- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Removal, remuneration, powers and rights of directors
Explain how directors are removed, the limits on managerial remuneration under section 197, the Board's powers under sections 179 and 180, and the individual and collective rights of directors.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain removal of directors by shareholders and by the Tribunal.
- Apply the percentage limits on managerial remuneration.
- Classify directors' powers and rights.
Directors hold power, so the law sets how they can lose office, how much they can be paid and which decisions need the shareholders' approval. This lesson covers those controls, and the rights directors have to do their job.
This lesson explains company law as the Tamil Nadu textbook presents it, corrected where the Act says otherwise, for study only. It is not legal advice; limits and rules are amended from time to time.
Removal of directors
- By shareholders (section 169): a company may remove a director before the end of the term by an ordinary resolution after special notice, without having to prove misconduct; the director must be given a chance to be heard. Shareholders may do this simply because they disagree with the director's policies.
- By the Tribunal: on an application complaining of oppression and mismanagement, the National Company Law Tribunal may end a director's appointment or set aside an agreement between the company and the director. The grounds the textbook lists include fraud, misfeasance, persistent negligence, conduct contrary to sound business principles or injurious to trade, and intent to defraud creditors or members.
The textbook also refers to removal by the Central Government on the recommendation of the Company Law Board. That was the earlier law; as chapter 26 explained, the Company Law Board was replaced by the National Company Law Tribunal.
Remuneration
Remuneration means money or its equivalent for services, including perquisites such as rent-free accommodation, goods or services at concessional rates, securities or sweat equity allotted, employer contributions to an approved superannuation fund, other fringe benefits and stock options. Under section 197, the total managerial remuneration of a public company to its directors, including the MD, whole-time directors and manager, must not exceed 11% of net profit (computed under section 198). Within that, one MD, whole-time director or manager may get up to 5%, and if there are more than one, 10% for all of them together. Where profits are absent or inadequate, payment is limited by the scale in Schedule V of the Act, which has been revised over time.
Powers of the Board
| Group | Examples |
|---|---|
| Powers exercised by resolution at a Board meeting (s.179(3)) | Make calls on unpaid share money; issue securities including debentures; borrow; invest funds; grant loans; diversify the business; approve amalgamation, merger or reconstruction; approve financial statements and the Board's report |
| Managerial powers | Contract with third parties; allot, forfeit or transfer shares; set terms of debentures; frame policies; appoint MD, manager and secretary; supervise subordinates |
| Powers needing the shareholders' resolution (s.180, s.181) | Sell or lease the whole or substantially the whole undertaking; borrow beyond paid-up capital and free reserves; give a director more time to repay a debt; contribute to charitable funds beyond 5% of average net profits of the three preceding years |
| Other powers | Fill casual vacancies; appoint the first auditor; appoint additional and alternate directors and KMP; recommend interim and final dividend |
Rights of directors
Rights of directors
-
Individual rights
- Inspect books of account
- Receive notice of Board meetings
- Take part and vote at meetings
- Receive draft circular resolutions
- Inspect minutes of Board meetings
-
Collective rights (as a Board)
- Refuse transfer of shares in a private company
- Elect a chairman of Board meetings
- Appoint the MD or manager
- Recommend dividend; shareholders may reduce but not raise it
Removal: ordinary resolution with special notice. Remuneration cap: 11% of net profit overall; 5% for one MD/WTD/manager, 10% for more than one.
Worked example 1: remuneration limits
Made-up: a public company's net profit (as computed under section 198) is ₹40 crore. It has one managing director and no other whole-time director or manager. Working: overall limit = 40 × 11 ÷ 100 = ₹4.4 crore for all directors and the manager. The MD's limit = 40 × 5 ÷ 100 = ₹2 crore. If it also had a whole-time director, the two together could get up to 40 × 10 ÷ 100 = ₹4 crore.
Worked example 2: Board or shareholders?
Made-up decisions for Madurai Motors Ltd (paid-up capital plus free reserves ₹50 crore): (a) invest surplus funds in government securities; (b) borrow so that total borrowings reach ₹70 crore; (c) approve the annual financial statements. Reasoning: (a) and (c) are powers exercised by resolution at a Board meeting. (b) takes borrowings beyond paid-up capital and free reserves (70 > 50), so it needs the shareholders' resolution under section 180.
Key takeaways: shareholders can remove a director by ordinary resolution after special notice, and the Tribunal can remove one for oppression or mismanagement; managerial remuneration is capped at 11% of net profit, with 5% for one and 10% for several executive directors or managers; some powers belong to the Board, others need shareholders' approval; directors have individual rights to information and collective rights such as recommending dividends.
Check your understanding
-
1. Shareholders can remove a director before the end of his term by:
- a special resolution only
- an ordinary resolution after special notice
- an order of the Registrar
- a vote of the Board
Show answer
Answer: B. Section 169 allows removal by ordinary resolution after special notice; no proof of misconduct is needed.
-
2. A public company's net profit is ₹20 crore and it has one managing director only. The MD's remuneration may not exceed:
- ₹2.2 crore
- ₹2 crore
- ₹1 crore
- ₹0.5 crore
Show answer
Answer: C. For a single MD, whole-time director or manager the limit is 5% of net profit: 20 × 5 ÷ 100 = ₹1 crore.
-
3. Which power needs the shareholders' resolution under section 180?
- Borrowing beyond paid-up capital and free reserves
- Making calls on unpaid share money
- Approving the Board's report
- Investing the company's funds
Show answer
Answer: A. Borrowing beyond paid-up capital and free reserves requires shareholders' approval; the others are exercised by Board resolution.
-
4. With regard to the dividend recommended by the Board, shareholders can:
- increase it
- compel payment of a higher rate
- ignore the Board and declare any rate
- reduce it, but not increase it
Show answer
Answer: D. Payment of dividend is the Board's prerogative to recommend; shareholders may reduce the recommended rate but cannot raise it.
-
5. Which is an individual right of a director?
- To inspect books of account
- To refuse transfer of shares
- To appoint the managing director
- To recommend dividend
Show answer
Answer: A. Inspecting books is an individual right; the other three are collective rights of the Board.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.