- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The Bhakti movement: Azhwars, Nayanmars, Sankara and Ramanuja
Explain why Tamil devotionalism arose, its themes and links with the arts, the Azhwars and Nayanmars and how their hymns were compiled, its impact, and the ideas of Adi Sankara and Ramanuja.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the rise of Tamil devotionalism and the three themes of Bhakti hymns.
- Name the leading Azhwars and Nayanmars and the compilations of their hymns.
- Describe the impact of Bhakti and the teachings of Adi Sankara and Ramanuja.
The book's third section deals with the devotional movement that opened a new chapter in Tamil history. A strong wave of devotion swept the country from the sixth to the ninth century, expressed in the hymns of the Nayanmars (Saiva saints) and the Azhwars (Vaishnava saints).
Why Bhakti arose
The book argues that new regional states needed an ideology, and in that age religion could be the rallying point. The Pallavas of Kanchipuram and the Pandyas of Madurai patronised Bhakti, which was led by the elite and wealthy merchants, with the local temple as its centre. Bhakti touched people's hearts and mobilised them. The saints used simple Tamil set to music, bringing local and regional culture into the mainstream. There were 12 Azhwars and 63 Nayanmars, from many strata of society, including artisans and cultivators, and women: Andal among the Azhwars, and Karaikkal Ammaiyar and the Pandya queen Mangayarkkarasiyar among the Nayanmars.
Bhakti as ideology
Bhakti means service, piety, faith and worship, and also, the book says, an enactment of emotion and aesthetic feeling. It identifies three major themes in the hymns:
- Devotion to a personal god.
- A protest against orthodox Vedic Brahmanism and the Brahmins' exclusive claim to divine grace and salvation.
- Outright condemnation of Jains and Buddhists as heretics; the book says the refashioned Saivism and Vaishnavism effectively challenged these faiths.
Bhakti also shaped the arts. Temple dance grew from folk dancing into a complex art with religious themes; prosperous temples kept trained dancers from Pallava times; scenes from the Puranas and epics were sculpted in stone and bronze; and hymns set to music became part of temple ritual. The veena was probably the most used instrument.
Azhwars and Nayanmars
| Feature | Azhwars (Vaishnava) | Nayanmars (Saiva) |
|---|---|---|
| Number | 12 | 63 |
| Leading saints | Periyalvar (Srivilliputtur), Andal, Nammalvar of Kurugur (Alvar Tirunagari), called the greatest | Appar (Tirunavukkarasar), Tirugnanasambandar, Sundarar, Manikkavasagar |
| Compiled by | Nathamuni, priest at Srirangam, end of the 9th century | Nambi Andar Nambi, end of the 10th century |
| Collection | Nalayira Divya Prabandham (four thousand hymns) | Panniru Tirumurai (12 books); books 1-7 are the Thevaram |
| Notes | Periyalvar sang of Krishna's childhood under the Pandya Srimara Srivallabha; Krishna is the hero of Andal's songs; Nammalvar's works include the Tiruvaymoli | Sambandar books 1-3, Appar 4-6, Sundarar 7, Manikkavasagar's Tiruvasagam 8; Sekkizhar's Periyapuranam, the 12th book, is a life-story of the 63 saints |
The book's sources for the movement include these hymns, the Tiruthondar Thogai, hymns engraved on temple walls, and the miniature sculptures and paintings around temple corridors. The Periyapuranam tells many stories, including miracles, but also contains historical information.
Impact
The book calls the movement a great social transformation. Its high point was the rise of temples across the Tamil landscape, which in later Chola times became great social institutions. Rulers settled Brahmin groups invited from the north; kings, local bodies and individuals endowed festivals in the temples. Bhakti thus speeded up the emergence of the state in the Tamil country and drew different social groups into one religious fold through the temple. Over the centuries it spread across India and transformed Hinduism.
Adi Sankara
The hymns were in simple Tamil; with Adi Sankara (traditionally dated 788-820), Bhakti discourse turned to Sanskrit philosophy. Sankara, from Kaladi in Kerala, taught Advaita (non-dualism), rooted in the Vedanta of the Upanishads, with the doctrine of maya (illusion), and won debates with rival schools. He founded smarta mathas at Sringeri, Dvaraka, Badrinath and Puri, headed by Brahmin pontiffs, and regarded Saiva and Vaishnava worship as two equally important aspects of Vedic religion. The book says his school stressed monastic organisation and the preservation of Sanskrit scriptures, and that he sought to root out Buddhism.
Ramanuja
Ramanuja (traditionally 1017-1137; the book gives 1138), born at Sriperumbudur, first studied under Yadavaprakasa at Kanchipuram in Sankara's school but disagreed with him and was drawn to the Srirangam tradition. Yamunacharya invited him to Srirangam but died as he arrived, and Ramanuja became head of the monastery there, reorganising the temple and its rituals. He challenged Sankara's Advaita with Visishtadvaita (qualified monism) and tried to widen the social base of Vaishnavism, persuading some temple authorities to let groups outside the varnashrama system enter the temple at least once a year. A century after his death his followers split into two schools under Vedanta Desikar and Manavala Mamunigal.
Sankara and Ramanuja (textbook account)
-
Adi Sankara
- From Kaladi, Kerala
- Advaita: non-dualism; the world as maya
- Mathas at Sringeri, Dvaraka, Badrinath, Puri
- Saiva and Vaishnava worship as equal aspects of Vedic religion
-
Ramanuja
- From Sriperumbudur; head at Srirangam
- Visishtadvaita: qualified monism
- Reformed temple ritual
- Opened temple entry, once a year, to groups outside varnashrama
In conclusion, the book says these developments fused north and south Indian traditions into a composite Indian culture, and that the Tamil devotional cult started Bhakti's popularity across India. It cites the historians M.G.S. Narayanan and Kesavan Veluthat, who see Bhakti as a cementing force that brought kings, Brahmin priests and ordinary people together and strengthened the new caste-based Hindu kingdoms.
12 Azhwars - Nalayira Divya Prabandham (Nathamuni). 63 Nayanmars - Panniru Tirumurai (Nambi Andar Nambi; Thevaram = books 1-7; Periyapuranam = book 12). Sankara: Advaita. Ramanuja: Visishtadvaita.
Worked example 1: placing the Tirumurai books
Question: In which Tirumurai books would you find the hymns of Appar and of Manikkavasagar, and how many books make up the Thevaram? Working: Sambandar fills books 1-3, Appar books 4-6, Sundarar book 7, so the Thevaram is books 1 to 7: 7 books. Manikkavasagar's Tiruvasagam is book 8. Answer: Appar 4-6; Manikkavasagar 8; the Thevaram is 7 books of the 12.
Worked example 2: protest and integration together
Question: The book says Bhakti protested against Brahmin exclusiveness, yet also strengthened caste-based kingdoms. Can both be true? Working: (1) The saints taught that anyone, of any birth, could reach god through devotion: a protest against exclusive access to grace. (2) But the movement centred on temples, which kings endowed and where invited Brahmin groups performed worship. (3) So it widened religious participation while the social order and royal power were reinforced through temple institutions. Answer: yes; the book presents it as including people emotionally while integrating them into a hierarchical state.
Key takeaways: Tamil Bhakti (6th-9th centuries), patronised by the Pallavas and Pandyas and centred on temples, used simple Tamil and music. Its hymns stress a personal god, protest Brahmin exclusiveness and condemn Jains and Buddhists. The 12 Azhwars' hymns form the Nalayira Divya Prabandham; the 63 Nayanmars' the Panniru Tirumurai. Bhakti made temples central and helped build the state. Sankara taught Advaita and founded four mathas; Ramanuja taught Visishtadvaita and opened temples a little to excluded groups. The book sees a fusion of northern and southern traditions.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who compiled the Nalayira Divya Prabandham?
- Nambi Andar Nambi
- Sekkizhar
- Nathamuni
- Ramanuja
Show answer
Answer: C. Nathamuni, a priest at the Ranganatha temple in Srirangam, compiled the four thousand Vaishnava hymns at the end of the ninth century. Nambi Andar Nambi compiled the Saiva hymns.
-
2. Which Azhwar is considered the greatest, according to the textbook?
- Nammalvar of Kurugur
- Periyalvar
- Andal
- Tirumangai
Show answer
Answer: A. The book says Nammalvar, from Kurugur (Alvar Tirunagari), is considered the greatest of the Azhwars.
-
3. Which of these is NOT one of the three themes of Bhakti hymns listed in the textbook?
- Devotion to a personal god
- Protest against Brahmin exclusiveness
- Condemnation of Jains and Buddhists as heretics
- Rejection of all temple worship
Show answer
Answer: D. The hymns centred on temples; the book's three themes are devotion to a personal god, protest against orthodox Brahmanism and condemnation of Jains and Buddhists.
-
4. Ramanuja's philosophy is known as:
- Advaita
- Visishtadvaita
- Saiva Siddhanta
- Dvaita
Show answer
Answer: B. Ramanuja challenged Sankara's Advaita with Visishtadvaita, described as qualified monism.
-
5. Which collection is the twelfth book of the Saiva canon?
- Thevaram
- Tiruvasagam
- Periyapuranam
- Tiruvaymoli
Show answer
Answer: C. Sekkizhar's Periyapuranam, a hagiography of the 63 Nayanmars, is the twelfth Tirumurai. The Thevaram is books 1-7, Tiruvasagam book 8; Tiruvaymoli is Nammalvar's Vaishnava work.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.