| Historian | View |
|---|---|
| D.D. Kosambi | The eastward move aimed at the iron ore of south Bihar; near monopoly of iron explains Magadha's dominance |
| R.S. Sharma | Iron axes and ploughs expanded the area under cultivation in the Ganga valley |
| Makkhan Lal | Iron clearing forests and producing surplus is a myth: the plain was still heavily forested in the 16th-17th centuries |
| A. Ghosh and Niharranjan Ray | The forests could have been cleared by fire |
From iron and rice to towns
- Eastward movement and iron Forests of the fertile Ganga plain opened up.
- Wet rice and surplus More food than farmers need.
- Crafts grow Iron tools improve pottery, carpentry and metalwork.
- Trade expands Goods move between regions.
- Towns: second urbanisation Political, trading and holy centres.
| Type | Examples |
|---|---|
| Political and administrative centres | Rajagriha, Shravasti, Kaushambi, Champa |
| Centres of trade and commerce | Ujjain, Taxila |
| Holy centre | Vaishali |
Second urbanisation = towns of the Ganga plain, from agricultural surplus + crafts + trade + population growth; marked by NBPW, moats and fortifications, ring wells and soak-pits.
Key takeaways: sources include the epics, dharmasastras, Buddhist and Jaina texts and Greek accounts, confirmed by excavation. Historians differ on whether iron cleared forests and raised yields, but iron clearly improved crafts. Surplus, crafts, trade and population produced the second urbanisation, with administrative, trading and holy towns and NBPW as an urban hallmark.