- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
DNA replication: models, proof and mechanism
Compare conservative, dispersive and semi-conservative replication, interpret the Meselson-Stahl experiment, and describe the enzymes and steps at the replication fork, including leading and lagging strands.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the three proposed models of DNA replication.
- Predict and interpret the bands in the Meselson and Stahl experiment.
- Name the roles of helicase, topoisomerase, primer, DNA polymerases and ligase.
- Explain why one strand is made continuously and the other in Okazaki fragments.
DNA replication takes place in the S phase of the cell cycle. Each DNA molecule must give two molecules identical to each other and to the parent, quickly and with very few errors, because uncorrected errors become mutations.
Three models
Proposed modes of DNA replication
-
Conservative
- Parent double helix stays intact
- An entirely new double helix is made
- One old molecule, one new molecule
-
Dispersive
- Parent molecule broken into fragments
- Each fragment templates new pieces
- Both daughters are patchworks of old and new
-
Semi-conservative
- Proposed by Watson and Crick (1953)
- Strands separate; each templates a new partner
- Each daughter has one old and one new strand
In the semi-conservative model the two strands unwind and separate as the hydrogen bonds between the bases break (these are weak bonds, not covalent ones). Each separated strand acts as a template, and its new partner is complementary to it.
The Meselson and Stahl experiment (1958)
Matthew Meselson and Franklin Stahl grew E. coli for many generations in a medium whose only nitrogen source, NH₄Cl, contained the heavy isotope ¹⁵N, so all its DNA was 'heavy'. DNA of different densities can be separated by caesium chloride (CsCl) density gradient centrifugation: heavy ¹⁵N DNA and light ¹⁴N DNA settle in different bands. They then moved the cells to a medium with ordinary ¹⁴NH₄Cl and took samples as the bacteria divided (about every 20 minutes).
| Sample | Observed | Conservative would give | Semi-conservative gives |
|---|---|---|---|
| Generation 0 | One heavy band | Heavy | Heavy |
| After 1 division (about 20 min) | One intermediate (hybrid) band | One heavy + one light | All hybrid ¹⁵N/¹⁴N |
| After 2 divisions (about 40 min) | One intermediate + one light band | One heavy + three light | Half hybrid, half light |
The single hybrid band after one division rules out conservative replication. After two divisions, a dispersive model would give one band of density between hybrid and light, not two separate bands. The observed pattern matches semi-conservative replication.
Enzymes and mechanism
Replication starts at an origin of replication (ori): one in prokaryotes, many in each long eukaryotic DNA molecule (each unit is a replicon). Since unwinding the whole molecule at once would need too much energy, a small Y-shaped opening, the replication fork, is made; there are two forks at each origin, so replication is bidirectional. Helicase unwinds the strands and topoisomerase (DNA gyrase) relieves the strain. In E. coli, DNA polymerase III is the main replicating enzyme; DNA polymerase I (Kornberg's enzyme) and II are involved in repair. The textbook states that eukaryotes have five types of DNA polymerase. Deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates serve both as building blocks and as the energy source.
DNA polymerase cannot start a chain on its own: it needs a short RNA primer that provides a free 3'-OH. It can only add nucleotides to the 3' end, so new DNA always grows 5' → 3'. Because the two template strands are antiparallel, the new strand on the template running 3' → 5' (towards the fork) is made continuously: the leading strand. On the other template the new strand is made discontinuously, away from the fork, as short Okazaki fragments: the lagging strand. Primers are removed (by the exonuclease activity of DNA polymerase), the gaps filled, and DNA ligase seals the fragments together. Repair enzymes such as nucleases correct errors.
Events at a replication fork
- Origin recognised Helicase and topoisomerase open the helix; two forks form
- RNA primer laid down Provides a 3'-OH end
- DNA polymerase extends 5' → 3' Leading strand continuous; lagging strand in Okazaki fragments
- Primers removed and gaps filled By DNA polymerase activity
- DNA ligase seals Fragments joined into a continuous strand
DNA polymerase adds only at the 3' end, so new DNA grows 5' → 3'. Leading strand: continuous. Lagging strand: Okazaki fragments joined by ligase.
Worked example 1: three generations in ¹⁴N
Heavy (¹⁵N) DNA replicates three times in ¹⁴N medium. What fraction of the DNA molecules is hybrid? Working: start with 1 molecule (2 heavy strands). After 1 round: 2 hybrid. After 2: 2 hybrid + 2 light. After 3: 2 hybrid + 6 light = 8 molecules. The two original heavy strands are never lost, so there are always exactly 2 hybrids. Answer: 2/8 = 1/4 hybrid, 3/4 light.
Worked example 2: replication speed
The textbook gives E. coli about 4.6 × 10⁶ bp replicated in about 18 minutes. Working: 18 min = 18 × 60 = 1080 s. Total rate = 4.6 × 10⁶ ÷ 1080 ≈ 4260 bp per second. Replication runs in two directions from one origin, so each fork works at about 4260 ÷ 2 ≈ 2130 bp per second, which matches the textbook's figure of roughly 2000 bp per second.
Key takeaways: replication is semi-conservative, as Meselson and Stahl proved with ¹⁵N, ¹⁴N and CsCl centrifugation. It begins at origins, opens forks with helicase and topoisomerase, needs RNA primers, and uses DNA polymerase III in E. coli. Because synthesis is only 5' → 3', the leading strand is continuous and the lagging strand is made as Okazaki fragments joined by ligase.
Check your understanding
-
1. Meselson and Stahl's experiment proved:
- Transduction
- Transformation
- That DNA is the genetic material
- The semi-conservative nature of DNA replication
Show answer
Answer: D. Using ¹⁵N and ¹⁴N with CsCl density gradient centrifugation, they showed that each daughter DNA has one old and one new strand.
-
2. E. coli grown on ¹⁵N medium are transferred to ¹⁴N medium for two generations. The DNA shows:
- One high and one low density band
- One intermediate density band
- One low and one intermediate density band
- One high and one intermediate density band
Show answer
Answer: C. After two semi-conservative rounds, half the molecules are hybrid (intermediate) and half fully light (low density).
-
3. The basic reason for the difference between leading and lagging strand synthesis is that:
- DNA polymerase can join new nucleotides only to the 3' end of a growing strand
- The origin occurs only at the 5' end
- DNA ligase works only 3' → 5'
- Helicase works only on one strand
Show answer
Answer: A. DNA polymerase adds nucleotides only to a 3'-OH, so new strands grow 5' → 3'. On the antiparallel template, one strand can grow continuously towards the fork and the other only in short fragments.
-
4. Okazaki fragments are joined together by:
- Helicase
- DNA ligase
- RNA primase
- Topoisomerase
Show answer
Answer: B. After the RNA primers are removed and the gaps filled, DNA ligase seals the fragments of the lagging strand into one continuous strand.
-
5. Which statement about DNA replication is NOT correct?
- Unwinding occurs as hydrogen bonds between bases break
- Each base pairs with another exactly like itself
- It is semi-conservative because one old strand is kept in each new molecule
- Complementary bases are held by hydrogen bonds
Show answer
Answer: B. Bases pair with complementary partners (A with T, G with C), not with identical bases. The other statements are correct.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.