• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Intellectual awakening: heterodox thinkers, Ajivikas and Carvakas

Explain the causes of the intellectual ferment of the sixth century BCE, name the heterodox teachers, and describe the beliefs of the Ajivikas, Purana Kassapa, Pakudha Kacchayana, Ajita Kesakambalin and the Carvakas.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the causes of the intellectual awakening of the sixth and fifth centuries BCE.
  • Name the heterodox teachers mentioned in the Samannaphala Sutta.
  • Describe the doctrines of the Ajivikas and the materialists, and the rivalry among sects.

In the sixth and fifth centuries BCE north India saw what the textbook calls a remarkable intellectual awakening. Wandering ascetics - Gosala, the Buddha, Mahavira, Ajita Kesakambalin and others - crossed the Ganga plain questioning Vedic ideas of the soul, mind and body. Their teachings answered the needs of a fast-changing society with new states, towns, crafts and long-distance trade.

Causes of the intellectual awakening

  1. State formation and the rigidity of Vedic religion constrained freedom of thought and action; revolt against dogma found expression in heterodox sects.
  2. Territorial identities sped up social, political and economic change; disillusioned elites turned to the heterodox faiths of Magadha and the middle Ganga plain.
  3. Vedic religion had not yet permeated society in these regions, so people found it easy to follow new sects.
  4. Urbanisation and trade produced merchants and bankers such as sethis who wanted social status equal to their wealth.
  5. Kshatriyas resented being denied the staged life of the ashramas, which the Vedic texts allowed only to Brahmins.

The philosopher S. Radhakrishnan, the book notes, explained such movements as the reaction of minds whose curiosity had been suppressed by ceremonial religion. The new sects' ideas included antinomian (that divine grace frees one from moral law), materialist and fatalist strands; they rivalled orthodox Vedic religion and each other.

The teachers of the Samannaphala Sutta

The Buddhist text Samannaphala Sutta says that before meeting the Buddha, Ajatashatru of Magadha discussed philosophy with six sect leaders: Purana Kassapa, Makkhali Gosala, Ajita Kesakambalin, Pakudha Kachchayana, Sanjaya Belatthiputta and Nigantha Nataputta (Mahavira). They are called long-standing homeless wanderers, founders of sects and leaders of orders. In this Buddhist account their doctrines are shown as unsatisfactory, while the Buddha's satisfied the king - a reminder that the source was written by a rival.

The Ajivikas

The Ajivikas grew from one of the ascetic groups of the time. Buddhist records name Nanda Vaccha as founder, followed by Kisa Samkicca and then Makkhali Gosala, the third and greatest. Gosala met Mahavira at Nalanda; they were together for six years and parted over doctrine. Gosala then went to Sravasti, patronised by a rich potter woman, Halahala; Sravasti became the Ajivika headquarters. Both Buddhist and Jaina accounts, being rivals, portray him harshly.

  • Niyati (fate): everything is predetermined and nothing in the world can be changed; one must pass through a series of transmigrations to end pain.
  • Six inevitable factors: gain and loss, joy and sorrow, life and death.
  • Practice: naked ascetics who ridiculed the severe austerities of Vedic ascetics; rich lay followers such as potters and bankers.
  • After Gosala: Purana Kassapa and Pakudha Kacchayana joined and revived the sect; it spread widely but was much less influential than Buddhism and Jainism.

Purana Kassapa taught that actions carry no merit or demerit - neither harm nor generosity changes anything, since all is fixed - and that non-action is the way out. Pakudha Kacchayana held that the world is made of seven eternal, unchanging substances that do not act on one another. Ajita Kesakambalin ('of the hair blanket') was a materialist: humans are made of four elements - fire, water, wind and sense (as the book lists them) - which return to the earth at death; there is no life after death.

In Tamil land, Manimekalai, Nilakesi and Sivagnanasiddhiyar refer to Ajivika doctrine; in Nilakesi the heroine's search for truth takes her to the Buddha and to Puranan, the Ajivika leader. The Cholas are known to have levied a tax on the Ajivikas.

Lokayata and Carvaka

Lokayata means materialist thought; Indian materialism is also called Carvaka, after one of its two founders. Carvaka and Ajita Kesakambalin are said to have made materialism a formal philosophical system. The Carvakas developed scepticism, sought knowledge through experience and questioned the authority of the Vedas.

Rivalry among the sects

Buddhist and Jaina texts mention other sects only to belittle them. The Jaina Bhagavatisutra gives a poor account of Gosala; Buddhaghosa ridicules him in his commentaries; and a Jataka story compares rival teachers to fireflies fading before the sun, meaning the Buddha. Historians therefore read these accounts with care.

Ajivikas: niyati (fate), six inevitable factors - gain and loss, joy and sorrow, life and death. Carvakas: materialism, scepticism, knowledge through experience.

Worked example 1: matching thinker and idea

Question: match - (i) Gosala, (ii) Ajita Kesakambalin, (iii) Pakudha Kacchayana, (iv) Purana Kassapa - with (p) seven unchanging substances, (q) no life after death, (r) niyati, (s) actions have no merit or demerit. Working: Gosala led the Ajivikas, whose basic principle is niyati; Ajita was the materialist who denied an afterlife; Pakudha spoke of seven substances; Purana denied merit and demerit. Answer: i-r, ii-q, iii-p, iv-s.

Worked example 2: judging a hostile source

Question: Buddhist and Jaina texts describe Gosala as a man of bad character. Should a historian accept this? Working: identify the authors - both belonged to rival sects competing for followers and patrons; the book says such texts belittle other sects. Look for independent evidence: Gosala had rich lay followers and a headquarters at Sravasti, which suggests real support. Answer: treat the portrait as biased; use it for what rivals thought, not as a neutral judgement.

Key takeaways: rigid ritual, new states, towns, wealthy merchants and Kshatriya grievances fed the sixth-century awakening. Six teachers appear in the Samannaphala Sutta. The Ajivikas under Gosala taught niyati; Purana Kassapa, Pakudha and Ajita added fatalist and materialist views; Carvakas stressed experience and doubted the Vedas. Rival texts belittle one another and must be read critically.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The basic principle of the Ajivikas was:

    1. ahimsa
    2. niyati or fate
    3. the Middle Path
    4. worship of Prajapati
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The book says the basic principle of the Ajivikas was niyati or fate: everything is predetermined and nothing can be changed.

  2. 2. Which Buddhist text describes Ajatashatru's discussions with six sect leaders before he met the Buddha?

    1. Bhagavatisutra
    2. Kalpasutra
    3. Samannaphala Sutta
    4. Mahavamsa
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Samannaphala Sutta records Ajatashatru's discourse with Purana Kassapa, Gosala, Ajita, Pakudha, Sanjaya and Nigantha Nataputta. The Bhagavatisutra and Kalpasutra are Jaina texts.

  3. 3. The headquarters of the Ajivika sect was at:

    1. Sravasti
    2. Nalanda
    3. Vaishali
    4. Pataliputra
    Show answer

    Answer: A. After parting from Mahavira, Gosala went to Sravasti, where the potter woman Halahala patronised him; Sravasti was the Ajivika headquarters.

  4. 4. Which cause of the intellectual awakening concerns merchants such as sethis?

    1. They wanted to perform more Vedic sacrifices
    2. They wanted to become Kshatriyas through war
    3. They opposed the growth of towns
    4. They sought a higher social status matching their economic status
    Show answer

    Answer: D. With urbanisation and trade, new classes of merchants and bankers such as sethis sought social status appropriate to their wealth, and turned to the new sects.

  5. 5. The Carvakas are best described as:

    1. materialists who stressed knowledge through experience and questioned the Vedas
    2. fatalists who believed in niyati
    3. Jaina monks who wore white
    4. priests who performed srauta sacrifices
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Lokayata or Carvaka is Indian materialism: it developed scepticism, sought knowledge through experience and questioned Vedic authority. Niyati belongs to the Ajivikas.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery