• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

The extremist trend and the partition of Bengal

Explain why an extremist trend rose against moderate politics, describe Curzon's measures, and analyse the reasons given for the partition of Bengal and its real aims as the textbook presents them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the reasons the book gives for the rise of the extremist or militant trend.
  • Describe Lord Curzon's measures before the partition of Bengal.
  • Compare the official reasons for partition with the aims the textbook attributes to Curzon, and explain why the partition united Bengalis instead.

In the previous chapter the early nationalists used petitions and prayers. By the 1890s many in the Congress were impatient with this approach. This lesson explains the rise of a more assertive trend and the event that set it alight: the partition of Bengal in 1905.

Resentment against moderate politics

By the last decade of the nineteenth century, the book says, there was open resentment within the Congress against moderate politics. Critics called the moderates' habit of appealing to the British through prayers and petitions a 'mendicant policy' (the politics of a beggar). The new trend, called extremist, radical or militant, was led by Bal Gangadhar Tilak in Maharashtra, Bipin Chandra Pal in Bengal and Lala Lajpat Rai in Punjab. The book gives three main reasons for its rise: factionalism in the Congress, frustration with moderate methods, and anger against Lord Curzon for dividing Bengal.

The book calls the Swadeshi movement (1905-1911) the most important phase of the national movement before Gandhi, because during it the movement changed in its objectives, methods and social base. Women, workers, peasants and marginalised groups met modern nationalist ideas for the first time, and the press in Indian languages, such as Swadesamitran in Tamil Nadu, Kesari in Maharashtra and Yugantar in Bengal, became more openly nationalist.

Curzon's measures

Lord Curzon became Viceroy and Governor General on 6 January 1899, when famine and plague had already made British rule unpopular. Instead of engaging the educated class, the book says, he took a series of repressive measures:

  1. He reduced the number of elected Indian members of the Calcutta Corporation (1899).
  2. The Universities Act of 1904 brought Calcutta University under direct government control.
  3. The Official Secrets Act was amended (1904) to curb the nationalist tone of newspapers.
  4. Finally he ordered the partition of Bengal (1905).

The partition plan

The Bengal Presidency was indeed very large, and its division had been discussed since the 1860s; the idea was revived in March 1890. On a tour of Assam, European planters asked Curzon for a sea outlet closer to Calcutta so that they would depend less on the Assam-Bengal railway. In December 1903 Curzon set out a scheme in his Minutes on Territorial Redistribution of India, later modified and published as the Risley Papers. These gave two official reasons: relief of Bengal and improvement of Assam. The book notes that they hid the fact that the plan was first devised for the convenience of British officials and European businessmen.

Between December 1903 and 1905 a small transfer of territory grew into a full partition. A new province of Eastern Bengal and Assam was to include the Chittagong and Dhaka divisions, parts of Rajshahi, the hills of Tippera, Assam and Malda.

The two provinces of 1905-1911 (figures from the textbook's map)
ProvinceArea (km²)Population (million)Muslims (million)Muslims (%)
Bengal3,66,69254916.67
Eastern Bengal and Assam2,75,938311858.06

The aims the book attributes to Curzon

In the textbook's judgement, Curzon's intention was to suppress political activity against British rule in Bengal and to create a Hindu-Muslim divide. The government ignored civil servants' alternative proposals, especially a division on linguistic lines, because that would have strengthened Bengali politicians. Curzon knew that the river Bhagirathi roughly divided a Muslim-majority east from a Hindu-majority west. In a speech at Dhaka in February 1904 he assured Muslims that the new province would give them a unity they had not enjoyed since the days of the old Muslim rulers. The book calls the partition a prime example of the British policy of divide and rule.

The plan backfired. The book says the British underestimated a Bengali identity that cut across caste, class, religion and region. Bengali had become a literary language with Rabindranath Tagore at its centre, regional newspapers built a sense of solidarity, and recurring famine, unemployment and economic slump had already bred anti-colonial feeling. So the partition united Bengalis instead of dividing them.

Partition of Bengal: stated reasons and the textbook's reading

  • Reasons stated in the Risley Papers
    • Relief of an over-large Bengal
    • Improvement of Assam
  • Aims the textbook attributes to Curzon
    • Convenience of officials and European business
    • Weakening Bengali political activity
    • A Hindu-Muslim divide (divide and rule)
  • Actual result
    • Bengalis united across religion and class
    • Nation-wide protest
    • A new phase of the national movement

Worked example 1: checking the map's percentages

Question: verify the Muslim percentages in the table. Working: Bengal: 9 ÷ 54 = 0.1667, that is 16.67%. Eastern Bengal and Assam: 18 ÷ 31 = 0.5806, that is 58.06%. Answer: the figures are consistent. They show what the book argues: the new eastern province had a Muslim majority, while Bengal was left with a large Hindu majority.

Worked example 2: using a speech as evidence

Question: how does Curzon's Dhaka speech of February 1904 support the book's view of the partition? Working: (1) the official reasons were administrative; (2) yet the Viceroy spoke to one community about the unity it would gain in the new province; (3) an administrative reform would not need a religious appeal. Answer: the speech suggests a political aim of winning Muslim support and separating the communities, which is why the book calls the partition divide and rule.

Partition of Bengal: scheme December 1903, declared 19 July 1905, in force 16 October 1905. Official aim: administration. The textbook's reading: divide and rule. Result: Bengali unity and nation-wide protest.

Key takeaways: the extremist trend rose from factionalism, frustration with mendicant politics and anger at Curzon. Curzon cut Indian seats in the Calcutta Corporation, controlled the university and curbed the press, then partitioned Bengal. The Risley Papers spoke of relief and improvement, but the book sees an aim to weaken Bengali politics and divide Hindus and Muslims. Instead, a shared Bengali identity turned the partition into the spark of the Swadeshi movement (1905-1911).

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The moderates' practice of appealing to the British through prayers and petitions was criticised by the militants as:

    1. passive resistance
    2. atmashakti
    3. the mendicant policy
    4. divide and rule
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Militants mocked the moderates' cautious appeals as a 'mendicant' (begging) policy.

  2. 2. Which of these was NOT one of Curzon's measures before the partition?

    1. Reducing elected Indians in the Calcutta Corporation
    2. The Universities Act of 1904
    3. Amending the Official Secrets Act
    4. The Indian Press Act of 1910
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Indian Press Act came in 1910, after Curzon. The other three are listed in the book as Curzon's measures of 1899-1904.

  3. 3. The official reasons for partition given in the Risley Papers were:

    1. relief of Bengal and improvement of Assam
    2. Hindu-Muslim unity and Bengali culture
    3. a linguistic division of Bengal
    4. the needs of the Indian National Congress
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The report gave relief of Bengal and improvement of Assam; the book says it concealed that the plan suited officials and European businessmen.

  4. 4. Why, according to the book, did Curzon reject a division of Bengal on linguistic lines?

    1. It would have been too costly
    2. It would have strengthened the position of Bengali politicians
    3. Assam's planters opposed it
    4. The Congress had demanded it
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A linguistic division would have further consolidated Bengali politicians, so Curzon preferred a division that separated Hindu-majority and Muslim-majority areas.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The partition united the people of Bengal. Reason (R): A Bengali identity had grown that cut across caste, class, religion and region.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. The book says the British underestimated a Bengali identity, built through literature and the press, which made people unite against the partition.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery