Revision notes

Chapter 3 Management by Objectives (MBO) and Management by Exception (MBE): Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Meaning, definitions and objectives of MBO

Definitions of MBO in the textbook
WhoThe definition in briefKey words to remember
George Odiorne (who popularised MBO in the USA)Superior and subordinate managers jointly identify common goals, define each person's main area of responsibility in terms of the results expected, and use these measures to run the unit and assess each member's contribution.Jointly; results expected; measures for assessment
Prof. ReddinSetting effective standards for managerial positions and periodically converting them into measurable, time-bound objectives, linked vertically and horizontally and with future planning.Measurable; time-bound; linked vertically and horizontally

The MBO idea in four steps

  1. Agree goals jointly Superior and subordinate together
  2. Express as results Measurable and time-bound
  3. Work with self-control Each person knows what to achieve
  4. Assess against the goals Contribution judged by results

MBO: goals set jointly, stated as measurable, time-bound results, linked across the organisation, and used to judge each person's contribution.

Key takeaways: MBO is a participative system that harmonises individual and organisational goals and builds self-control; George Odiorne popularised it in the USA; Reddin stresses measurable, time-bound objectives linked vertically and horizontally; its eight objectives range from judging performance to organisational control and integration.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Features of MBO

Features of MBO grouped (a memory aid)

  • About goals
    • Integrates individual and organisational goals
    • Combines long-run and short-run goals
    • Relates organisational goals to society's goals
    • Goals refined with experience
  • About performance
    • Stresses effective performance, not goals alone
    • Raises capability at all levels
  • About people and climate
    • Motivation and satisfaction
    • Participation in goal setting
    • Consultation replaces authority
    • Trust, goodwill and will to perform
The textbook lists the ten features in one sequence; this grouping only helps recall.
Ordinary target setting compared with MBO
PointTarget given from aboveMBO
Who sets the goalSuperior aloneSuperior and subordinate jointly
StyleExercise of authorityConsultation
Goals and societyNot consideredRelated to society's goals
ChangeFixed onceRefined and modified with experience
ClimateFear of failureTrust, goodwill and will to perform

MBO's features in one line: joint, integrated, refined goals; stress on performance; participation and consultation in a climate of trust.

Key takeaways: MBO integrates individual and organisational goals, joins long-run with short-run goals and relates them to society; it stresses performance, refines goals with experience and raises capability at all levels; it motivates through participation and consultation and builds trust, goodwill and a will to perform.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

The process of MBO

Process of MBO

  1. 1. Define organisational objectives
  2. 2. Goals of each section
  3. 3. Fix key result areas
  4. 4. Set subordinate objectives
  5. 5. Match resources with objectives
  6. 6. Periodical review meetings
  7. 7. Appraisal of activities
  8. 8. Reappraisal of objectives

Then back to step 1: 1. Define organisational objectives

Reappraisal leads back to fresh objectives, so the process repeats.

MBO order: Objectives of organisation → Section goals → KRAs → Subordinate targets → Resources → Review → Appraisal → Reappraisal.

Key takeaways: the first step of MBO is defining organisational objectives at the top; KRAs such as profitability, market standing and innovation are fixed in order of priority; subordinate targets are set by discussion, preferably in numbers; objectives are matched to resources; periodical reviews, appraisal and reappraisal complete the cycle.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Advantages and disadvantages of MBO

MBO: benefits and drawbacks at a glance

  • Advantages
    • Commitment and clear roles
    • Participative management
    • No departments at cross purposes
    • Systematic evaluation and criteria
    • Easy delegation, fixed responsibility
    • Job enrichment, quick decisions
  • Disadvantages
    • Philosophy not understood
    • Time consuming, costly, paper work
    • Stress on short-term objectives
    • Status of subordinates a problem
    • Rigid if objectives are not revised

MBO works when people understand it and goals are revised with change; it fails when it becomes paper work, short-term and rigid.

Key takeaways: MBO brings commitment, clear roles, participative management, consistent departmental goals, systematic evaluation, easy delegation, job enrichment, fixed responsibility and quick decisions; its disadvantages are poorly explained philosophy, time, cost and paper work, short-term emphasis, the status problem and rigidity.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Management by Exception (MBE)

Process of MBE

  1. Set norms Objectives or standards with expected results
  2. Measure and compare Actual performance against the norm
  3. Analyse deviation Is the gap insignificant or significant?
  4. Insignificant: no action Seniors attend to other matters
  5. Significant: report Passed to senior managers as an 'exception'
  6. Solve at once The exception is dealt with immediately
MBO and MBE side by side
PointMBOMBE
Main ideaGoals set jointly and achieved with self-controlSeniors act only on significant deviations
Chiefly a tool ofPlanning, motivation and appraisalControl
Senior managers' attentionOn setting and reviewing goals with subordinatesOn exceptional cases only

MBE: try to control everything and you control nothing. Set a norm, let subordinates handle what is within it, and report only the exceptions.

Key takeaways: MBE is a control principle based on the belief that controlling everything controls nothing; norms are set, actual performance is compared, insignificant deviations need no action and significant ones are passed up as exceptions to be solved at once; it saves time and aids delegation, but can demotivate lower staff and cause delay.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery