• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Stock exchange traders and types of speculators

Explain the roles of remisiers, authorised clerks, brokers and jobbers, distinguish speculation from gambling, and explain the four types of speculators: bull, bear, stag and lame duck.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Distinguish remisiers, authorised clerks, brokers and jobbers.
  • Distinguish speculation from gambling.
  • Explain bull, bear, stag and lame duck with worked examples.

A stock exchange has its own cast of characters. Some act for others and earn a commission; some trade on their own account; and some try to profit from price changes. The textbook describes the main traders and then four kinds of speculators named after animals whose behaviour they resemble.

Stock exchange traders

Traders as the textbook describes them
TraderRoleEarns
RemisierAgent of a member of the stock exchange; brings business to the member (his principal)Commission
Authorised clerkEmployee of a member, appointed to transact business for the employer on the floorSalary plus commission
BrokerCommission agent who brings buyers and sellers together; does not buy or sell on his own behalf; executes clients' ordersCommission (brokerage)
JobberSecurity merchant who buys and sells on his own behalf as an independent operator; cannot deal for the public; called Taravaniwala in IndiaProfit from price differences; barred from taking commission

Speculation and gambling

Speculation means trading a financial instrument with high risk in the expectation of significant returns, taking advantage of price fluctuations. It is common where prices move often and sharply. Gambling, in the textbook's words, involves no reasoning, increases price fluctuations, is unethical and illegal, and performs no economic function. Speculation, by contrast, is described in the textbook as helping to balance demand and supply.

Types of speculators

Speculators named after animals

  • Bull (Tejiwala) Optimistic: expects prices to rise
    • Buys now
    • Hopes to sell later at a higher price
  • Bear (Mandiwala) Pessimistic: expects prices to fall
    • Sells now (without holding the securities)
    • Hopes to buy later at a lower price to deliver
  • Stag Cautious: a 'premium hunter'
    • Applies for new shares in demand
    • Sells at a premium after allotment, before paying the allotment money
  • Lame duck A bear in difficulty
    • Cannot get the securities he agreed to deliver
    • Holders will not sell and the buyer will not carry over

The names come from the animals' behaviour: a bull tosses its victim up in the air, so the bull speculator pushes prices up; a bear presses its victim down, so the bear speculator pushes prices down. A stag is cautious, like the deer; a lame duck struggles to keep up.

Bull buys expecting a rise; bear sells expecting a fall; stag hunts premiums on new issues; lame duck is a bear who cannot deliver.

Worked example 1: a bull and a bear (illustrative)

Bull: expecting a rise, a made-up speculator buys 100 shares at ₹120 and later sells at ₹135. Gain = 100 × (₹135 - ₹120) = 100 × ₹15 = ₹1,500 (ignoring costs). If the price had fallen to ₹110, the loss would be 100 × ₹10 = ₹1,000. Bear: expecting a fall, another agrees to sell 100 shares at ₹120 for later delivery, then buys them at ₹105 to deliver. Gain = 100 × (₹120 - ₹105) = ₹1,500. If the price rose instead, the bear would lose. These examples show how speculators reason; they are not suggestions to trade, since price moves cannot be known in advance.

Worked example 2: a stag

A made-up company's new shares are in heavy demand. A stag applies and is allotted 50 shares at an issue price of ₹60. When trading begins the share is quoted at ₹72, and he sells. Working: premium earned = 50 × (₹72 - ₹60) = 50 × ₹12 = ₹600, before costs. If he had not been allotted shares, or the price had opened below ₹60, he would have earned nothing or lost.

Key takeaways: remisiers are agents of members, authorised clerks are members' employees, brokers act for clients on commission, and jobbers (Taravaniwalas) trade on their own account without commission; speculation involves reasoning and high risk, gambling none; bulls (Tejiwalas) are optimistic, bears (Mandiwalas) pessimistic, stags hunt premiums on new issues, and a lame duck is a bear unable to meet his commitment.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Jobbers transact in a stock exchange:

    1. for their clients
    2. for their own transactions
    3. for other brokers
    4. for other members
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Jobbers buy and sell securities on their own behalf as independent operators and cannot deal on behalf of the public.

  2. 2. A pessimistic speculator who expects prices to fall is a:

    1. stag
    2. bull
    3. lame duck
    4. bear
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A bear (Mandiwala) expects prices to fall; he sells now hoping to buy later at a lower price. He is pessimistic.

  3. 3. Who acts as an agent of a member of the stock exchange and gets a commission for bringing business?

    1. Remisier
    2. Jobber
    3. Authorised clerk
    4. Stag
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A remisier acts as an agent of a member, obtains business for him and earns a commission.

  4. 4. A bear who cannot get the securities he agreed to deliver is called a:

    1. bull
    2. stag
    3. lame duck
    4. jobber
    Show answer

    Answer: C. When a bear finds it difficult to fulfil his commitment, he is said to be struggling like a lame duck.

  5. 5. A made-up bull buys 80 shares at ₹50 and sells them at ₹57. What is his gain, ignoring costs?

    1. ₹570
    2. ₹560
    3. ₹4,560
    4. ₹400
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Gain = 80 × (₹57 - ₹50) = 80 × ₹7 = ₹560.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery