- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
The Indian National Congress, early nationalists and the drain theory
Describe how and why the Indian National Congress was founded, its early demands, the methods of the Moderates and the rise of radical voices, and explain Dadabhai Naoroji's drain of wealth theory.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why scattered protests of 1875-85 led to a national organisation, and describe the founding of the Congress in 1885.
- List the constitutional, economic, administrative and judicial demands of the early Congress.
- Explain the methods of the Moderates, the rise of radical leaders, and Naoroji's drain theory.
By the 1880s Indians had grievances, newspapers and local associations. What was missing was a single body speaking for the whole country. This lesson looks at how the Indian National Congress filled that gap and how its early leaders built the first Indian critique of colonialism.
Why a national organisation
The book lists agitations between 1875 and 1885: the Indian textile industry's campaign on cotton import duties (1875), demands for Indianisation of government services (1877), protests against the Vernacular Press Act (1878) and agitation over the Ilbert Bill (1883). These were scattered and uncoordinated, and leaders realised they would not move policy-makers without a national political organisation. The name Indian National Congress itself expressed the idea of India as one nation.
Founding of the Congress, 1885
In December 1884 Allan Octavian Hume, a retired English ICS officer, presided over a meeting of the Theosophical Society in Madras, where the idea of an all-India political organisation emerged. The Indian National Congress was formed on 28 December 1885 in Bombay, with W.C. Bonnerjee elected as its first president. It was small, with under a hundred members, but it had an all-India character and served as a common platform for movements in different regions. One of its main aims, the book says, was to weld Indians into a nation.
| Area | Demand |
|---|---|
| Constitutional | Indian representation and participation in government |
| Economic | Lower land revenue, protection of peasants from zamindars, heavy duties on imports to help swadeshi goods |
| Administrative | Indianisation of services through simultaneous civil service examinations in England and India |
| Judicial | Complete separation of the executive and the judiciary |
The early nationalists (1885-1915)
The early leaders were lawyers, teachers, doctors and journalists from the elite, but from all regions. They used constitutional methods: petitions, prayers and memoranda, which earned them the name Moderates. The book stresses that no ready-made anti-colonial theory existed then; the early nationalists developed the idea of Indians as one nation and an indigenous anti-colonial ideology that later mass leaders such as Gandhi built on.
From the late 1890s some leaders, notably Bipin Chandra Pal, Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Lala Lajpat Rai, wanted more than petitions and were called Extremists. The book connects Tilak's call 'Swaraj is my birthright and I shall have it' with this period and gives the year 1897. The book's view is that the two groups should not be seen as opposite poles: both were part of one national movement, and both contributed to the Swadeshi movement after the partition of Bengal in 1905, when the Moderates too accepted boycott and mass mobilisation.
Moderates and Extremists (to be studied further in the next chapter)
-
Moderates
- Petitions, prayers, memoranda
- Asked for economic and administrative reforms
- Naoroji, Gokhale, Pherozeshah Mehta, Surendranath Banerjea
-
Extremists
- Wanted more radical methods
- Asked for Swaraj
- Tilak, Lajpat Rai, Bipin Chandra Pal
Leaders as educators: the press
Both groups saw themselves as educators. When the Congress was founded, the book says, one-third of its members were journalists. Naoroji edited the Voice of India and Rast Goftar; Surendranath Banerjea edited the Bengalee; Tilak edited the Kesari and the Mahratta. Tilak believed the lower middle classes, peasants, artisans and workers could play a large role, and used his papers to voice their discontent. On 27 July 1897 he was arrested under Section 124A. Civil liberty, especially freedom of expression and of the press, became central to the freedom struggle.
Naoroji and the drain theory
Dadabhai Naoroji, called the Grand Old Man of Indian Nationalism, served in Bombay's municipal bodies in the 1870s, founded the India Society (1865) and the East India Association (1866) in London, was elected to the British Parliament in 1892, and was thrice president of the Congress. In Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901) he set out the drain of wealth. In any country, he argued, taxes should be spent on that country's people; in British India they were spent for England's welfare. According to the book, he calculated that India exported an average of 13 million pounds worth of goods a year to Britain from 1835 to 1872 with no corresponding return, and that the Home Charges made up a loss of 30 million pounds a year.
What made up the Home Charges (Naoroji's drain)
- Profits to Company shareholders in Britain
- Guaranteed interest to railway investors
- Pensions to retired officials and generals
- Interest on loans for wars of conquest in and outside India
Worked example 1: estimating the size of the drain
Question: Naoroji's average export without return was 13 million pounds a year from 1835 to 1872. Roughly how much is that over the whole period? Working: 1872 − 1835 = 37, and counting both end years gives 38 years; 13 × 38 = 494. Answer: about 494 million pounds, close to 500 million, which shows why the figure alarmed nationalists.
Worked example 2: classifying a demand
Question: classify 'English judges treat Indian political workers unfairly, so the officer who prosecutes should not also judge'. Working: the complaint is about courts; the remedy separates those who govern from those who judge. Answer: a judicial demand, the separation of the executive and the judiciary.
INC: 28 December 1885, Bombay; Hume helped found it; Bonnerjee first president. Drain theory: Naoroji, Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901) - India's wealth flowed to Britain as Home Charges without return.
Key takeaways: scattered protests of 1875-85 showed the need for one national body, and the Congress was founded in Bombay on 28 December 1885. Its early demands were constitutional, economic, administrative and judicial. The Moderates used petitions and the press; radicals such as Tilak wanted Swaraj, but the book sees both as parts of one movement. Naoroji's drain theory exposed how Home Charges carried India's wealth to Britain.
Check your understanding
-
1. Where and when was the Indian National Congress founded?
- Madras, 16 May 1884
- Calcutta, 28 December 1886
- Bombay, 28 December 1885
- Poona, December 1895
Show answer
Answer: C. The book records its founding on 28 December 1885 in Bombay, with W.C. Bonnerjee as first president. 16 May 1884 is the Madras Mahajana Sabha's inaugural meeting.
-
2. Simultaneous civil service examinations in England and India was a demand of which type?
- Judicial
- Administrative
- Economic
- Religious
Show answer
Answer: B. The book lists Indianisation of services through simultaneous examinations as the administrative demand of the early Congress.
-
3. Which book of Dadabhai Naoroji set out the drain of wealth theory?
- Poverty and Un-British Rule in India
- Hind Swaraj
- Discovery of India
- Gita Rahasya
Show answer
Answer: A. Naoroji's Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901) explained how India's wealth was drained to Britain.
-
4. Which item was NOT part of the Home Charges described by Naoroji?
- Pensions to retired officials and generals
- Guaranteed interest to railway investors
- Interest on loans for wars of conquest
- Grants to Indian handloom weavers
Show answer
Answer: D. Home Charges were payments to Britain: shareholders' profits, railway interest, pensions and war-loan interest. Grants to Indian weavers were no part of them.
-
5. Why were the early Congress leaders called 'Moderates'?
- They opposed all reform
- They used constitutional methods such as petitions, prayers and memoranda
- They were all members of the Theosophical Society
- They wanted the Company to continue ruling India
Show answer
Answer: B. The book says their constitutional methods of petitions, prayers and memoranda earned them the name Moderates.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.