• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Economic systems: capitalism, socialism and mixedism

Compare capitalist, socialist and mixed economies on ownership, motive, role of government, price mechanism and income distribution, with the features, merits and demerits of each as the textbook lists them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define an economic system and name its three types.
  • State the features, merits and demerits of capitalism, socialism and mixedism.
  • Compare the three systems on eight points.

Every society must answer the same basic questions: what to produce, how to produce and for whom. An economic system is the manner in which individuals and institutions are connected to carry out economic activities in an area. The textbook describes three systems, two of them opposite extremes and the third a blend.

Capitalism

Adam Smith is called the Father of Capitalism. A capitalist economy, also called a free (laissez-faire) or market economy, has privately owned means of production, a minimum role for government, and markets that decide economic activity. Features: private property and the law of inheritance; freedom of choice and enterprise; the profit motive ('maximise profit' is the producer's golden rule); free competition in product and factor markets; the price mechanism (demand and supply) as the heart of the system; a limited government role (defence, public health, education); and inequality of income between 'haves' and 'have-nots'.

Merits: automatic working, efficient use of resources, incentive for hard work, economic progress, consumer sovereignty (consumers' wishes decide what is produced), high capital formation, and new technology. Demerits: concentration of wealth and income, waste on competitive advertising and duplicate products, class struggle, business cycles, and production of non-essential or even harmful goods when they pay.

The textbook also notes globalism, a term it credits to Manfred Steger (2002) for the market ideology of globalisation that links nations through trade; it is also called 'extended capitalism'.

Socialism

Karl Marx is called the Father of Socialism. Socialism is a system of total planning, public ownership and state control; it is also called a planned or command economy, where a central authority decides what, how and for whom to produce. Features: public ownership of the means of production, central planning, maximum social benefit, no competition, no free price mechanism (prices set by the planning authority), equality of income (no private property or inheritance), equality of opportunity through free health and education, and a classless society.

Merits: fewer inequalities, rational allocation of resources, no class conflict, an end to trade cycles, and social welfare. Demerits: red tape and bureaucracy, no incentive for efficiency, limited consumer choice, and concentration of power in the state. The textbook adds that today there are no absolutely socialist economies.

Mixed economy (mixedism)

In a mixed economy the private and public sectors co-exist and work together; it tries to remove the evils of both extremes. The textbook gives India as an example. Features: ownership by both sectors, co-existence of private (profit) and public (welfare) firms, economic planning that both sectors follow, basic problems solved by both price mechanism and state intervention, and freedom with overall government control. Merits: rapid and balanced growth (agriculture and industry, rural and urban), proper use of resources, progressive taxation for equality, and protection of workers and weaker sections through minimum wages, rationing and fair price shops. Demerits: poor coordination between sectors, a competitive rather than complementary attitude, alleged inefficiency of some public enterprises (the textbook says this criticism is not absolute), fear of nationalisation, and widening inequality.

Comparison of economic systems (based on the textbook's table)
PointCapitalismSocialismMixedism
Ownership of means of productionPrivatePublicPrivate and public
Economic motiveProfitSocial welfareSocial welfare and profit
Solving central problemsFree marketCentral planningBoth planning and market
Role of governmentInternal regulation onlyComplete involvementLimited role
Income distributionUnequalEqualLess unequal
Nature of enterprisePrivateGovernmentBoth
Economic freedomCompleteLackingLimited
Major problemInequalityInefficiencyInequality and inefficiency

Who decides what to produce?

  • Capitalism
    • Consumers and firms through prices
    • Profit guides choices
  • Socialism
    • Central planning authority
    • Social welfare guides choices
  • Mixedism
    • Prices and the state together
    • Plan targets for both sectors

Worked example 1: identify the system

Made-up country X: all factories belong to the state, a planning board fixes prices, and private property cannot be inherited. Working: public ownership, administered prices and no inheritance are features of socialism. Answer: socialist (command) economy.

Worked example 2: a policy and its system

Made-up country Y: private firms run most shops and factories, the government runs railways and fair price shops, and it taxes higher incomes at higher rates. Working: both sectors co-exist (feature of mixedism); fair price shops protect weaker sections and progressive taxation aims at equality (merits of mixedism). Answer: mixed economy.

Key takeaways: capitalism rests on private ownership, profit and the price mechanism; socialism on public ownership, planning and welfare; mixedism combines the two. Each has merits and demerits, and the textbook notes that it is now hard to find a 100 per cent pure form of any system.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The heart of a capitalist economy is:

    1. central planning
    2. the price mechanism
    3. public ownership
    4. the law of inheritance alone
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In capitalism all activities are regulated by market forces of demand and supply, so the price mechanism is its heart. Central planning belongs to socialism.

  2. 2. Which is a demerit of socialism?

    1. Red tape and bureaucracy
    2. Class struggle
    3. Wastage on competitive advertising
    4. Production of harmful goods for profit
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Decisions pass through many officials, causing red tape. The other three are demerits the textbook lists for capitalism.

  3. 3. 'Consumers' desire determines what to produce.' This merit is called:

    1. Equality of opportunity
    2. Rational allocation
    3. Consumer sovereignty
    4. Balanced growth
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Consumers act like sovereigns because production is aimed at satisfying them; this is consumer sovereignty, a merit of capitalism.

  4. 4. In the textbook's comparison table, the income distribution of a mixed economy is:

    1. Equal
    2. Unequal
    3. Completely equal
    4. Less unequal
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Capitalism is unequal, socialism equal, and mixedism in between: less unequal, because of progressive taxation and welfare measures alongside private ownership.

  5. 5. Fixing minimum wages and running fair price shops are given as merits of which system?

    1. Mixed economy
    2. Pure capitalism
    3. Globalism
    4. None of these
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook lists these as special advantages to society in a mixed economy, where the government protects workers and weaker sections.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery