- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Duties and liabilities of directors; registers; manager, MD and whole-time director
Explain the collective, general and specific duties of directors, their liability to outsiders, to the company and under criminal law, the register of directors and KMP, and compare a manager with a director and an MD with a whole-time director.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the collective, general and specific duties of directors.
- Explain when directors are liable to outsiders, to the company and criminally.
- Compare manager and director, and managing director and whole-time director.
Power brings duty. Directors handle other people's money, so the law expects good faith and care from them, and makes them answer personally when they fail. This lesson ends the chapter by placing directors beside managers and comparing the two kinds of executive director.
This lesson explains company law as the Tamil Nadu textbook presents it, corrected where the Act says otherwise, for study only. It is not legal advice; limits and rules are amended from time to time.
Duties of directors
Because directors act as agents and trustees, they owe a fiduciary duty to the company: they must act in good faith in its best interest, make no secret profit, act with due care and diligence, and not delegate their work unless the Act or the articles allow it (or specialised expertise demands it).
| Kind | Examples from the textbook |
|---|---|
| Collective (as a Board) | Approve and authenticate annual accounts; present the directors' report; appoint the first auditors; call and hold Board and general meetings; pass resolutions at meetings or by circulation |
| General | Frame policies; delegate to committees where the articles permit; instruct employees; appoint MD, manager and secretary; act according to the articles, in good faith and with reasonable care |
| Specific | Disclose name, address, occupation, shareholding and interest in the company's contracts; see that the prospectus is true and signed; keep application money in a scheduled bank; file returns of allotment and other documents with the Registrar; pay declared dividends; call the annual and extraordinary general meetings |
Liabilities of directors
Liabilities of directors
-
To outsiders
- Contracts in personal capacity
- Contracts for an undisclosed principal or a company not yet formed
- Ultra vires contracts
- Mis-statement in prospectus; irregular allotment; failure to repay application money
-
To the company
- Ultra vires acts, such as paying dividend out of capital
- Breach of trust, such as using company property for themselves
- Misfeasance (wilful negligence)
-
Criminal
- Fine, imprisonment or both for statutory defaults: mis-statement in prospectus, failure to file returns, to issue certificates, to keep registers, to hold the AGM or to provide financial statements
Directors acting within their powers are not personally liable to outsiders: the company is. The textbook notes that mere failure to recover a debt due to the company is not misfeasance.
Register of directors and KMP
Every company must keep at its registered office a register of directors and KMP, recording each person's DIN (or PAN for KMP without a DIN), names, parents' and spouse's names, date of birth, addresses, nationality, occupation, dates of appointment and cessation with reasons, offices held in other bodies corporate, and, for a company secretary, ICSI membership number. It must also record the securities each of them holds in the company and its group companies. Other statutory registers include those of members, debenture holders, loans and investments, and contracts in which directors are interested.
Comparisons
| Basis | Manager | Director |
|---|---|---|
| Position | In charge of a department and its performance | Appointed by shareholders to lead the company |
| Work | Allocates work and tells subordinates what, when and how | Frames policies and gives fundamental guidelines to managers |
| Level | Middle (executive) level | Top level |
| Responsibility | Implements plans and policies | Formulates plans and policies |
| Basis | Managing director | Whole-time director |
|---|---|---|
| Powers | Substantial powers of management, under the Board | Powers as stated in the terms of employment |
| Simultaneous posts | A company may not have an MD and a manager at the same time (s.196) | May act as a director in whole-time employment |
| Appointment and term | Appointed for at most five years at a time; Board appointment approved by the general meeting (s.196) | Same five-year limit and approval rule apply |
Duty of good faith and care; liability when acting beyond powers, in breach of trust or with wilful negligence.
Worked example 1: whose liability?
Made-up: directors of Nilgiri Tea Ltd (a) pay a dividend out of capital when there are no profits; (b) use the company's guest house for a family holiday free of charge; (c) fail to hold the annual general meeting. Reasoning: (a) an ultra vires act, so liability to the company; (b) breach of trust, so they must make good the loss; (c) a statutory default, so criminal liability (fine) may follow.
Worked example 2: MD and manager together?
Made-up: Ooty Mills Ltd has a managing director and now wants to appoint a separate 'manager' (in the Act's sense) for the whole company, and to reappoint its MD for seven years. Reasoning: section 196 forbids having an MD and a manager at the same time, so it cannot appoint both. It also limits each appointment of an MD, whole-time director or manager to five years at a time, so seven years is not allowed; it may reappoint for up to five.
Key takeaways: directors owe fiduciary duties of good faith and care, with collective, general and specific duties; they are liable to outsiders when they exceed their powers, to the company for ultra vires acts, breach of trust and misfeasance, and criminally for statutory defaults; a register of directors and KMP is kept at the registered office; directors frame policy while managers implement it; an MD and a manager cannot be appointed together, and each executive appointment is for at most five years.
Check your understanding
-
1. Directors who use company property for their own benefit are guilty of:
- misfeasance only
- breach of trust
- lawful use
- an ultra vires contract with outsiders
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook gives use of the company's property for directors' own benefit as its example of breach of trust; they must make good the loss.
-
2. According to the textbook, mere failure to take steps to recover a debt due to the company:
- is misfeasance
- is breach of trust
- is a criminal offence
- does not constitute misfeasance
Show answer
Answer: D. Misfeasance covers wilful negligence; the textbook states mere failure to recover a debt does not amount to it.
-
3. Who formulates plans and policies: a manager or a director?
- A director
- A manager
- Neither
- The auditor
Show answer
Answer: A. Directors, at the top level, formulate plans and policies; managers, at the middle level, implement them.
-
4. For how long at a time can a managing director be appointed?
- Ten years
- Three years
- Five years
- For life
Show answer
Answer: C. Section 196 limits the appointment of an MD, whole-time director or manager to five years at a time.
-
5. Paying dividend out of capital makes directors liable to the company because it is:
- an ultra vires act
- an act of misfeasance by outsiders
- a duty under the Act
- required by the articles
Show answer
Answer: A. Applying funds to purposes not allowed, such as paying dividends out of capital, is ultra vires, and directors are liable to the company.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.