• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

The income method and the expenditure method

Measure national income by adding factor incomes and by adding final expenditures, apply the items to include and exclude in each method, and derive NNP at factor cost from gross value added.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Group factor incomes into labour, capital and mixed income and use Y = w + r + i + π + (R − P).
  • Use C + I + G + (X − M) and leave out items that are not final expenditure.
  • Find NNP at factor cost from gross value added.

The product method counts output where it is made. The other two methods count the same value where it is earned and where it is spent. Each has its own traps, mostly payments that look like income or spending but do not come from current production.

The income method (factor earning method)

This method approaches national income from the distribution side. Steps: (1) classify enterprises into industrial groups; (2) group factor incomes into labour income (wages and salaries, fringe benefits, employer's contribution to social security), capital income (profit, interest, dividend, royalty) and mixed income (farming, sole proprietorship, other professions); (3) add net factor income from abroad. Data on income from abroad come from the balance of payments accounts.

Y = w + r + i + π + (R − P), where w is wages, r rent, i interest, π profits, and (R − P) net factor income from abroad (factor income received from abroad minus factor income paid abroad).

Precautions in the income method
IncludeExclude
Imputed rent of self-occupied houses or officesTransfer payments such as pensions and social insurance
Imputed value of services of owners and family labourReceipts from sale of second-hand goods
Windfall gains such as lottery prizes
Corporate profit tax as a separate item (already inside profit)

Worked example 1: income method

Made-up data (₹ crore): wages and salaries 500; rent including imputed rent of owner-occupied houses 80; interest 70; profits 150 (corporate profit tax of 20 is already part of this); old age pensions 40; lottery prizes 10; net factor income from abroad −20. Step 1, keep factor incomes: 500 + 80 + 70 + 150 = 800. Step 2, leave out: pensions (transfer), lottery prizes (windfall) and the separate tax figure (already in profit). Step 3, add (R − P): 800 + (−20) = 780.

The expenditure method (outlay method)

Here the total expenditure of society in the year is added: private consumption expenditure (C), investment expenditure (I), government expenditure on consumption and capital goods (G) and net exports (X − M). The textbook writes this as GNP = C + I + G + (X − M); strictly, C + I + G + (X − M) gives GDP at market prices, and net factor income from abroad is added to reach GNP.

  1. Exclude spending on second-hand goods.
  2. Exclude purchase of old shares and bonds in the secondary market: they transfer ownership and produce nothing.
  3. Exclude transfer payments such as old age pensions.
  4. Exclude spending on intermediate goods (seeds and fertilisers bought by farmers, cotton and yarn bought by textile mills), to avoid double counting.

Worked example 2: expenditure method with traps

Made-up (₹ crore): private consumption 900; investment 250; government purchases 300; exports 120; imports 150; purchase of second-hand cars 40; purchase of old shares 60; old age pensions paid 25; net factor income from abroad 15. Step 1, final expenditure only: C + I + G + (X − M) = 900 + 250 + 300 + (120 − 150) = 1,450 − 30 = 1,420 = GDP(MP). Step 2, exclude the 40, 60 and 25. Step 3, GNP(MP): 1,420 + 15 = 1,435.

National income from gross value added

Putting the pieces together: NNP(FC) = Gross value added by all producers within the domestic territory − depreciation − net indirect taxes + net factor income from abroad.

Worked example 3: from GVA to national income

Made-up (₹ crore): GVA at market prices = 2,000; depreciation = 150; indirect taxes = 160; subsidies = 40; NFIA = 30. Step 1: net indirect taxes = 160 − 40 = 120. Step 2: NNP(FC) = 2,000 − 150 − 120 + 30 = 1,760. Check by stages: NDP(MP) = 2,000 − 150 = 1,850; NDP(FC) = 1,850 − 120 = 1,730; NNP(FC) = 1,730 + 30 = 1,760.

Three methods side by side

  • Product method
    • Adds value added by sectors
    • Used in India for agriculture, mining, manufacturing
    • Trap: double counting
  • Income method
    • Adds wages, rent, interest, profit, mixed income
    • Plus (R − P)
    • Trap: transfers and windfalls
  • Expenditure method
    • Adds C + I + G + (X − M)
    • Final spending only
    • Trap: second-hand goods, old shares

Key takeaways: the income method adds factor incomes plus (R − P), including imputed rent and family labour but not transfers, windfalls or second-hand sales. The expenditure method adds final spending only. NNP(FC) = GVA − depreciation − net indirect taxes + NFIA.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which is included in national income under the income method?

    1. Old age pension
    2. Lottery prize
    3. Imputed rent of an owner-occupied house
    4. Sale proceeds of a second-hand scooter
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The owner-occupier is enjoying the service of the house, so its imputed rent is included. Pensions are transfers, lottery prizes are windfalls, and second-hand sales create no new output.

  2. 2. Income from farming and sole proprietorship is classified as:

    1. mixed income
    2. labour income
    3. capital income
    4. transfer income
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Farmers and sole proprietors supply both labour and capital and their earnings cannot be split easily, so the textbook calls them mixed income.

  3. 3. Made-up (₹ crore): wages 300, rent 50, interest 40, profit 110, pensions 20, NFIA 10. National income by the income method is:

    1. ₹530 crore
    2. ₹500 crore
    3. ₹490 crore
    4. ₹510 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Factor incomes = 300 + 50 + 40 + 110 = 500. Pensions are excluded. Add NFIA: 500 + 10 = 510. ₹530 crore wrongly adds the pensions.

  4. 4. Purchase of old shares in the secondary market is excluded from the expenditure method because it:

    1. is too small to measure
    2. only transfers ownership and produces no new goods or services
    3. is an indirect tax
    4. is a stock variable
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Buying old shares moves an existing asset from one owner to another; nothing new is produced this year.

  5. 5. Made-up (₹ crore): GVA(MP) = 1,000, depreciation = 80, indirect taxes = 70, subsidies = 20, NFIA = −10. NNP(FC) is:

    1. ₹860 crore
    2. ₹880 crore
    3. ₹840 crore
    4. ₹960 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Net indirect taxes = 70 − 20 = 50. NNP(FC) = 1,000 − 80 − 50 + (−10) = 860.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery