- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Scope and limitations of macro economics
Describe the main areas macro economics covers, from national income and inflation to business cycles, poverty, growth and policy, and state its four limitations, including the fallacy of composition.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain each area in the scope of macro economics.
- Name the four phases of a business cycle.
- State the limitations of macro economics and explain the fallacy of composition with an example.
A subject's scope tells us how far it reaches. Macro economics reaches into almost every big economic headline: incomes, prices, jobs, booms and slumps, and the policies meant to manage them. But a wide view also has blind spots, and the textbook names them honestly.
Scope of macro economics
| Area | What is studied |
|---|---|
| National income | Measuring national income and its composition by sectors; its trends show the long-run growth process |
| Inflation | A steady increase in the general price level, measured with price index numbers such as the Wholesale Price Index and Consumer Price Index |
| Business cycle | Cyclical movements of boom, recession, depression and recovery, studied through aggregate variables |
| Poverty and unemployment | Their magnitude, so that resources can be allocated and corrective steps taken |
| Economic growth | Growth and development and the factors behind them, understood only through macro analysis |
| Economic policies | Policies to solve basic problems, overcome obstacles and achieve growth |
The four phases of a business cycle
- Boom Output, employment and prices are high.
- Recession Activity starts to slow down.
- Depression Output and employment are at their lowest.
- Recovery Activity picks up again, leading towards the next boom.
Then back to step 1: Boom
The textbook calls poverty and unemployment in resource-rich nations an economic paradox: a country can have plenty of natural resources and still have many poor and jobless people. Knowing how large the problem is lets planners decide where to spend.
Limitations of macro economics
- Excessive generalisation: conclusions about the economy as a whole may hide what is happening to particular groups.
- Assumed homogeneity: it treats individual units as if they were alike, though they differ.
- Fallacy of composition: what is good for an individual need not be good for the nation, and the reverse; what suits one country, or one time, may not suit another.
- Non-economic factors left out: many non-economic factors shape economic activity but do not find a place in usual macro economic analysis.
Fallacy of composition: what is true for a part need not be true for the whole. Saving more may help one family, but if everyone saves more at once, total spending and income can fall.
Worked example 1: averages that hide differences
Made-up data: a village has 5 families with monthly incomes ₹4,000, ₹5,000, ₹6,000, ₹10,000 and ₹75,000. Step 1, total: 4,000 + 5,000 + 6,000 + 10,000 + 75,000 = ₹1,00,000. Step 2, average: 1,00,000 ÷ 5 = ₹20,000. Step 3, compare: four of the five families earn ₹10,000 or less, far below the average. Answer: the aggregate figure ₹20,000 suggests a comfortable village while most families are poor. This is the danger of excessive generalisation and of assuming the units are alike.
Worked example 2: the fallacy of composition
At a cricket match, one spectator who stands up sees better. Working: if all spectators stand, nobody sees better than before and everyone is less comfortable. Economic version: one farmer who grows a bumper crop earns more; if all farmers grow bumper crops at once, the price may fall so much that farmers as a group earn less. Answer: a result true for one unit can be false for the whole, so individual experience cannot simply be added up.
Key takeaways: the scope of macro economics covers national income, inflation, business cycles, poverty and unemployment, growth and policies. Its limits are over-generalisation, assumed homogeneity, the fallacy of composition and the neglect of non-economic factors.
Check your understanding
-
1. A steady increase in the general price level is called:
- Business cycle
- Inflation
- National income
- Deflation
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook defines inflation as a steady increase in the general price level, measured with price index numbers. Deflation is a fall in prices.
-
2. Which is NOT one of the four phases of a business cycle named in the chapter?
- Boom
- Recovery
- Stagnation
- Depression
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter names boom, recession, depression and recovery. Stagnation is not one of the four phases listed.
-
3. 'What is good for an individual need not be good for the nation.' This limitation is called:
- Fallacy of composition
- Excessive generalisation
- Assumed homogeneity
- Consumer sovereignty
Show answer
Answer: A. The fallacy of composition warns that a result true for one part is not necessarily true for the whole.
-
4. Made-up data: 4 workers earn ₹8,000, ₹9,000, ₹11,000 and ₹52,000 a month. What is their average, and what does it show?
- ₹10,000; it describes all four well
- ₹80,000; it is the total
- ₹9,500; it is the middle value
- ₹20,000; most workers earn far less, so the average over-generalises
Show answer
Answer: D. Total = 8,000 + 9,000 + 11,000 + 52,000 = ₹80,000. Average = 80,000 ÷ 4 = ₹20,000. Three of the four earn ₹11,000 or less, so the aggregate hides the differences.
-
5. Poverty and unemployment in resource-rich nations are described in the textbook as:
- an economic paradox
- a business cycle
- a stock variable
- consumer sovereignty
Show answer
Answer: A. It is a paradox because plenty of resources would be expected to bring prosperity, yet poverty and unemployment remain.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.