• Practice
  • About 22 min
  • 5 practice questions

Balance of trade, balance of payments and correcting disequilibrium

Distinguish the balance of trade from the balance of payments, describe the three BoP accounts, explain the types and causes of BoP disequilibrium, and set out automatic and deliberate measures to correct it.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define balance of trade and balance of payments and tell them apart.
  • Place transactions in the current, capital and official reserve accounts.
  • Explain cyclical, secular and structural disequilibrium and its causes.
  • Explain automatic correction, devaluation, exchange control and trade measures.

A family keeps track of what it earns and spends; a country does the same with the rest of the world. The balance of trade looks only at goods, while the balance of payments records every economic transaction. When the books do not balance for long, a country must act.

Balance of trade (BOT)

The balance of trade compares the value of a country's commodity exports with its commodity imports. Goods are called visible trade because they can be seen and checked by customs. Exports greater than imports is a favourable BOT; exports less than imports is an unfavourable BOT.

Balance of payments (BoP)

The balance of payments is a systematic record of all of a country's economic and financial transactions with the rest of the world over a period. Money received from abroad is a credit; money paid abroad is a debit. Credits include exports of goods and services, gifts received, borrowing from abroad, FDI received and official sale of reserve assets. Debits include imports, transfers to foreigners, lending abroad, investment abroad and official purchase of reserves.

Components of the BoP
AccountWhat it records
Current accountTrade in goods and services (tourism, transport, royalties) and unilateral transfers (gifts, foreign aid)
Capital accountDirect investment, interest-bearing financial instruments, deposits and gold
Official reserve assets accountGovernment movements of gold, convertible foreign currency, SDRs and the IMF position to cover imbalances in the other two

BoP balanced: receipts ÷ payments = 1. Favourable: R ÷ P > 1. Unfavourable (adverse): R ÷ P < 1.

Worked example 1: a made-up country's accounts (₹ crore)

ItemCreditDebit
Goods500650
Services300150
Transfers (gifts, remittances)8020
Total current account880820

Balance of trade (goods only) = 500 − 650 = −150, unfavourable. Current account = 880 − 820 = +60, a surplus, because services and remittances more than cover the goods gap. R ÷ P on current account = 880 ÷ 820 ≈ 1.07 > 1. Lesson: a country can have an unfavourable trade balance and still a favourable current account. The fee paid to a foreign doctor for a consultation would be a debit under services in the current account.

Types of BoP disequilibrium

  • Cyclical: countries are in different phases of the business cycle, or their elasticities of demand differ.
  • Secular (long-run): deep changes as an economy grows; in early development investment exceeds saving and imports exceed exports, as the textbook says has happened in India since 1951.
  • Structural: new sources of supply, better substitutes, exhaustion of resources or changes in transport routes and costs.

Causes listed in the textbook

  • Cyclical fluctuations: world trade shrinks in depression.
  • Structural changes from big development programmes that raise import needs.
  • Development expenditure: low income and saving, heavy dependence on imported capital and technology.
  • Consumerism: a big rise in consumption raises imports and cuts exports.
  • Demonstration effect: people in less developed countries imitate Western-style goods.
  • Borrowing: repaying foreign loans with interest is a heavy burden.
  • Technological backwardness: for example, importing petroleum instead of using available solar energy.
  • Global politics: the textbook includes spending of export earnings on imported weapons.

Measures to correct disequilibrium

Correcting BoP disequilibrium

  • Automatic correction
    • Price adjustments
    • Interest rate adjustments
    • Income adjustments
    • Capital flows
  • Monetary measures
    • Monetary contraction or expansion
    • Devaluation or revaluation
    • Exchange control
  • Trade measures
    • Export promotion: lower duties, subsidies, incentives
    • Import control: duties, quotas, prohibition
  • Miscellaneous
    • Foreign loans and investment
    • Tourism and remittances
    • Import substitution

Automatic correction works under free exchange rates: money flowing out of a deficit country lowers its prices (exports rise, imports fall) and raises its interest rates (capital flows in), while the surplus country's rising income raises its imports. Devaluation is a deliberate cut in the official external value of a currency; it makes exports cheaper for foreigners and imports dearer at home. The textbook records that the Indian rupee was devalued three times after 1947: in 1949, 1966 and 1991. Exchange control means the government or central bank takes control of foreign exchange: exporters surrender it, and imports are controlled. The textbook warns that very tight import and exchange controls can encourage smuggling.

Worked example 2: effect of devaluation (illustrative rates)

The rupee moves from ₹70 to ₹80 per US dollar. Import: a machine priced at $1,000 used to cost 1,000 × 70 = ₹70,000; now it costs 1,000 × 80 = ₹80,000, dearer by ₹10,000. Export: a ₹1,40,000 consignment used to cost a US buyer 1,40,000 ÷ 70 = $2,000; now 1,40,000 ÷ 80 = $1,750, cheaper by $250. Result: imports fall and exports rise, helping to reduce a deficit.

Key takeaways: BOT covers visible goods only; BoP records all transactions in current, capital and official reserve accounts. Disequilibrium is cyclical, secular or structural. It may correct itself through prices, interest, income and capital flows, or be corrected by monetary measures (contraction, devaluation, exchange control), trade measures and miscellaneous steps.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The balance of trade includes:

    1. gifts and foreign aid
    2. goods and services
    3. all capital flows
    4. only exports and imports of goods
    Show answer

    Answer: D. BOT covers only visible trade in commodities. Services, transfers and capital flows appear in the balance of payments.

  2. 2. Fees paid to a foreign doctor for treating a patient in India are recorded as a:

    1. credit in the capital account
    2. debit in the current account
    3. credit in the official reserve account
    4. debit in the capital account
    Show answer

    Answer: B. It is a payment abroad (debit) for a service, and services belong in the current account.

  3. 3. Imports exceeding exports for a long period because a developing economy invests more than it saves is:

    1. cyclical disequilibrium
    2. structural disequilibrium
    3. secular disequilibrium
    4. a favourable BoP
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Secular (long-run) disequilibrium comes from deep changes as an economy grows; early development typically brings investment above saving and imports above exports.

  4. 4. Receipts are ₹900 crore and payments ₹1,000 crore. The BoP is:

    1. balanced, since R ÷ P = 1
    2. favourable, since R ÷ P > 1
    3. neither, since it cannot be judged
    4. unfavourable, since R ÷ P = 0.9
    Show answer

    Answer: D. R ÷ P = 900 ÷ 1,000 = 0.9 < 1, so the BoP is unfavourable (adverse).

  5. 5. After a devaluation of the rupee from ₹75 to ₹80 per dollar, a $500 import costs in rupees:

    1. ₹2,500 more
    2. ₹2,500 less
    3. ₹500 more
    4. the same
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Before: 500 × 75 = ₹37,500. After: 500 × 80 = ₹40,000. It costs ₹2,500 more, which discourages imports.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery