• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Management by Exception (MBE)

Explain management by exception as a control principle, follow its process with a tolerance-limit example, and state its advantages and disadvantages.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the meaning of management by exception and the belief behind it.
  • Describe the process of MBE using a tolerance limit.
  • State the advantages and disadvantages of MBE.

A school principal who checked every student's every homework would never find time to run the school. Instead, class teachers handle routine matters and report only serious cases. That is management by exception (MBE): senior managers attend only to cases that go beyond an accepted limit.

Meaning of MBE

The textbook describes MBE as an important principle of managerial control suggested by the classical writers on management. It rests on the belief that an attempt to control everything results in controlling nothing. MBE is a style of management that focuses on identifying and handling cases that deviate from the norm.

The textbook adds that MBE has a general business application and a business intelligence application. General business exceptions are cases that depart from the normal course of a business process and need special handling, usually by a person. Their causes may include process deviation, infrastructure or connectivity problems, external deviation, poor business rules and malformed data.

Process of MBE

Process of MBE

  1. Set norms Objectives or standards with expected results
  2. Measure and compare Actual performance against the norm
  3. Analyse deviation Is the gap insignificant or significant?
  4. Insignificant: no action Seniors attend to other matters
  5. Significant: report Passed to senior managers as an 'exception'
  6. Solve at once The exception is dealt with immediately

The textbook's illustration is a quality limit. Suppose a production manager allows up to five defects in every 100 units. As long as defects do not exceed five, supervisors or foremen deal with them. When defects go above five, the matter is reported to the production manager.

Advantages of MBE

  1. Saves managers' time: they deal only with exceptional matters; routine problems are left to subordinates.
  2. Focus on major problems: managerial talent and energy are better used.
  3. Easier delegation: top management concentrates on strategic decisions and leaves operational ones to lower levels; the span of control increases, which motivates and develops subordinates.
  4. Separates important from unimportant information: managers must study past records and business data to spot deviations, making better use of trends and history.
  5. Keeps management alert: by identifying critical problems it warns of opportunities and threats and helps avoid uninformed, impulsive action.
  6. Better yardsticks: it gives clear standards for judging results, which helps objective performance appraisal.

Disadvantages of MBE

  1. Demotivation: only managers hold power over really important decisions, which can demotivate employees at lower levels.
  2. Delay and difficult cases: passing issues up to managers takes time. The textbook also notes that employees who deviate from normal procedures are hard to manage; their compliance failures can leave them with limited duties and may finally end in dismissal.
MBO and MBE side by side
PointMBOMBE
Main ideaGoals set jointly and achieved with self-controlSeniors act only on significant deviations
Chiefly a tool ofPlanning, motivation and appraisalControl
Senior managers' attentionOn setting and reviewing goals with subordinatesOn exceptional cases only

MBE: try to control everything and you control nothing. Set a norm, let subordinates handle what is within it, and report only the exceptions.

Worked example 1: applying a tolerance limit

Using the textbook's limit of 5 defects per 100 units, a made-up factory inspects three batches of 400 units each. Allowed defects per batch = 5 × (400 ÷ 100) = 5 × 4 = 20. Batch A: 14 defects, within 20, handled by the foreman. Batch B: 20 defects, exactly at the limit, which does not exceed 5 per 100, so still handled by the foreman. Batch C: 27 defects, which is 27 ÷ 4 = 6.75 per 100, above 5, so it is an exception and is reported to the production manager.

Worked example 2: significant or not?

A made-up company tells branch managers to report only if monthly expenses exceed budget by more than 10%. Branch X has a budget of ₹2,00,000 and spends ₹2,14,000; Branch Y has the same budget and spends ₹2,30,000. Working: X's excess = ₹14,000 = 14,000 ÷ 2,00,000 × 100 = 7%, within the limit, so no report. Y's excess = ₹30,000 = 15%, above 10%, so it is an exception for the senior manager to solve at once.

Key takeaways: MBE is a control principle based on the belief that controlling everything controls nothing; norms are set, actual performance is compared, insignificant deviations need no action and significant ones are passed up as exceptions to be solved at once; it saves time and aids delegation, but can demotivate lower staff and cause delay.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. MBE is based on the belief that:

    1. every matter should go to the top manager
    2. an attempt to control everything results in controlling nothing
    3. workers should set all goals
    4. control is unnecessary
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says MBE rests on the belief that trying to control everything results in controlling nothing.

  2. 2. Which keeps management alert to opportunities and threats by identifying critical problems?

    1. MBA
    2. MBO
    3. MBE
    4. Rule of thumb
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Keeping management alert to opportunities and threats by identifying critical problems is listed as an advantage of MBE.

  3. 3. In the MBE process, what happens when the deviation is insignificant?

    1. No action is required and seniors concentrate on other matters
    2. The matter is reported to the board
    3. The employee is dismissed
    4. The norm is cancelled
    Show answer

    Answer: A. With an insignificant or no deviation, no action is required and senior managers can concentrate on other matters.

  4. 4. Which of these is a disadvantage of MBE?

    1. It saves managers' time
    2. It facilitates delegation
    3. It gives better yardsticks for judging results
    4. Lower-level employees may be demotivated because only managers decide important matters
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook's main disadvantage of MBE is that only managers hold power over important decisions, which can demotivate lower-level employees.

  5. 5. With a limit of 5 defects per 100 units, how many defects are allowed in a batch of 600 units before the matter must be reported?

    1. 25
    2. 30
    3. 35
    4. 60
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Allowed = 5 × (600 ÷ 100) = 5 × 6 = 30. Up to 30 defects is handled by supervisors; more than 30 is an exception.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: MBO and MBE

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery