• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Home Rule Leagues of Tilak and Besant

Describe how Tilak's and Besant's Home Rule Leagues were set up and worked, how the government repressed them, why they mattered for later mass politics, and why they declined.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the twin objectives of the Home Rule Leagues and the areas of each League.
  • Describe the internment of Besant in 1917, the protests and the Montagu declaration.
  • Explain the importance of the Home Rule movement and the reasons for its decline.

In 1916 India had two Home Rule Leagues working side by side, one led by Tilak and one by Besant. They kept politics alive during the war and trained many of the workers who would later follow Gandhi. This lesson looks at how they worked.

Bringing the extremists back

The moderates disliked the idea of another separate organisation, and Besant knew she needed the Congress's approval. In December 1915, through the efforts of Tilak and Besant, the Bombay session changed the Congress constitution so that members of the extremist section could be admitted. Besant insisted the Congress take up the Home Rule programme before September 1916, or she would organise a League herself.

In 1916 two Home Rule Leagues were launched, with their areas clearly divided. Their twin objectives were: (1) to establish Home Rule for India within the British Empire, and (2) to arouse in the Indian masses a sense of pride in the motherland.

The two Home Rule Leagues of 1916

  • Tilak's League
    • Founded April 1916 at the Bombay Provincial Conference, Belgaum
    • Maharashtra (with Bombay city), Karnataka, Central Provinces and Berar
    • Six branches
    • About 14,000 members (April 1917), 32,000 (early 1918)
  • Besant's League
    • Inaugurated at Madras, September 1916
    • The rest of India
    • Branches at Kanpur, Allahabad, Benaras, Mathura, Calicut, Ahmednagar and elsewhere
    • Strongly supported in Madras

Tilak's League

Tilak spread the demand for Home Rule through lectures. His League's popularity was confined to Maharashtra and Karnataka, but it claimed 14,000 members in April 1917 and 32,000 by early 1918. The book records that on 23 July 1916, his sixtieth birthday, Tilak was arrested for propagating Home Rule.

Besant's League

Seeing no move from the Congress, Besant inaugurated her League at Madras in September 1916 and toured widely, declaring that the price of India's loyalty was India's freedom. Moderates unhappy with the Congress's inactivity joined, and so did figures such as Jawaharlal Nehru, Muhammad Ali Jinnah, B. Chakravarti, Jitendralal Banerji, Satyamurti and Khaliquzzaman.

Repression and the Montagu declaration

The Madras government barred students from the League's meetings, and in June 1917 interned Besant, B.P. Wadia and George Arundale at Ootacamund. Repression strengthened the movement. Sir S. Subramaniam renounced his knighthood; leaders who had kept away, such as Madan Mohan Malaviya and Surendranath Banerjea, joined. At the AICC meeting of 28 July 1917 Tilak proposed civil disobedience if the internees were not freed, and, on Gandhi's advice, Jamnadas Dwarkadas and Shankerlal Banker collected a thousand signatures of people willing to defy the orders and march to Besant's place of detention. The internees were released.

On 20 August 1917 the Secretary of State Edwin Montagu announced that the goal of British rule in India was 'self-governing institutions and responsible government'. The book says this almost overnight made Besant a near-loyalist. Released in September 1917, she was elected president of the Calcutta session of the Congress in 1917.

From internment to the Montagu declaration (1917)

  1. June 1917 Besant, Wadia and Arundale interned at Ootacamund.
  2. Protest grows Knighthood renounced; new leaders join; signatures for defiance.
  3. Release Government frees the internees.
  4. 20 August 1917 Montagu promises responsible government as the goal.
  5. December 1917 Besant presides over the Calcutta Congress.

Importance and decline

The book gives the Leagues a lasting importance. They prepared the ground for mass mobilisation and for Gandhi's satyagrahas: many early Gandhian satyagrahis had been Home Rule members and used the Leagues' networks. The book calls the Home Rule League the first Indian political movement to cut across sectarian lines, with members from the Congress, the League, the Theosophists and labour.

The movement declined after Besant accepted the proposed Montagu-Chelmsford reforms and Tilak went to Britain in September 1918 to pursue his libel case against Valentine Chirol, author of Indian Unrest. Besant's Indian Home Rule League was renamed the Commonwealth of India League, which lobbied British MPs for dominion status like that of Canada and Australia, and was later turned by V.K. Krishna Menon into the India League.

Worked example 1: growth of Tilak's League

Question: by what percentage did Tilak's League grow from April 1917 to early 1918? Working: increase = 32,000 − 14,000 = 18,000; percentage = 18,000 ÷ 14,000 × 100 ≈ 128.6%. Answer: membership more than doubled, growing by about 129%.

Worked example 2: why repression backfired

Question: explain, using 1917 events, why repression strengthened the Home Rule movement. Working: (1) Besant's internment made her a martyr in public eyes; (2) respected figures, Sir S. Subramaniam, Malaviya and Banerjea, now openly sided with her; (3) the threat of mass defiance worried the government, which released the internees and soon issued the Montagu declaration. Answer: repression widened support and forced the government to make a political promise.

Home Rule Leagues (1916): Home Rule within the Empire + pride in the motherland. Tilak: Belgaum, April 1916. Besant: Madras, September 1916. Montagu declaration: 20 August 1917.

Key takeaways: the Bombay Congress of 1915 readmitted the extremists. In 1916 Tilak's League (west and centre) and Besant's League (rest of India) worked for Home Rule within the Empire. Besant's internment in 1917 widened support and was followed by the Montagu declaration. The Leagues built networks that Gandhi's satyagrahas used, and declined after 1918.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Where was Tilak's Home Rule League set up in April 1916?

    1. Madras
    2. Lucknow
    3. At the Bombay Provincial Conference at Belgaum
    4. Calcutta
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The book says Tilak's League was set up at the Bombay Provincial Conference held at Belgaum in April 1916.

  2. 2. Who were interned at Ootacamund in June 1917?

    1. Tilak, Lajpat Rai and Pal
    2. Besant, B.P. Wadia and George Arundale
    3. Gandhi, Malaviya and Jinnah
    4. Satyamurti, Nehru and Khaliquzzaman
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Madras government interned Annie Besant and her associates B.P. Wadia and George Arundale at Ootacamund.

  3. 3. What did the Montagu declaration of 20 August 1917 announce as the goal of British rule?

    1. Self-governing institutions and responsible government
    2. Complete independence by 1920
    3. Separate electorates for all communities
    4. Abolition of the Congress
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Montagu announced 'self-governing institutions and responsible government' as the goal, which the book says made Besant almost a loyalist.

  4. 4. Valentine Chirol, against whom Tilak pursued a libel case in Britain, was the author of:

    1. How India Wrought for Freedom
    2. Poverty and Un-British Rule in India
    3. Hind Swaraj
    4. Indian Unrest
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Chirol wrote Indian Unrest. Tilak's journey to Britain in 1918 for the case is one reason the book gives for the decline of Home Rule.

  5. 5. Which of the following does the book give as an importance of the Home Rule Leagues?

    1. They won dominion status for India in 1918
    2. They prepared networks later used for Gandhi's satyagrahas
    3. They ended the Lucknow Pact
    4. They merged with the Muslim League
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Many early Gandhian satyagrahis had been Home Rule members, and they used the Leagues' organisational networks.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery