- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Other causes and the first Indian associations
Explain how memories of 1857, racial discrimination, repressive laws, the press and pride in India's past fed nationalism, and describe the Madras Native Association and Madras Mahajana Sabha.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List and explain five further factors the book gives for the rise of nationalism.
- Describe the petitions and achievements of the Madras Native Association (1852).
- Describe the founding of the Madras Mahajana Sabha (1884) and its merger with the Congress.
Economic hardship and new ideas were not enough on their own. The book names further experiences that hurt Indian pride and showed how the colonial state treated Indians, and it then turns to the first organisations, several of them in Madras, through which Indians began to speak together.
Five further factors
- Memories of 1857. The book says the national movement dates its birth from the 1857 uprising. British reprisals after the revolt were brutal, with mock trials and executions of guilty and innocent alike. It quotes Elphinstone, Governor of Bombay, writing to John Lawrence that vengeance was being taken without distinguishing friend from foe and that the looting of Delhi outdid Nadir Shah's.
- Racial discrimination. Indians were kept out of high office. When Indians began to succeed in the civil service examination, the maximum age was cut from twenty-one to nineteen, and requests to hold the examination in India as well as in England were refused.
- Repressive and exploitative measures. Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code (1870) punished attempts to excite disaffection against the government; the Vernacular Press Act (1878) censored the Indian-language press. Customs duty on imported English cottons was abolished while an excise duty was put on Indian-made cloth. Under Viceroy Ripon the Ilbert Bill allowed Indian judges to try Europeans, but European opposition got it amended to suit their interests.
- The press. Printing spread ideas of self-government, democracy and civil rights. Ram Mohan Roy's Sambad Kaumudi (1821, Bengali) and Mirat-ul-Akbar (1822, Persian) were early examples; later the Amrita Bazar Patrika, Bombay Chronicle, Tribune, Indian Mirror, The Hindu and Swadesamitran built public opinion.
- Pride in India's past. Orientalists such as William Jones, Charles Wilkins and Max Muller translated Sanskrit, Persian and Arabic texts into English. Many early nationalists, impressed by this heritage, called for India's glory to be revived; Aurobindo Ghose described nationalism's mission as recovering Indian thought and greatness.
Why nationalism rose: the textbook's causes
-
Economic
- New land tenures
- De-industrialisation
- Famines and emigration
-
Intellectual
- Western education
- Missionaries
- Social and religious reform
-
Political and emotional
- Memories of 1857
- Racial discrimination
- Repressive laws
- The press
- Pride in India's past
The Madras Native Association (1852)
One of the first organised efforts to air grievances was the Madras Native Association (MNA), formed on 26 February 1852. It represented the landed and business classes of the Madras Presidency and was inspired by Gajula Lakshminarasu, a leading Madras businessman. As Parliament prepared to renew the Company's Charter in 1853, the MNA sent a petition in December 1852. It said that the ryotwari and zamindari systems had thrown cultivators into deep distress and urged a revival of the old village system; it called the courts slow, complicated and staffed by judges not tested in law or local languages; and it objected to state money going to missionary schools under grants-in-aid.
Parliament discussed the petition in March 1853, and H.D. Seymour, chairman of the Indian Reform Society, visited Madras in October 1853, touring places such as Guntur, Cuddalore, Tiruchirappalli, Salem and Tirunelveli. When the Charter Act of 1853 still left the Company in power, the MNA sent a second petition, signed by about fourteen thousand people, asking that Company rule end and India pass directly to the Crown. Lakshminarasu died in 1866 and the MNA was defunct by 1881. The book judges that it achieved few reforms and spoke for the elite, especially the landed gentry, within one Presidency; but it began organised Indian opinion.
The Madras Mahajana Sabha (1884)
With the MNA gone, educated Indians in Madras felt the need for a new body. The Madras Mahajana Sabha (MMS) was organised in May 1884, with its inaugural meeting on 16 May 1884. Among those present the book names G. Subramaniam, Viraraghavachari, Ananda Charlu, Rangiah, Balaji Rao and Salem Ramaswamy. After its second provincial conference, its leaders attended the first session of the Indian National Congress in Bombay and merged the MMS with the Congress.
| Feature | Madras Native Association | Madras Mahajana Sabha |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 26 February 1852 | 16 May 1884 (inaugural meeting) |
| Leading figures | Gajula Lakshminarasu | G. Subramaniam, Viraraghavachari, Ananda Charlu and others |
| Main method | Petitions to the British Parliament | Provincial conferences |
| Fate | Defunct by 1881 | Merged with the Indian National Congress |
Worked example 1: matching a grievance to a factor
Question: an Indian graduate in 1880 says he can no longer sit for the civil service because the age limit was cut. Which factor does this illustrate, and why did it anger the educated? Working: (1) the cut came as Indians began to succeed; (2) the examination was held only in England, which already favoured the well-off; (3) the effect was to keep Indians out of high office. Answer: racial discrimination, which convinced the educated class that the colonial state would not share power fairly.
Worked example 2: judging an organisation
Question: give one strength and one weakness of the MNA. Working: strength: it pressed grievances on Parliament through petitions, one with about fourteen thousand signatures, and marked the start of organised opinion. Weakness: it spoke for the landed elite of one Presidency. Answer: it pioneered organised petitioning, but a body representing all sections of all India was still needed, which the Congress would supply.
MNA 1852 (Lakshminarasu, petitions to Parliament) - MMS 1884 (16 May, merged with the Congress) - Indian National Congress 1885.
Key takeaways: bitter memories of 1857, exclusion from high office, laws such as Section 124A and the Vernacular Press Act, the Ilbert Bill controversy, a growing press and pride in India's heritage all fed national feeling. In Madras the MNA (1852) petitioned Parliament against Company misrule and the MMS (1884) later merged with the Congress.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Vernacular Press Act of 1878 was resented because it:
- censored the Indian-language press
- abolished customs duty on English cloth
- allowed Indian judges to try Europeans
- reduced the civil service age limit
Show answer
Answer: A. The Vernacular Press Act censored the press in Indian languages. The other options describe other grievances listed in the book.
-
2. The Ilbert Bill, introduced under Viceroy Ripon, proposed that:
- Indians could sit the civil service examination in India
- Indian judges could try Europeans
- the Company's rule should end
- excise duty be put on Indian cloth
Show answer
Answer: B. It empowered Indian judges to try Europeans; European opposition got it amended to suit their interests.
-
3. Who inspired the founding of the Madras Native Association?
- H.D. Seymour
- Salem Ramaswamy
- Ananda Charlu
- Gajula Lakshminarasu
Show answer
Answer: D. The book names Gajula Lakshminarasu, a prominent Madras businessman, as the inspiration behind the MNA (1852). Seymour was a visiting British reformer; the others were MMS figures.
-
4. What did the MNA's second petition to Parliament ask for?
- A university in Madras
- Repeal of Section 124A
- An end to Company rule and direct rule by the Crown
- Simultaneous civil service examinations
Show answer
Answer: C. After the Charter Act of 1853 kept the Company in power, the MNA's second petition, with about fourteen thousand signatures, asked for Company rule to end and for transfer to the Crown.
-
5. Arrange in chronological order: (i) Vernacular Press Act (ii) Madras Native Association (iii) Madras Mahajana Sabha (iv) Section 124A added to the Penal Code.
- ii, iv, i, iii
- iv, ii, i, iii
- ii, i, iv, iii
- i, ii, iii, iv
Show answer
Answer: A. MNA 1852; Section 124A 1870; Vernacular Press Act 1878; MMS 1884. So the order is ii, iv, i, iii.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.