• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Uses, difficulties, social accounting and national income as welfare

State the uses of national income data, explain the difficulties of measuring it in India, describe the five sectors of social accounting, and judge when higher per capita income does not mean higher welfare.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • List the uses of national income analysis.
  • Explain the seven difficulties in measuring national income.
  • Name the five sectors of social accounting and the limits of per capita income as a welfare index.

Knowing how to compute national income is only half the job. We also need to know what the figure is used for, why it is hard to measure correctly, and what it fails to show.

Importance of national income analysis

National income accounts, also called social accounts, help us: (1) know the relative contribution of each sector and how income is produced, distributed, spent, saved or taxed; (2) frame monetary, fiscal and other policies; (3) prepare plans and evaluate their progress; (4) build short-run and long-run economic models; (5) make international, inter-regional and inter-temporal comparisons; (6) know per capita income, which reflects welfare if income is equally distributed; (7) know how income is distributed among factors; and (8) work out ratios such as the tax-GDP, fiscal deficit-GDP, current account deficit-GDP and debt-GDP ratios.

Difficulties in measuring national income

In India a special problem is the large unorganised, non-monetised subsistence sector, where barter is still used and output is hard to value. The textbook lists further difficulties:

Difficulties in measuring national income

  • What to leave out
    • Transfer payments (pensions, unemployment allowance, subsidies, interest on national debt)
    • Income from illegal activities
    • Capital gains
  • What is hard to value
    • Unpaid services, such as a homemaker's work
    • Production for self-consumption
    • Depreciation, damage and repair allowances
  • Measurement
    • Changing prices (use constant prices)
    • Statistical problems: unreliable data, many languages, non-cooperation, untrained staff

A homemaker's cooking, cleaning and child care are not directly included, while the same work done by a paid servant is included. Capital gains (selling a house or shares for more than was paid) are excluded. Because of these problems the textbook notes that Indian estimates may carry a margin of error of at least 10 per cent.

Social accounting

The social accounting method records transactions between sectors and traces their links, which helps forecasting. A sector is a group of individuals or institutions with common, interrelated transactions. The five sectors are: firms (all producing organisations; public enterprises such as post offices and railways are counted here); households (consumers and owners of factors); government (public bodies at centre, state and local levels, which Edey and Peacock treat as a collective 'person' buying goods and services to meet collective wants); rest of the world (exports, imports, external loans and overseas investment income); and the capital sector (saving and investment: banks, insurance and other money-market agencies). For sectoral shares of GDP the economy is also divided into primary, secondary and tertiary sectors.

National income and welfare

  1. Composition matters: more capital goods than consumer goods, or more luxuries for the rich, adds less to welfare.
  2. Higher GDP with air, water and soil pollution gives little welfare.
  3. War goods raise output but not welfare.
  4. Income raised by employing children or by long working hours does not raise welfare.

The textbook therefore points to the Physical Quality of Life Index (PQLI) as a better welfare indicator. As it is usually constructed, the PQLI combines life expectancy, infant mortality and basic literacy. The textbook also notes that national income should allow for the erosion of natural resources and for social and environmental costs, and that India's income looks very low in US dollars but better when measured by purchasing power parity (PPP).

A higher per capita income suggests higher welfare only when income is fairly distributed and the extra output is of useful, non-harmful goods produced without damaging people or nature.

Worked example 1: income up, per capita unchanged

Made-up: national income rises from ₹1,000 crore to ₹1,100 crore while population rises from 50 lakh to 55 lakh. Year 1: ₹1,000 crore = ₹10,000,000,000 and 50 lakh = 5,000,000 people, so per capita income = 10,000,000,000 ÷ 5,000,000 = ₹2,000. Year 2: 11,000,000,000 ÷ 5,500,000 = ₹2,000. Answer: national income grew 10 per cent, but so did population, so the average person is no better off.

Worked example 2: include or exclude?

Decide for each: (a) a cook's salary in a household; (b) the same cooking done by a homemaker; (c) profit from selling an old house; (d) old age pension; (e) wheat a farmer keeps for his family. Working: (a) paid service, included; (b) unpaid, not directly included; (c) capital gain, excluded; (d) transfer, excluded; (e) self-consumed output, included under the product method, though hard to value. Answer: included (a) and (e); excluded (b), (c), (d).

Key takeaways: national income data guide policy, planning, comparisons and ratios. Measurement is hard because of transfers, unpaid work, self-consumption, depreciation, illegal income, capital gains, price changes and weak statistics. Social accounting uses five sectors. Per capita income is an imperfect welfare index, so measures like the PQLI are used alongside it.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Interest on national debt is treated as:

    1. factor income
    2. mixed income
    3. a transfer payment
    4. a capital gain
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The government pays it on past borrowing without any current productive work in return, so the textbook treats it as a transfer payment, excluded from national income.

  2. 2. In social accounting, the railways and post offices are included in which sector?

    1. Government
    2. Firms
    3. Capital
    4. Households
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Public enterprises that produce and sell services are separated from the government sector and counted as firms.

  3. 3. Which of these does NOT reduce the welfare meaning of a rise in GDP?

    1. More war goods
    2. More pollution
    3. More child labour
    4. More food and medicines shared widely
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Useful consumer goods spread across the population raise welfare. War goods, pollution and child labour raise output without raising welfare.

  4. 4. Made-up: national income ₹6,000 crore and population 1.5 crore. Per capita income is:

    1. ₹4,000
    2. ₹9,000
    3. ₹40,000
    4. ₹400
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 6,000 crore ÷ 1.5 crore = 6,000 ÷ 1.5 = ₹4,000 (the crores cancel).

  5. 5. The capital sector in social accounting covers:

    1. factories making machines
    2. saving and investment transactions of banks, insurance and money-market agencies
    3. imports of capital goods
    4. government buildings
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The capital sector records saving and investment through financial agencies, which only finance firms' activity and are kept apart from firms.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: National Income

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery