• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Iron, agriculture and the second urbanisation

Name the sources for this period, weigh the differing views on the role of iron in the Ganga valley, and explain how surplus, crafts and trade led to the second urbanisation and its towns.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • List the literary and archaeological sources for the age of the Mahajanapadas.
  • Compare the views of historians on how far iron helped clear forests and raise farm output.
  • Explain the causes and features of the second urbanisation and name its types of towns.

From about 1000 BCE the Vedic people moved east into the thickly forested, fertile Ganga plain. The Tamil Nadu textbook links this movement with iron, richer farming, growing crafts and, in time, new towns. The same years saw a spirit of questioning that produced new faiths. This lesson covers the material changes; later lessons turn to kingdoms and ideas.

Sources

Literary sources include the epics Mahabharata and Ramayana, the dharmasastras, Buddhist texts such as the Tripitakas and Jatakas, Jaina texts, and Greek accounts such as that of Arrian. Archaeological excavations have corroborated the literary evidence.

How important was iron? Differing views

The book presents a debate rather than one answer. It agrees that agriculture improved in the middle Ganga plain: wet rice cultivation gave more produce than other crops and created an agrarian surplus, and protected irrigation alone does not explain it. But historians disagree about how much iron did.

Views on the impact of iron technology, as summarised in the Tamil Nadu textbook
HistorianView
D.D. KosambiThe eastward move aimed at the iron ore of south Bihar; near monopoly of iron explains Magadha's dominance
R.S. SharmaIron axes and ploughs expanded the area under cultivation in the Ganga valley
Makkhan LalIron clearing forests and producing surplus is a myth: the plain was still heavily forested in the 16th-17th centuries
A. Ghosh and Niharranjan RayThe forests could have been cleared by fire

The book's own conclusion: whether the iron axe cleared forests or the iron ploughshare raised yields is debated, but iron certainly played a critical role in craft production. Surplus and leisure, together with better technology, led to more crafts, and crafts in turn aided vibrant trade.

The second urbanisation

Agricultural surplus, the growth of crafts and trade, and a growing population led to the rise of towns in the Ganga plain. Because India's first urbanisation was the Harappan civilisation, this is called the second urbanisation.

From iron and rice to towns

  1. Eastward movement and iron Forests of the fertile Ganga plain opened up.
  2. Wet rice and surplus More food than farmers need.
  3. Crafts grow Iron tools improve pottery, carpentry and metalwork.
  4. Trade expands Goods move between regions.
  5. Towns: second urbanisation Political, trading and holy centres.
Types of towns named in the textbook
TypeExamples
Political and administrative centresRajagriha, Shravasti, Kaushambi, Champa
Centres of trade and commerceUjjain, Taxila
Holy centreVaishali

Archaeological evidence: iron hoes, sickles, knives, hooks, nails, arrowheads, vessels and mirrors show the wide use of iron; textiles, beads, pottery, ivory, glassware, other metals and many terracottas are found. Urban features include Northern Black Polished Ware (NBPW), a luxury ware called an 'urban hallmark'; towns such as Rajagriha and Kaushambi enclosed by a moat and sometimes fortified; houses of mud brick and sometimes burnt brick; and drains, ring wells and soak-pits.

Second urbanisation = towns of the Ganga plain, from agricultural surplus + crafts + trade + population growth; marked by NBPW, moats and fortifications, ring wells and soak-pits.

Worked example 1: writing a balanced note on iron

Question: write a critical note on the use of iron in clearing forests. Working: (1) state the view for - R.S. Sharma: iron axes and ploughs extended cultivation; Kosambi: iron ore explains Magadha's power. (2) State the views against - Makkhan Lal: the plain was still forested centuries later; Ghosh and Ray: fire could clear forests. (3) Conclude with the textbook: the farming role is debated, but iron clearly improved crafts. Answer: a short note that names each historian and ends with that agreed point.

Worked example 2: classifying towns

Question: sort Taxila, Champa and Vaishali by type. Working: Champa appears in the list of political and administrative centres; Taxila is with Ujjain as a trade centre; Vaishali is named as a holy centre. Answer: Champa - administrative; Taxila - commercial; Vaishali - holy centre.

Key takeaways: sources include the epics, dharmasastras, Buddhist and Jaina texts and Greek accounts, confirmed by excavation. Historians differ on whether iron cleared forests and raised yields, but iron clearly improved crafts. Surplus, crafts, trade and population produced the second urbanisation, with administrative, trading and holy towns and NBPW as an urban hallmark.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which historian held that iron axes and iron ploughs expanded the area under cultivation in the Ganga valley?

    1. Makkhan Lal
    2. R.S. Sharma
    3. D.D. Kosambi
    4. Niharranjan Ray
    Show answer

    Answer: B. R.S. Sharma held this view. Makkhan Lal called it a myth, Ghosh and Ray argued the forests could have been cleared by fire, and Kosambi stressed control of the iron ore of south Bihar.

  2. 2. Why is the growth of towns in the Ganga plain called the second urbanisation?

    1. Because it came after the first urbanisation of the Harappan civilisation
    2. Because it happened twice in Magadha
    3. Because towns were built of second-hand bricks
    4. Because it came after the Mauryan cities
    Show answer

    Answer: A. India's first urbanisation was the Harappan civilisation; the towns of the Ganga plain are therefore called the second urbanisation.

  3. 3. Which pottery, considered a luxury ware and an 'urban hallmark', is found at the cities of this period?

    1. Painted Grey Ware
    2. Ochre Coloured Pottery
    3. Black and Red Ware
    4. Northern Black Polished Ware
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book lists Northern Black Polished Ware (NBPW), considered luxury ware and an urban hallmark, among the urban features of these cities.

  4. 4. According to the textbook, on which point about iron is there no disagreement?

    1. That iron axes cleared all the forests
    2. That iron ploughs doubled rice yields
    3. That iron played a critical role in improving the production of artefacts
    4. That iron was unknown before 600 BCE
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The book says it is debated whether iron axes cleared forests or ploughshares raised yields, but there can be no two opinions that iron played a critical role in craft production.

  5. 5. Ujjain and Taxila are classified in the textbook as:

    1. holy centres
    2. centres of trade and commerce
    3. Neolithic villages
    4. capitals of gana-sanghas
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The book names Ujjain and Taxila as centres of trade and commerce; Rajagriha, Shravasti, Kaushambi and Champa were administrative centres and Vaishali a holy centre.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery