• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Advantages and disadvantages of MBO

Explain the eleven advantages of MBO listed in the textbook and the five disadvantages that arise when it is applied, with examples.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the advantages of MBO for managers, workers and the organisation.
  • Explain the disadvantages of MBO as the textbook states them.
  • Judge in a given case whether MBO is helping or hurting.

MBO sounds attractive: people set their own goals, work with self-control and are judged by results. In practice it has real benefits but also real costs. The textbook lists eleven advantages and five disadvantages; long-answer questions usually ask for any five.

Advantages of MBO

  1. Commitment: managers at various levels take part in setting objectives, and that commitment ensures hard work to achieve them.
  2. Clear role: managers understand their role in the organisation as a whole.
  3. Respect for planning: managers recognise the need for planning and appreciate it.
  4. Participative management: subordinates too are involved in goal setting.
  5. No cross purposes: each department's objectives agree with the whole organisation's, so departments do not work against each other.
  6. Systematic evaluation: performance is evaluated systematically.
  7. Criteria for performance: MBO gives the yardstick of performance and helps take corrective action.
  8. Easy delegation: authority is easily delegated, since each person's targets are known.
  9. Job enrichment: workers are motivated because jobs become more meaningful.
  10. Fixed responsibility: each worker's responsibility is clearly fixed.
  11. Quick decisions: decisions are taken quickly, since each worker knows the purpose of a decision and does not oppose it.

Disadvantages of MBO

The textbook says these disadvantages arise from the way MBO is applied:

  1. Philosophy not explained: many executives do not know what MBO is, how it works, why it is needed or how participants benefit.
  2. Time, cost and paper work: framing MBO takes much of senior people's time, involves heavy expenditure and needs a lot of paper work.
  3. Short-term emphasis: MBO tends to stress short-term objectives and neglect long-term ones.
  4. Status problem: proper goal setting needs a certain status for subordinates, which is not possible in the MBO process.
  5. Rigidity: objectives should change with circumstances, external or internal; if they are not changed, planned results cannot be obtained.

MBO: benefits and drawbacks at a glance

  • Advantages
    • Commitment and clear roles
    • Participative management
    • No departments at cross purposes
    • Systematic evaluation and criteria
    • Easy delegation, fixed responsibility
    • Job enrichment, quick decisions
  • Disadvantages
    • Philosophy not understood
    • Time consuming, costly, paper work
    • Stress on short-term objectives
    • Status of subordinates a problem
    • Rigid if objectives are not revised

Notice that the textbook's features of MBO (Lesson 2) say goals are combined long-run with short-run and refined with experience, while its disadvantages say MBO stresses short-term objectives and can be rigid. These are not contradictions: the features describe what MBO aims at, and the disadvantages describe what often goes wrong when it is applied badly.

MBO works when people understand it and goals are revised with change; it fails when it becomes paper work, short-term and rigid.

Worked example 1: advantage or disadvantage?

In a made-up company: (a) each branch manager now knows exactly which targets she answers for; (b) the head office spends six weeks filling in goal forms for 400 staff; (c) a target fixed before a sudden price war is not changed. Reasoning: (a) is fixed responsibility, an advantage; (b) shows MBO as time consuming with heavy paper work, a disadvantage; (c) is rigidity, a disadvantage, because objectives were not changed with circumstances.

Worked example 2: counting the cost

Suppose (made-up figures) 20 senior managers each spend 30 hours a year on framing MBO, and an hour of a senior manager's time costs the firm ₹1,500. Working: total hours = 20 × 30 = 600; cost = 600 × ₹1,500 = ₹9,00,000. If MBO raises profit by more than this, it is worth it; if not, its 'heavy expenditure' disadvantage outweighs the gains. This is why the textbook warns about the cost of MBO.

Key takeaways: MBO brings commitment, clear roles, participative management, consistent departmental goals, systematic evaluation, easy delegation, job enrichment, fixed responsibility and quick decisions; its disadvantages are poorly explained philosophy, time, cost and paper work, short-term emphasis, the status problem and rigidity.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Delegation of authority is easily done with the help of:

    1. MBE
    2. MBO
    3. rule of thumb
    4. scalar chain only
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook lists easy delegation of authority among the advantages of MBO.

  2. 2. Which is a disadvantage of MBO according to the textbook?

    1. It is time consuming and needs heavy paper work
    2. It fixes responsibility
    3. It gives criteria of performance
    4. It enriches jobs
    Show answer

    Answer: A. MBO is time consuming, leads to heavy expenditure and needs heavy paper work. The other options are advantages.

  3. 3. Under MBO a department does not work at cross purposes with another because:

    1. departments never meet
    2. only one department exists
    3. each department's objectives are consistent with the whole organisation's
    4. the government fixes the objectives
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Each department's objectives are derived from and consistent with the organisation's objectives.

  4. 4. Objectives that are not changed when circumstances change show which disadvantage of MBO?

    1. Job enrichment
    2. Quick decisions
    3. Participative management
    4. Rigidity
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says MBO is rigid: if objectives are not changed with changed circumstances, the planned results cannot be obtained.

  5. 5. 15 made-up managers each spend 40 hours on MBO paper work, and an hour costs ₹1,200. What is the total cost?

    1. ₹7,20,000
    2. ₹72,000
    3. ₹6,00,000
    4. ₹48,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Hours = 15 × 40 = 600. Cost = 600 × ₹1,200 = ₹7,20,000.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Management by Exception (MBE)

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery