- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Keynes's psychological law of consumption and its determinants
State Keynes's psychological law of consumption, its assumptions and three propositions, and explain the subjective and objective factors that shape the consumption function, including Duesenberry's hypothesis.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the psychological law of consumption and its three assumptions.
- Prove its three propositions from a schedule.
- List subjective and objective determinants of consumption.
Why does consumption rise by less than income? Keynes answered with a 'law' about human behaviour, which is the foundation of the consumption function.
The law
In Keynes's words (paraphrased), we can rely with confidence, both from human nature and from experience, on the fact that people as a rule and on average increase their consumption as their income increases, but not by as much as the increase in income. In short, people tend to spend less than the full increment of income.
Psychological law of consumption: when income rises, consumption rises, but by less than the rise in income (0 < MPC < 1).
Assumptions
- Ceteris paribus: income distribution, tastes, habits, social customs, prices and population do not change; consumption depends on income alone.
- Normal conditions: in war, revolution or hyperinflation the law may fail and people may spend all extra income.
- A laissez-faire capitalist economy: people must be free to spend; if the state regulates consumption, the law breaks down.
Worked example 1: proving the three propositions
| Income Y | Consumption C | Saving S = Y − C |
|---|---|---|
| 300 | 280 | 20 |
| 400 | 355 | 45 |
| 500 | 430 | 70 |
Proposition 1, consumption rises by less than income: income rises by 100 each time, consumption by 355 − 280 = 75 and 430 − 355 = 75. 75 < 100. Proposition 2, extra income is split between consumption and saving: each extra 100 = 75 consumed + 25 saved (45 − 20 = 25; 70 − 45 = 25). Proposition 3, both rise together: consumption goes 280 → 355 → 430 and saving 20 → 45 → 70; neither falls. On the diagram, the gap between the 45° line and the C curve widens as income rises.
Determinants of the consumption function
Keynes divided the factors into subjective (internal, psychological) and objective (external, real and measurable).
Subjective factors: motives to refrain from spending
-
Individuals (Keynes's eight motives)
- Precaution: reserve for accidents, sickness
- Foresight: future needs such as old age
- Calculation: to earn interest and appreciation
- Improvement: to raise the standard of living
- Independence: financial independence
- Enterprise: funds for trading
- Pride: to leave a fortune
- Avarice: miserly instinct
-
Governments, institutions and firms
- Enterprise: invest without borrowing
- Liquidity: meet emergencies
- Improvement: rising income, proof of good management
- Financial prudence: provide for depreciation and repay debt
Keynes held that subjective factors do not change in the short run, so the consumption function is stable in the short period.
| Factor | Effect on consumption |
|---|---|
| Income distribution | More equal distribution raises the propensity to consume, since the rich save a larger share (a view the textbook says V.K.R.V. Rao supported) |
| Price level | A fall in prices raises real income, so people may consume more |
| Wage level | Higher wages raise consumption; windfall gains act similarly |
| Interest rate | A higher rate encourages saving and reduces consumption |
| Fiscal policy | Lower taxes raise disposable income; progressive taxes shift income to the poor and raise the propensity to consume |
| Consumer credit | Easy instalments encourage purchase of durables like cars, fridges and computers |
| Demographic factors | Larger families, later life-cycle stages (such as college-going children) and urban living raise consumption |
| Duesenberry hypothesis | Consumption depends also on past income and habit, and on the demonstration effect: lower-income groups imitate richer ones |
| Windfall gains or losses | Stock market gains or losses shift the function up or down |
Worked example 2: classify the factor
Name the factor and its direction: (a) a bank offers easy EMIs on refrigerators; (b) a worker saves for her old age; (c) a family whose income has fallen keeps spending as before because it is used to that lifestyle; (d) the government cuts income tax. Working and answer: (a) consumer credit, objective, consumption rises; (b) motive of foresight, subjective, consumption falls; (c) Duesenberry's habit (past income) effect, objective, consumption does not fall much; (d) fiscal policy, objective, disposable income and consumption rise.
Key takeaways: consumption rises with income but by less. The law assumes ceteris paribus, normal times and a laissez-faire capitalist economy. Its three propositions: ΔC < ΔY; ΔY = ΔC + ΔS; both C and S rise. Subjective motives are stable in the short run; objective factors such as income distribution, prices, wages, interest, taxes, credit, family size and the demonstration effect shift the function.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the psychological law of consumption, when income rises:
- consumption rises by more than income
- consumption falls
- consumption rises, but by less than income
- saving falls
Show answer
Answer: C. Keynes's law says people increase consumption as income rises, but not by the full increase, so MPC is between 0 and 1.
-
2. The law may NOT hold during:
- hyperinflation or war
- normal times
- a laissez-faire economy
- a stable period
Show answer
Answer: A. The law assumes normal conditions; in war, revolution or hyperinflation people may spend all of their extra income.
-
3. 'The desire to provide for anticipated future needs, such as old age' is the motive of:
- precaution
- avarice
- pride
- foresight
Show answer
Answer: D. Foresight is saving for expected future needs. Precaution is for unforeseen events like accidents; pride is to leave a fortune; avarice is miserliness.
-
4. Poor families copying the spending of rich families is called:
- the multiplier
- the demonstration effect
- the accelerator
- the paradox of thrift
Show answer
Answer: B. Duesenberry's demonstration effect: consumption standards of low-income groups are influenced by those of high-income groups.
-
5. Made-up: income rises from ₹600 crore to ₹700 crore and consumption from ₹520 crore to ₹590 crore. Which proposition-based statement is correct?
- The extra ₹100 crore is split into ₹70 crore consumption and ₹30 crore saving
- Saving falls by ₹10 crore
- Consumption rises by ₹100 crore
- MPC is 1.43
Show answer
Answer: A. ΔC = 590 − 520 = 70; ΔS = 100 − 70 = 30. Saving rises from 80 to 110, consistent with all three propositions. MPC = 0.7.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.