• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

The gene and the search for the genetic material

Trace the idea of the gene from Mendel's factors to the one gene-one polypeptide hypothesis, and explain how the experiments of Avery, MacLeod and McCarty and of Hershey and Chase showed that DNA is the genetic material.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the classical properties of genes and the one gene-one enzyme and one gene-one polypeptide hypotheses.
  • Outline the early history from chromosomes to 'nuclein'.
  • Explain how Avery, MacLeod and McCarty identified the transforming principle.
  • Explain the design and result of the Hershey-Chase experiment.

Mendel showed that hereditary 'factors' pass from parents to offspring in predictable patterns, but he did not know what those factors were made of. This chapter of the Tamil Nadu textbook follows the story from the gene as an idea to the gene as a stretch of DNA, and then to how DNA is copied, read and controlled. The whole hereditary information of an organism is its genome; a gene is a sequence within it that, in the textbook's words, represents a single protein (or a functional RNA).

The gene as the unit of inheritance

Mendel (1860s) called hereditary units 'factors'. According to the textbook, the Danish biologist Wilhelm Johannsen coined the word gene in 1909. In the classical concept, which the textbook attributes to Sutton (1902), genes are discrete particles that follow Mendel's rules, occupy a definite locus on a chromosome and control a particular character. Their classical properties:

  • There are far more genes than chromosomes, so many genes lie on each chromosome.
  • Genes are arranged in a single line, like beads on a string, each at its own locus.
  • A gene may exist in alternative forms (alleles) and may change suddenly (mutation).
  • Genes can copy themselves.

In the early 1940s George Beadle and Edward Tatum, working with the red bread mould Neurospora crassa, proposed the one gene-one enzyme hypothesis: one gene controls the production of one enzyme. Since many enzymes are built of more than one polypeptide chain, each made by a different gene, this was refined to one gene-one polypeptide.

Towards DNA

Early steps in the search (dates as in the textbook)

  1. 1848: Hofmeister Saw nuclei organise into rod-like chromosomes in mitosis
  2. 1869: Miescher Isolated 'nuclein' from cell nuclei
  3. 1889: Altmann Renamed it nucleic acid; now known as DNA
  4. By 1920 Chromosomes known to contain protein and DNA
  5. 1928: Griffith Bacterial transformation discovered (Class XI); its chemical cause unknown

Since chromosomes hold roughly equal amounts of protein and DNA, many biologists thought protein, with its twenty kinds of building blocks, was the only molecule varied enough to carry genetic information. Griffith's transformation of harmless R-strain pneumococci into virulent S-strain by heat-killed S cells showed that something carried hereditary information, but not what.

Avery, MacLeod and McCarty (1944)

These workers repeated Griffith's experiment outside the living host (in vitro). They prepared an extract of heat-killed S cells containing DNA, RNA and protein. Added to R cells, it turned some of them into smooth, virulent S cells. They then treated portions of the extract with enzymes: DNase (destroys DNA) abolished transformation, while RNase (destroys RNA) and proteases (destroy proteins) did not. So the transforming substance was DNA. Transformation is the change in which DNA taken from one type of cell gives another type some of the first type's properties.

Hershey and Chase (1952)

Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase worked with phage T2, a virus of Escherichia coli made only of DNA inside a protein coat. They used a difference in chemistry: DNA contains phosphorus but no sulphur; proteins contain sulphur (in cysteine and methionine). Phages grown with radioactive ³⁵S had labelled protein; phages grown with ³²P had labelled DNA. Each kind was allowed to infect unlabelled bacteria. Before the bacteria burst, the cultures were agitated in a blender to shake off phage coats and then centrifuged: heavier bacteria formed a pellet, lighter phage coats stayed in the liquid (supernatant).

Results of the Hershey-Chase experiment
LabelLabels whatRadioactivity found inConclusion
³⁵SProtein coatSupernatant, not the bacteria; not in progeny phagesProtein stays outside
³²PDNABacterial cells; also in progeny phagesDNA enters and is inherited

DNase stops transformation; RNase and protease do not (Avery and colleagues). ³²P enters the bacteria, ³⁵S does not (Hershey and Chase). DNA is the genetic material.

Worked reasoning example 1: why not carbon or nitrogen?

Could Hershey and Chase have used radioactive carbon or nitrogen instead? Reasoning: (1) The design depends on a label found in only one of the two molecules. (2) Both DNA and protein contain carbon and nitrogen, so either label would appear in both and could not tell them apart. (3) Phosphorus is in DNA but not in phage protein, and sulphur in protein but not in DNA. Answer: no; carbon and nitrogen would label both, so the experiment would give no clear answer.

Worked reasoning example 2: predicting an enzyme test

Suppose an S-cell extract is treated with both RNase and protease, but not DNase, and then added to R cells. Will transformation occur? Reasoning: (1) RNase removes RNA and protease removes protein. (2) DNA remains intact. (3) DNA is the transforming principle. Answer: yes, transformation still occurs.

Key takeaways: a gene is a unit at a fixed locus that controls a character; one gene-one enzyme became one gene-one polypeptide. Avery, MacLeod and McCarty showed that only DNase destroys the transforming principle. Hershey and Chase showed that phage DNA (³²P), not protein (³⁵S), enters bacteria and reaches the progeny, convincing biologists that DNA is the genetic material.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Hershey and Chase experiment with bacteriophage showed that:

    1. Protein gets into the bacterial cells
    2. DNA is the genetic material
    3. DNA contains radioactive sulphur
    4. Viruses undergo transformation
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Only ³²P-labelled DNA entered the bacteria and appeared in progeny phages, while ³⁵S-labelled protein stayed outside, showing DNA is the genetic material.

  2. 2. In the experiment of Avery, MacLeod and McCarty, transformation was lost when the extract was treated with:

    1. RNase
    2. Protease
    3. DNase
    4. Lipase
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Only DNase, which destroys DNA, abolished transformation. RNase and proteases did not, so DNA was the transforming substance.

  3. 3. The one gene-one enzyme hypothesis was proposed by:

    1. Beadle and Tatum
    2. Hershey and Chase
    3. Watson and Crick
    4. Meselson and Stahl
    Show answer

    Answer: A. George Beadle and Edward Tatum proposed it in the early 1940s from work on Neurospora crassa.

  4. 4. Why was radioactive sulphur used to label the protein of phage T2?

    1. Proteins contain phosphorus but DNA does not
    2. DNA contains sulphur
    3. Sulphur labels both DNA and protein equally
    4. Proteins contain sulphur (in cysteine and methionine) but DNA does not
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Sulphur occurs in the amino acids cysteine and methionine but not in DNA, so ³⁵S labels only protein. Phosphorus labels only DNA.

  5. 5. Which is a property of genes in the classical concept?

    1. There are fewer genes than chromosomes
    2. Genes are arranged in a linear order on chromosomes
    3. Genes never mutate
    4. Each gene occupies several loci
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Genes lie in a single linear order like beads on a string, each at its own locus. There are more genes than chromosomes, and genes can mutate.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery