• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

The chromosomal theory of inheritance

Trace how cytologists linked Mendel's factors to chromosomes, state the salient features of the Sutton-Boveri chromosomal theory, and match each Mendelian principle with chromosome behaviour in meiosis.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Outline the discoveries of Roux, Montgomery, Boveri and Sutton.
  • State the salient features of the chromosomal theory of inheritance.
  • Match Mendel's factors with chromosome behaviour during meiosis.
  • Explain why chromosome number alone does not decide a species' characters.

Mendel described factors without knowing where they were. By 1900, better microscopes and stains had revealed thread-like bodies in the dividing nucleus - chromosomes ('coloured bodies'). Once Mendel's work was rediscovered, biologists noticed that chromosomes behave in meiosis exactly as Mendel's factors should. This lesson shows how that link was made.

Chromosomes and genes

A chromosome is a long, continuous, coiled DNA molecule with genes arranged in a linear order; each gene has a definite position, its locus. A diploid organism has two complete basic sets of chromosomes, one from each parent. The chromosomal theory of inheritance states that Mendelian factors (genes) have specific loci on chromosomes, and chromosomes carry them from one generation to the next.

How the theory developed

Milestones named in the Tamil Nadu textbook

  1. Roux (1883) Chromosomes of a cell are responsible for heredity
  2. Montgomery (1901) Chromosomes occur in distinct pairs; maternal pairs with paternal in meiosis
  3. Boveri (1902) Chromosomes contain genetic determiners
  4. Sutton (1902) Parallel between chromosomes and Mendel's factors at gamete formation
  5. Sutton and Boveri (1903) Chromosomal theory of inheritance proposed

T. H. Morgan later received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine (1933) for showing, with Drosophila, the role chromosomes play in heredity.

Salient features of the theory

  • Somatic cells arise from the zygote by mitosis and carry two sets of chromosomes, one maternal and one paternal; the two members of each pair are homologous chromosomes.
  • Chromosomes keep their structural individuality throughout the life cycle.
  • Each chromosome carries specific determiners (Mendelian factors), now called genes.
  • Chromosome behaviour during meiosis provides the evidence that genes lie on chromosomes.
Parallelism noticed by Sutton and Boveri
Mendelian factorsChromosome behaviour
Alleles of a factor occur in pairsChromosomes occur in homologous pairs
The two alleles separate at gamete formation (segregation)Homologous chromosomes separate in anaphase I of meiosis
Different factors assort independentlyDifferent chromosome pairs orient and separate independently - but genes on the SAME chromosome normally do not assort independently

Segregation = homologues separating. Independent assortment = different homologous pairs lining up independently. Genes on one chromosome travel together (linkage).

Chromosome numbers

Diploid chromosome numbers listed in the Tamil Nadu textbook
Plant2n
Haplopappus gracilis4
Arabidopsis10
Onion16
Maize20
Rice24
Apple34
Potato48
Sugarcane80
Ophioglossum (adder's tongue fern)1262

Chromosome number is generally constant within a species, but very different species can share the same number, and the number tells us nothing about complexity. What decides a species' characters is the genetic material carried on the chromosomes, not how many there are.

Worked reasoning example 1: alleles in gametes

A plant is Aa and the gene lies on chromosome 3. Explain, using chromosomes, why half its gametes carry A. Reasoning: (1) One homologue of chromosome 3 carries A and the other carries a. (2) In anaphase I the two homologues go to opposite poles. (3) After meiosis II each gamete has one copy of chromosome 3, either the A-bearing or the a-bearing one, with equal chance. So half the gametes carry A - Mendel's segregation, explained by chromosomes.

Worked reasoning example 2: counting arrangements

A cell has 2n = 6 (three homologous pairs) and is heterozygous for one gene on each pair (AaBbCc). How many kinds of gametes can independent orientation of chromosomes produce? Working: each pair can orient two ways, independently. Kinds of gametes = 2 × 2 × 2 = 2³ = 8. This is the chromosomal reason behind Mendel's independent assortment.

Key takeaways: genes lie in a linear order at fixed loci on chromosomes; Sutton and Boveri (1902-1903) united chromosome behaviour with Mendel's laws; segregation reflects separation of homologues, independent assortment reflects independent orientation of different pairs, and genes on the same chromosome tend to stay together.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who first recognised the parallel between Mendel's factors and chromosome behaviour at gamete formation, as a young American student?

    1. W. S. Sutton
    2. T. Boveri
    3. Wilhelm Roux
    4. T. H. Morgan
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Sutton (1902) noticed that chromosomes and Mendel's factors behave alike during gamete formation; with Boveri he proposed the chromosomal theory (1903). Roux (1883) only suggested chromosomes carry heredity.

  2. 2. Mendel's Law of Segregation is explained at the chromosome level by:

    1. crossing over in pachytene
    2. duplication of chromosomes in S phase
    3. separation of homologous chromosomes during meiosis
    4. fusion of gametes
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Each homologue carries one allele; when homologues separate in meiosis I, each gamete receives only one allele, exactly as the Law of Segregation requires.

  3. 3. Which statement is NOT a feature of the chromosomal theory?

    1. Somatic cells carry a maternal and a paternal set
    2. Chromosomes lose their individuality after each division
    3. Each chromosome carries specific genes
    4. Meiosis gives evidence that genes are on chromosomes
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The theory says chromosomes RETAIN their structural individuality throughout the life cycle. The other three statements are its salient features.

  4. 4. Which plant in the textbook's table has the lowest diploid chromosome number?

    1. Arabidopsis (2n = 10)
    2. Onion (2n = 16)
    3. Maize (2n = 20)
    4. Haplopappus gracilis (2n = 4)
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook lists Haplopappus gracilis with 2n = 4, the smallest in its table.

  5. 5. Why do genes on the same chromosome usually NOT show independent assortment?

    1. They travel to the gamete together on one chromosome
    2. They are always recessive
    3. They are destroyed during meiosis
    4. They lie on non-homologous chromosomes
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Independent assortment needs genes on different chromosome pairs. Genes on one chromosome move as a unit unless crossing over separates them - this is linkage.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery