- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Stock exchange vs commodity exchange; recent developments
Distinguish a stock exchange from a commodity exchange, and describe the recent developments the textbook lists: the National Stock Market System (NSE, SHCIL, NCDS, STCI, NSDL), Nifty, Sensex, futures and options.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish a stock exchange from a commodity exchange on the textbook's bases.
- Describe the parts of the National Stock Market System and their roles as the textbook gives them.
- Explain Nifty, Sensex, futures and options in simple terms.
Both stock exchanges and commodity exchanges bring buyers and sellers together and are driven by demand and supply. The difference lies in what is traded and why. The second half of this lesson covers the textbook's 'recent developments', which changed Indian stock trading from paper and trading floors to screens and electronic records.
Stock exchange and commodity exchange
| Basis | Stock exchange | Commodity exchange |
|---|---|---|
| What is traded | Industrial securities such as stocks and bonds, and government securities | Commodities: metals (gold, silver, copper), energy (crude oil, natural gas), agricultural goods (rice, wheat, cocoa), livestock |
| Function | Easy marketability and liquidity of securities | Hedging or price insurance services |
| Object | Capital formation and best use of capital resources | Smooth flow of goods through risk reduction |
| Participants | Investors and speculators | Producers, dealers, traders and speculators |
| Goods suitable | Standardised securities | Only durable, graded goods with large trade volume, price uncertainty and uncontrolled supply |
| Role of speculation | Ensures a broad, ready, liquid and continuous market | Assumes and absorbs price risk |
| Forward contracts | Simple, because securities are fully standardised | Standards must be fixed for deliverable grades |
| Cornering | Easier, as the seller must deliver the agreed securities | Harder, as the seller may deliver standard or other deliverable goods |
Recent developments: the National Stock Market System
The textbook says the liberalisation process changed the structure of the Indian stock market. A National Stock Market System, advocated by the High Powered Group on the Establishment of New Stock Exchanges headed by M. J. Pherwani (the Pherwani Committee), comprises:
- National Stock Exchange (NSE): incorporated in November 1992 (as the textbook states); a country-wide, screen-based, online, order-driven system in which a central computer matches members' buy and sell orders and reports them instantly. The textbook mentions its debt and capital segments.
- Stock Holding Corporation of India Ltd (SHCIL): set up to speed up trading, clearing and settlement; the textbook says it came into being in 1986, began operations in 1988 and was the first depository participant registered with SEBI.
- National Clearance and Depository System (NCDS): created to overcome settlement problems such as counter-party risk, bad and delayed deliveries, and counterfeit or forged scrips.
- Securities Trading Corporation of India (STCI): set up by the RBI in May 1994 with public sector banks and financial institutions, to develop an active secondary market in government securities and PSU bonds.
- National Securities Depository Ltd (NSDL): after the Depositories Act of August 1996, NSDL was inaugurated on 8 November 1996 as India's first depository, beginning paperless settlement. The textbook adds that demat trading began on the NSE on 26 December 1996 and on the BSE on 29 December 1997.
Indices, futures and options
Two indices described in the textbook
-
Nifty (NSE)
- From 'National' and 'Fifty'
- Index of 50 actively traded stocks across sectors
- Market-capitalisation weighted: bigger company, bigger weight
- Used as a benchmark by some mutual funds
-
Sensex (BSE)
- Short for 'Sensitive Index'
- A list of 30 stocks chosen by the BSE
- Selection based on trading volume
- Weights and criteria change over time
A futures market is an auction market where participants buy and sell contracts for delivery on a specified future date. An option gives a party the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell an instrument at a fixed price within a specified period: a call option is a right to buy, and a put option a right to sell. The textbook notes two uses: leverage (gaining from price changes without paying the full price of the share) and hedging (protection against price fluctuations). The textbook also gives normal equity trading hours on the BSE and NSE as 9.15 a.m. to 3.30 p.m., Monday to Friday; such timings are set by the exchanges and can change.
Stock exchange: securities, for capital formation. Commodity exchange: goods, for price-risk insurance. NSE screens + NSDL demat = paperless, floorless trading.
Worked example 1: market-capitalisation weights
A made-up mini-index has three companies with market capitalisation (share price × number of shares) of ₹600 crore, ₹300 crore and ₹100 crore. Working: total = 600 + 300 + 100 = ₹1,000 crore. Weights = 600 ÷ 1,000 = 60%, 300 ÷ 1,000 = 30%, 100 ÷ 1,000 = 10%. If only the largest company's price rises 5%, the index rises by about 60% × 5% = 3%. This is why the textbook says 'larger the size, larger the weightage'.
Worked example 2: hedging with a commodity contract
A made-up rice miller will need 100 quintals of paddy in three months and fears a price rise. He agrees today, on a commodity exchange, to buy at ₹2,000 a quintal for delivery in three months (illustrative price). Working: if the market price rises to ₹2,300, he still pays 100 × ₹2,000 = ₹2,00,000 instead of 100 × ₹2,300 = ₹2,30,000, avoiding ₹30,000 of extra cost. If the price falls to ₹1,800, he pays more than the market price, but he has bought certainty. This is the 'price insurance' function of a commodity exchange.
Key takeaways: a stock exchange trades securities for capital formation; a commodity exchange trades graded goods and provides price insurance; the National Stock Market System, advocated by the Pherwani Committee, includes NSE, SHCIL, NCDS, STCI and NSDL; Nifty is the NSE's 50-stock index and Sensex the BSE's 30-stock index; futures fix future delivery, and options give a right (call to buy, put to sell) without obligation.
Check your understanding
-
1. The main function of a commodity exchange, as compared in the textbook, is:
- providing hedging or price insurance services
- capital formation through share issues
- issuing currency
- fixing interest rates
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says a commodity exchange offers hedging or price insurance services, while a stock exchange provides marketability and liquidity to securities.
-
2. The National Stock Market System was advocated by the committee headed by:
- George Odiorne
- Prof. Reddin
- M. J. Pherwani
- Henry Fayol
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says it was advocated by the High Powered Group on the Establishment of New Stock Exchanges headed by M. J. Pherwani.
-
3. According to the textbook, India's first depository, inaugurated on 8 November 1996, was:
- SHCIL
- STCI
- OTCEI
- NSDL
Show answer
Answer: D. NSDL was inaugurated as the first depository in India on 8 November 1996, after the Depositories Act of August 1996.
-
4. How many stocks make up the Sensex, as the textbook describes it?
- 50
- 30
- 24
- 100
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says Sensex is a list of 30 stocks chosen by the BSE; Nifty has 50.
-
5. In a made-up index, a company's market capitalisation is ₹450 crore out of a total of ₹1,500 crore. What is its weight?
- 45%
- 15%
- 30%
- 33%
Show answer
Answer: C. Weight = 450 ÷ 1,500 × 100 = 30%.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.