Hindu scripture. Although it won few followers, it deeply influenced intellectuals, including the Tagore family.
In Tamil Nadu, Kasi Viswanatha Mudaliar followed the Samaj, wrote the play Brahmo Samaja Natakam and a tract supporting widow remarriage, and in 1864 a Tamil journal, Tathuva Bodhini, was started for its cause.
Worked example 1: reformist or revivalist?
Question: a movement says customs must be judged by reason and that no scripture is infallible. Another says society must return to the Vedas, rejecting later texts. Classify them. Working: the first relies on reason and conscience over tradition, so it is reformist (like the Brahmo Samaj); the second appeals to a pure ancient tradition, so it is revivalist (like the Arya Samaj). Answer: reformist, then revivalist, though the book notes both appealed to some lost purity.
Worked example 2: why argue from scripture?
Question: Rammohan Roy rejected the infallibility of the Vedas, yet he quoted sacred texts against sati. Why? Working: (1) sati drew its legitimacy from religion; (2) showing that the texts did not sanction it removed that legitimacy for believers; (3) this persuaded more people than an appeal to reason alone. Answer: because social customs were defended in religious terms, reformers often had to answer in religious terms too.
Indian Renaissance: rationalism, religious universalism and humanism. Brahmo Samaj, 1828, Rammohan Roy: one God, against idolatry, caste, sati and child marriage, for widow remarriage.
Key takeaways: Enlightenment ideas, English education and printing produced a Renaissance that began in Bengal. The book rejects the British claim that only they could reform India. Reform movements, reformist or revivalist, were united by rationalism, universalism and humanism. Rammohan Roy's Brahmo Samaj (1828) preached one God and fought sati, which was banned in 1829; it was carried on by Devendranath Tagore and Keshab Chandra Sen and reached Tamil Nadu through Kasi Viswanatha Mudaliar.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which province does the textbook say was the first where many reform ideas originated?
- Bengal
- Punjab
- Bombay
- Madras
Show answer
Answer: A. Bengal was the first province affected by British influence, so many ideas of reform began there.
-
2. The textbook names three ideas that gave the reform movements an ideological unity. They are:
- nationalism, socialism and secularism
- rationalism, religious universalism and humanism
- utilitarianism, liberalism and conservatism
- revivalism, mysticism and ritualism
Show answer
Answer: B. Rationalism, religious universalism and humanism let reformers judge practices by social utility.
-
3. Why does the book call the British argument that only they could reform Indian society 'self-serving'?
- Because the British banned all reform
- Because Indians had no reformers
- Because missionaries and Utilitarians used it to justify British rule
- Because the British never criticised sati
Show answer
Answer: C. The book says the argument was articulated by missionaries and Utilitarians to justify British rule, while Indian reformers had fought social evils through the ages.
-
4. Rammohan Roy's tract of 1818 argued that:
- the Vedas should be returned to
- no religion sanctioned the burning alive of widows
- English should replace Persian
- idol worship was essential to Hinduism
Show answer
Answer: B. Written as a conference between a supporter and an opponent of widow burning, it cited sacred texts to show no religion sanctioned it.
-
5. Who in Tamil Nadu wrote the play Brahmo Samaja Natakam?
- Arumuga Navalar
- Iyotheethoss Pandithar
- Ramalinga Swamigal
- Kasi Viswanatha Mudaliar
Show answer
Answer: D. Kasi Viswanatha Mudaliar, an adherent of the Samaj, wrote the play and a tract supporting widow remarriage.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.