• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Militant nationalism and the Surat split

Explain the outlook of the Lal-Bal-Pal leadership, how militants differed from moderates over methods and Swaraj, why militant nationalism declined by 1908, and how the Congress split at Surat in 1907.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Compare the moderate and militant views of British rule and their meanings of Swaraj.
  • Identify continuities between the two phases and the weaknesses of militant nationalism.
  • Narrate the events from the Calcutta session of 1906 to the Surat split of 1907 and its results.

The Swadeshi years made Maharashtra, Bengal and Punjab centres of a more assertive nationalism. This lesson looks at what the militants believed, where they differed from the moderates and where they did not, and how the disagreement split the Congress in 1907.

Lal-Bal-Pal and the militant outlook

Lala Lajpat Rai, Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Bipin Chandra Pal, often called the Lal-Bal-Pal triumvirate, made Punjab, Maharashtra and Bengal the epicentres of militant nationalism; Aurobindo Ghose was another influential leader. Both groups knew the wrongs of British rule. The difference, the book explains, lay in their view of the rulers: the moderates believed British rule could be reformed by persuasion, representation and petitions, while the militants held that the colonial rulers would never listen to reason because they would not give up the advantages of empire. Militant nationalism also shifted political pressure from the opinion of educated Indians to protesting masses.

Moderates and militants compared

  • Moderates
    • British rule can be reformed by persuasion
    • Petitions, representations, educated opinion
    • Limited reforms; annulment of partition
    • Critical of revolutionaries
  • Militants
    • Rulers will not give up empire's advantages
    • Boycott and mass protest
    • Swaraj
    • Sympathetic to revolutionaries but against political murder

Continuity and differences

The book stresses continuity too. The militants did not move beyond peaceful methods, and for the most part militant nationalism stayed tied to non-violence. But they appealed to patriotic feeling through religious symbols.

Their common goal was Swaraj, though they meant different things by it. For Tilak, Swaraj meant Indian control of the administration, rule by Indians, but not a total break with Britain. For Bipin Chandra Pal it meant complete freedom from any foreign rule. On revolutionaries in Bengal, Punjab and Maharashtra, the moderates were critical, while the militants were sympathetic; yet the militant leaders did not approve of political murders or individual acts of terror and were careful not to associate themselves with them.

Decline of militant nationalism

By 1908, the book says, militant nationalism was declining. It gives these reasons: patriotism combined with the assertion of Hindu beliefs was not acceptable to Muslims; like their predecessors, the leaders failed to reach the larger sections of society; and the Surat split of 1907 weakened them further, while government repression put the main leaders in jail.

The Surat split, 1907

Tension grew after Lord Minto became Viceroy in 1906. At the Calcutta session of 1906 a split was avoided by electing Dadabhai Naoroji as president, and the militants managed to pass four resolutions: on Swadeshi, Boycott, National Education and Self-Government. The next session was planned for Poona, a militant stronghold, but the moderates, fearing a repeat of Calcutta, moved it to Surat. The militants proposed Lala Lajpat Rai for president against the moderates' candidate Rash Behari Ghosh; Lajpat Rai declined to avoid a split. The dispute came down to whether the four Calcutta resolutions would be kept. The Pherozeshah Mehta group wanted them dropped; the militants then opposed Ghosh's election, and the session ended in chaos.

Road to the Surat split

  1. Calcutta, 1906 Naoroji president; four militant resolutions passed.
  2. Venue moved Poona replaced by Surat.
  3. Presidency contest Lajpat Rai declines; Rash Behari Ghosh is the moderate choice.
  4. Resolutions dispute Mehta group seeks to drop the four resolutions.
  5. Surat, 1907 Session ends in chaos; Congress splits.

After Surat, the Congress without the militants, sometimes called the 'Mehta Congress', was, in the book's words, more loyal to the British than before; its 1908 session was attended only by moderates, who reaffirmed loyalty to the Raj. The militants could not form a new organisation, chiefly because the government jailed their prominent leaders.

Worked example 1: comparing two meanings of Swaraj

Question: a speaker says, 'Indians must run the government of India, but the link with Britain can remain.' Whose idea of Swaraj is closer? Working: (1) Tilak: Indian control of administration without total severance from Britain; (2) Pal: complete freedom from any foreign rule. The speaker keeps the link. Answer: closer to Tilak's view.

Worked example 2: why did the venue matter?

Question: why did the moderates move the 1907 session from Poona to Surat? Working: (1) at Calcutta in 1906 the militants had pushed through four resolutions; (2) Poona was Tilak's region and a militant stronghold, where local delegates might help them again; (3) a venue outside that stronghold improved the moderates' chances of controlling the session. Answer: to avoid a repeat of the Calcutta session, as the book says.

Calcutta 1906: four resolutions (Swadeshi, Boycott, National Education, Self-Government). Surat 1907: dispute over keeping them; Rash Behari Ghosh vs the militants; the Congress splits.

Key takeaways: Lal-Bal-Pal and Aurobindo Ghose led a more assertive nationalism that relied on the masses rather than petitions, but stayed largely peaceful and used religious symbols. Tilak and Pal meant different things by Swaraj. Militant nationalism declined by 1908 through narrow appeal, alienation of Muslims, repression and the Surat split, after which the moderate Congress reaffirmed loyalty.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The four resolutions passed at the Calcutta session of 1906 were on:

    1. Swadeshi, Boycott, National Education and Self-Government
    2. Swaraj, Partition, Press and Courts
    3. Home Rule, Khilafat, Boycott and Swadeshi
    4. Education, Railways, Famine and Taxes
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The militants managed to pass resolutions on Swadeshi, Boycott, National Education and Self-Government; keeping them was the main dispute at Surat.

  2. 2. Whose name did the militants propose as president for the Surat session?

    1. Aurobindo Ghose
    2. Pherozeshah Mehta
    3. Lala Lajpat Rai
    4. Dadabhai Naoroji
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The militants proposed Lala Lajpat Rai against the moderates' Rash Behari Ghosh, but Lajpat Rai declined to avoid a split.

  3. 3. For Bipin Chandra Pal, Swaraj meant:

    1. Indian control of administration while keeping the link with Britain
    2. complete freedom from any foreign rule
    3. more Indian seats in the councils
    4. annulment of the partition only
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The book contrasts Tilak's Swaraj (rule by Indians without total severance from Britain) with Pal's complete freedom from foreign rule.

  4. 4. Which statement about the militant nationalists is correct according to the textbook?

    1. They organised most political murders in Bengal
    2. They rejected all religious symbols
    3. They supported the moderates at Surat
    4. They were sympathetic to revolutionaries but did not approve of political murders
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book says militants were sympathetic to revolutionaries but did not approve of political murders or individual terrorism and kept their distance from them.

  5. 5. Why did the militants fail to form a new organisation after Surat, according to the book?

    1. Their prominent leaders were jailed by the government
    2. They rejoined the moderates in 1908
    3. They lacked newspapers
    4. The Viceroy invited them into his council
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The book says the primary reason was government repression, which put all the prominent militant leaders in jail.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery