- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Linguistic reorganisation of states
Trace the idea of linguistic provinces from the Nagpur Congress of 1920 to the Linguistic Provinces Commission, the JVP Committee, Potti Sriramulu's fast, the States Reorganisation Commission and the changes of 1956, 1960 and 1966.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why language became a basis for drawing state boundaries, and trace the idea from 1920 to 1946.
- Describe the reports of the Linguistic Provinces Commission (1948) and the JVP Committee (1949), and Article 3 of the Constitution.
- Explain the effect of Potti Sriramulu's fast, the States Reorganisation Commission and the reorganisation of 1956-1966.
Section 8.4 of the textbook explains that the British had drawn provinces and presidencies for administrative convenience, without regard to language and culture. In a democracy where the people are sovereign, the book argues, India as a multicultural nation had to apply federal principles fully, not just as an administrative device.
The idea in the national movement
- Nagpur session of the Congress, 1920: national identity was to be achieved through linguistic identity, and Provincial Congress Committees were set up on a linguistic basis.
- Nehru Report, 1928 (Section 86): provinces should be redistributed on a linguistic basis if most people of an area wanted it, subject to financial and administrative considerations.
- Congress election manifesto, 1945: provinces should be formed as far as possible on a linguistic and cultural basis, so that each group could develop its own life and culture within the nation.
- 31 August 1946: Pattabhi Sitaramayya demanded an Andhra province as the first problem for the Constituent Assembly, and on 8 December 1946 presided over a conference asking the Assembly to accept the linguistic principle.
Postponement, 1947-1949
The matter was debated in the Constituent Assembly between 1947 and 1949 but held over, because the task was huge and could cause problems so soon after partition and its violence. The Drafting Committee found that Andhra could not be named as a separate unit until its territory was defined, so on 17 June 1948 Rajendra Prasad set up the three-member Linguistic Provinces Commission to examine Andhra, Kerala, Karnataka and Maharashtra. Its report of 10 December 1948 argued against linguistic reorganisation at that time.
The demand did not stop. After Pattabhi Sitaramayya became Congress President at the Jaipur session, a committee of Jawaharlal Nehru, Vallabhbhai Patel and Pattabhi Sitaramayya - the JVP Committee - was formed. Its report of 1 April 1949 called the demand, in the circumstances, 'narrow provincialism' that could become a menace to development, and observed that language binds but also separates. It accepted that boundaries could be adjusted later, when conditions were calmer, and concluded that it was not the right time. The Constitution's Article 3 let Parliament by law form new states, increase or reduce their area and alter their boundaries; the book notes that the makers did not limit reorganisation to language alone.
Potti Sriramulu and the States Reorganisation Commission
The demand revived after the first general elections. Potti Sriramulu began a fast for a separate Andhra state on 19 October 1952 and died on 15 December 1952. (Andhra State was formed on 1 October 1953, a date the book does not give; its exercise names Andhra as the first state formed on a linguistic basis.) This led to the States Reorganisation Commission, chaired by Fazl Ali (spelt 'Fazli Ali' in the text), with K.M. Panikkar and H.N. Kunzru, which reported in October 1955. The book lists the 16 states it recommended and calls its plan a compromise between administrative convenience and linguistic concerns.
Reorganisation in stages
The book says the Nehru government was by then committed to the linguistic principle and passed the States Reorganisation Act, 1956. The core principle in each case was linguistic identity.
| Year | Change |
|---|---|
| 1956 | Andhra Pradesh formed by joining the Telugu-speaking areas of Hyderabad State to Andhra (the book says it included the Hyderabad State) |
| 1956 | Kerala formed from Travancore-Cochin State and the Malabar district of Madras |
| 1956 | Karnataka (then called Mysore State) formed from Mysore State and parts of Bombay and Madras States |
| May 1960 | Gujarat created for Gujarati speakers (the bilingual Bombay State was divided into Gujarat and Maharashtra) |
| 1966 | Punjab trifurcated: a Punjabi-speaking Punjab, with Haryana carved out and areas added to Himachal Pradesh |
The book notes that the demand for a Punjabi Suba was called separatist by the establishment until 1966, and that the trifurcation of Punjab completed the process begun by the Congress in 1920.
Linguistic states: from idea to reality
- 1920 Nagpur Congress committees organised by language.
- 1928 Nehru Report Section 86: provinces on a linguistic basis.
- 1948-49 Linguistic Provinces Commission and JVP Committee advise delay.
- 1952 Potti Sriramulu's fast and death.
- 1955-56 States Reorganisation Commission; States Reorganisation Act.
- 1960 and 1966 Gujarat and Maharashtra; trifurcation of Punjab.
Worked example 1: two committees compared
Question: How did the JVP Committee's view differ from the Nehru Report's? Step 1: the Nehru Report (1928) supported linguistic provinces on popular demand. Step 2: the JVP Committee (1949) thought the time was wrong after partition and warned of narrow provincialism, though it allowed for later change. Step 3: the difference is one of timing and circumstances, not total rejection of the idea.
Worked example 2: matching people and bodies
Match: Fazl Ali; Pattabhi Sitaramayya; Rajendra Prasad; Potti Sriramulu. Step 1: Fazl Ali - chairman, States Reorganisation Commission. Step 2: Pattabhi Sitaramayya - raised the Andhra demand in 1946 and was the 'P' of the JVP Committee. Step 3: Rajendra Prasad - set up the Linguistic Provinces Commission in 1948. Step 4: Potti Sriramulu - fasted for Andhra and died in 1952.
1920 Nagpur Congress - 1928 Nehru Report - 1948 Linguistic Provinces Commission - 1949 JVP Committee - 1952 Potti Sriramulu - 1955 SRC report - 1956 States Reorganisation Act - 1960 Gujarat - 1966 Punjab.
Key takeaways: linguistic provinces were a promise of the national movement from 1920; after partition the Constituent Assembly, the Linguistic Provinces Commission and the JVP Committee advised delay; Potti Sriramulu's fast and death forced the issue; and the States Reorganisation Commission and the 1956 Act, followed by the changes of 1960 and 1966, redrew India's map largely on language lines.
Check your understanding
-
1. At which Congress session was it resolved to set up Provincial Congress Committees on a linguistic basis?
- Karachi, 1931
- Lahore, 1929
- Nagpur, 1920
- Jaipur, 1948
Show answer
Answer: C. The book says the Nagpur session of 1920 recorded that national identity would be achieved through linguistic identity and organised Provincial Congress Committees by language.
-
2. Who were the members of the JVP Committee?
- Jinnah, Vallabhbhai Patel and Prasad
- Jawaharlal Nehru, Vallabhbhai Patel and Pattabhi Sitaramayya
- Jagjivan Ram, Vinoba Bhave and Patel
- Jawaharlal Nehru, V.P. Menon and Panikkar
Show answer
Answer: B. JVP stands for Jawaharlal Nehru, Vallabhbhai Patel and Pattabhi Sitaramayya; the committee reported on 1 April 1949.
-
3. Whose death after a fast in December 1952 revived the demand for an Andhra state?
- Potti Sriramulu
- Pattabhi Sitaramayya
- T. Prakasam
- K.M. Panikkar
Show answer
Answer: A. Potti Sriramulu began his fast on 19 October 1952 and died on 15 December 1952, which led to the formation of Andhra and then the States Reorganisation Commission.
-
4. Who chaired the States Reorganisation Commission that reported in October 1955?
- H.N. Kunzru
- K.M. Panikkar
- Rajendra Prasad
- Fazl Ali
Show answer
Answer: D. Fazl Ali was chairman, with K.M. Panikkar and H.N. Kunzru as members.
-
5. Which constitutional article lets Parliament form new states and alter the boundaries of existing ones?
- Article 1
- Article 3
- Article 370
- Article 356
Show answer
Answer: B. The book quotes Article 3, under which Parliament may by law form a new state, increase or diminish the area of a state, and alter its boundaries.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.