- Practice
- About 22 min
- 5 practice questions
The modern theory, gains from trade and the terms of trade
Explain the Heckscher-Ohlin factor endowment theory, compare it with the classical theory, list the gains from trade, and calculate the net barter, gross barter, income and factoral terms of trade.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the Heckscher-Ohlin theorem and judge factor abundance using factor ratios.
- Compare classical and modern trade theory.
- List the gains from international trade.
- Calculate and interpret the main terms-of-trade indices.
Ricardo told us that comparative cost differences lead to trade, but not why costs differ. The modern theory answers that question with differences in factor endowments. Once we know trade brings gains, the terms of trade tell us how those gains are shared.
Heckscher-Ohlin: the factor endowment theory
The modern theory was developed by the Swedish economists Eli Heckscher and his student Bertil Ohlin (Heckscher's paper appeared in 1919; Ohlin developed it fully later). It traces comparative cost differences to (i) differences in factor endowments between countries and (ii) differences in the factor proportions that goods need.
- Two countries, two commodities and two factors (a 2 × 2 × 2 model).
- Countries differ in factor endowments; goods differ in factor intensity.
- Both countries use the same technology and have identical demand conditions.
- Perfect competition in product and factor markets.
Heckscher-Ohlin theorem: a capital-abundant country exports capital-intensive goods, and a labour-abundant country exports labour-intensive goods.
Abundance is relative: a country is capital-abundant only if its ratio of capital to other factors is higher than the other country's, not because it has more capital in total.
Worked example 1: who is capital-abundant? (made-up data)
| Item | Country M | Country N |
|---|---|---|
| Labour (units) | 80 | 30 |
| Capital (units) | 60 | 45 |
| Capital-labour ratio | 60 ÷ 80 = 0.75 | 45 ÷ 30 = 1.5 |
Step 1: M has more capital in total (60 > 45). Step 2: but N's capital per worker is higher (1.5 > 0.75). Answer: N is capital-abundant and should export capital-intensive goods such as machinery; M is labour-abundant and should export labour-intensive goods such as garments.
Limitations: factor endowments change over time, and the efficiency of the same factor can differ between countries (a country with fewer workers may have more labour in terms of efficiency).
| Classical theory | Modern theory |
|---|---|
| Based on the labour theory of value | Based on the general theory of value |
| One-factor (labour) model | Multi-factor (labour and capital) model |
| Cost differences come from differences in workers' efficiency | Cost differences come from differences in factor endowments |
Gains from international trade
Gains from trade (textbook's four heads)
-
Efficient production
- Better use of resources
- Specialisation by comparative advantage
- Better skills and techniques
- More output, higher living standards
-
Equalisation of prices
- Goods prices tend to equalise, differing by transport cost
- Factor prices tend to equalise (the textbook notes this has not really happened)
- Equitable distribution of scarce materials
-
General advantages
- Variety of goods, more jobs
- Industrialisation of backward nations
- Division of labour, more transport
Terms of trade
The terms of trade are the rate at which one country's goods are exchanged for another's, expressed as the relation between export prices and import prices. Gerald M. Meier classified the concepts; the textbook covers these:
| Concept | Formula | Given by |
|---|---|---|
| Net barter (commodity) terms of trade | Tn = (Px ÷ Pm) × 100 | Taussig, 1927 (Viner called it commodity terms of trade) |
| Gross barter terms of trade | Tg = (Qm ÷ Qx) × 100 | Taussig, 1927 |
| Income terms of trade | Ty = (Px ÷ Pm) × Qx | G.S. Dorrance, 1948 |
| Single factoral terms of trade | Tf = (Px ÷ Pm) × Fx | Jacob Viner |
| Double factoral terms of trade | Tff = (Px ÷ Pm) × (Fx ÷ Fm) × 100 | Jacob Viner |
Tn above 100 is favourable: each unit of exports buys more imports. For the gross barter terms, the usual (Taussig) form puts import quantity on top, so a value above 100 means more imports for a given quantity of exports; the Tamil Nadu textbook prints this ratio the other way round (Qx ÷ Qm), so check which form your teacher uses.
Worked example 2: computing the indices (made-up index numbers, base year = 100)
Px = 120, Pm = 100, Qx = 110, Qm = 132, Fx = 105, Fm = 100. Net barter: (120 ÷ 100) × 100 = 120, favourable. Gross barter: (132 ÷ 110) × 100 = 120, more imports per unit of exports. Income terms: (120 ÷ 100) × 110 = 1.2 × 110 = 132, the country's capacity to import has risen 32%. Single factoral: 1.2 × 105 = 126. Double factoral: 1.2 × (105 ÷ 100) × 100 = 1.2 × 1.05 × 100 = 126. Check: 1.2 × 110 = 132 and 1.2 × 1.05 = 1.26.
Key takeaways: the H-O theory explains comparative costs by factor endowments: countries export goods that use their relatively abundant factor. The modern theory is multi-factor and rests on the general theory of value. Trade brings efficient production, price equalisation, wider access to scarce materials and general gains. Terms of trade measure how those gains are shared; Tn = (Px ÷ Pm) × 100.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the Heckscher-Ohlin theorem, a labour-abundant country will export:
- capital-intensive goods
- labour-intensive goods
- only raw materials
- nothing
Show answer
Answer: B. Each country exports goods that use its relatively abundant factor intensively, so a labour-abundant country exports labour-intensive goods.
-
2. Made-up data: Country R has 100 workers and 50 machines; Country S has 20 workers and 30 machines. Which is capital-abundant?
- S, because its capital-labour ratio is 1.5 against R's 0.5
- Both equally
- R, because it has more machines
- Neither
Show answer
Answer: A. R: 50 ÷ 100 = 0.5; S: 30 ÷ 20 = 1.5. Abundance is relative, so S is capital-abundant even though R has more machines.
-
3. Export price index 90, import price index 100. The net barter terms of trade are:
- 90, unfavourable
- 110, favourable
- 111, favourable
- 190
Show answer
Answer: A. Tn = (90 ÷ 100) × 100 = 90. Below 100 means each unit of exports buys fewer imports: unfavourable.
-
4. The income terms of trade were given by:
- Taussig
- G.S. Dorrance
- Gerald Meier
- Jacob Viner
Show answer
Answer: B. G.S. Dorrance gave the income terms of trade in 1948. Taussig gave the barter terms; Viner the factoral terms; Meier classified them.
-
5. Px = 110, Pm = 100 and the export quantity index Qx = 120. The income terms of trade are:
- 110
- 230
- 132
- 91.7
Show answer
Answer: C. Ty = (Px ÷ Pm) × Qx = (110 ÷ 100) × 120 = 1.1 × 120 = 132.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.