- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The war, Congress reunion and the Lucknow Pact
Explain how the war brought the moderates, extremists and Muslim League together, and describe the provisions and significance of the Lucknow Pact of 1916.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the political situation created by the Minto-Morley reforms of 1909.
- Trace the steps from the memorandum of October 1916 to the Lucknow sessions of December 1916.
- List and explain the provisions of the Lucknow Pact and assess its significance.
In 1916 the Congress reunited and, together with the Muslim League, presented joint demands to the British. This lesson explains how that happened and what the two bodies agreed at Lucknow.
Before the war: a divided scene
The book describes Indian politics before the war as in disarray. To win over the moderates and the Muslim League and to isolate the extremists, the British passed the Minto-Morley reforms in 1909. The moderates waited and watched; the League welcomed the separate electorates given to Muslims. In 1913 new leaders joined the League, the most prominent being Muhammad Ali Jinnah, already a Congress member, who demanded more reforms for Muslims.
How the war brought them together
At first Britain did not seek Indian support, but once fighting spread to West Asia and Africa it needed it, and Indian leaders decided to press for reforms. The Congress and the League both met at Bombay in 1915 and spoke in similar tones. In October 1916 the Hindu and Muslim elected members of the Imperial Legislative Council sent a memorandum to the Viceroy on post-war reforms; the government was unmoved. In November 1916 the Congress and the League met at Calcutta, discussed the memorandum and agreed on the composition of legislatures and each community's representation. Meanwhile the extremists had been readmitted to the Congress, so 1916 became a historic year: the Congress, the Muslim League and the Home Rule League all held their annual sessions at Lucknow. The Congress president Ambika Charan Mazumdar welcomed the extremists back after ten years of separation.
Tilak and Besant helped bring the Congress and the League together in what is called the Congress-League Pact or Lucknow Pact, and Jinnah played a pivotal role. The Calcutta agreements of November were confirmed at the December 1916 sessions.
Road to the Lucknow Pact
- Bombay, 1915 Congress and League sessions in similar tones; Congress opens its doors to extremists.
- October 1916 Memorandum of elected members to the Viceroy.
- Calcutta, November 1916 Congress and League agree on representation.
- Lucknow, December 1916 Both sessions confirm the Pact; Congress reunited.
Provisions of the Lucknow Pact
| Area | What the Pact proposed |
|---|---|
| Provinces | As free as possible from central control in administration and finance |
| Legislatures | Four-fifths of central and provincial councils elected on as broad a franchise as possible, one-fifth nominated |
| Executive councils | Half the members, including the central executive council, to be Indians elected by the councils |
| Muslim representation | Congress accepted separate electorates for Muslims in provincial elections, with weightage beyond their population share except in Punjab and Bengal, where some ground was given to Hindu and Sikh minorities |
| Power of councils | Governments bound by council resolutions; a vetoed resolution passed again after at least one year to take effect |
| Imperial status | The Secretary of State's relation to India like the Colonial Secretary's to the Dominions; India equal with the Dominions in imperial bodies |
Significance
The book says the Pact paved the way for Hindu-Muslim unity, which reached its height during the Khilafat and Non-Cooperation movements. It showed that educated members of the Congress and the League could work together for a common goal. Sarojini Naidu (the book calls her Sarojini Ammaiyar) called Jinnah, the chief architect of the Pact, the 'Ambassador of Hindu-Muslim Unity'. Historians also note that by accepting separate electorates the Congress recognised the principle introduced in 1909, an arrangement whose later effects are studied in coming chapters.
Worked example 1: applying the four-fifths rule
Question: under the Pact's proposal, how many members of an imagined council of 125 would be elected and how many nominated? (The number 125 is made up for practice.) Working: elected = 4/5 × 125 = 100; nominated = 1/5 × 125 = 25; check: 100 + 25 = 125. Answer: 100 elected and 25 nominated.
Worked example 2: the one-year rule
Question: a provincial council passes a resolution in March 1918; the Governor-in-Council vetoes it. Under the Pact's proposal, what must happen for it to take effect? Working: (1) a vetoed resolution can be passed again only after an interval of not less than one year; (2) so the council must wait until at least March 1919; (3) if passed again then, it should be put into effect. Answer: re-pass it no earlier than March 1919, after which the government must act on it.
Lucknow Pact (December 1916): Congress and League agree on joint reform demands - four-fifths elected councils, half the executive Indian, separate electorates for Muslims - and the Congress is reunited.
Key takeaways: the 1909 reforms aimed, the book says, to isolate the extremists and gave Muslims separate electorates. The war gave Indians leverage; the October 1916 memorandum and the Calcutta talks led to the Lucknow sessions of December 1916, where the Congress reunited and signed a pact with the League. The Pact sought elected majorities, Indian executives, provincial autonomy, Dominion-like status and separate electorates, and opened the way to Hindu-Muslim cooperation in the Khilafat and Non-Cooperation movements.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the book, the British passed the Minto-Morley reforms of 1909 mainly to:
- grant dominion status
- win over the moderates and the League and isolate the extremists
- abolish separate electorates
- hand power to the Home Rule Leagues
Show answer
Answer: B. The book says the reforms were meant to win over the moderates and the Muslim League so as to isolate the extremists.
-
2. Who presided over the Lucknow session of the Congress in 1916 and welcomed back the extremists?
- Annie Besant
- Ambika Charan Mazumdar
- Muhammad Ali Jinnah
- Rash Behari Ghosh
Show answer
Answer: B. Ambika Charan Mazumdar, the Congress president at Lucknow, welcomed the extremists after ten years of separation.
-
3. Under the Lucknow Pact, what share of the central and provincial councils was to be elected?
- One-half
- Two-thirds
- Four-fifths
- All members
Show answer
Answer: C. Four-fifths were to be elected on as broad a franchise as possible and one-fifth nominated.
-
4. Who called Jinnah the 'Ambassador of Hindu-Muslim Unity', according to the textbook?
- Annie Besant
- Bal Gangadhar Tilak
- Gandhi
- Sarojini Naidu
Show answer
Answer: D. The book says Sarojini Ammaiyar (Sarojini Naidu) gave Jinnah this title as the chief architect of the Lucknow Pact.
-
5. The Lucknow session of 1916 is especially noted for:
- the Congress accepting the League's demand for separate electorates for Muslims
- the Congress splitting again
- the League merging permanently with the Congress
- the launch of the Non-Cooperation movement
Show answer
Answer: A. At Lucknow the Congress agreed to separate electorates for Muslims in provincial elections as part of the joint scheme with the League.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.