- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Partition: the Radcliffe line and its human cost
Explain how the boundaries of India and Pakistan were drawn by the Radcliffe commissions in 1947, read the textbook's population figures for divided Punjab and Bengal, and describe the violence, migration and refugee crisis that followed.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the challenges free India faced, as the textbook sets them out.
- Explain how Sir Cyril Radcliffe's two Boundary Commissions worked, and why the book says the award contained anomalies.
- Use the book's figures to describe the minorities left on each side, the migration and the loss of life, and explain the Nehru-Liaquat (Delhi) Pact of 1950.
Unit 8 of the Tamil Nadu textbook opens with the words of Nehru's midnight speech of 14-15 August 1947 about India's 'tryst with destiny', and then asks how the new nation met its challenges. The book lists them: dealing with the consequences of partition, planning the economy and reforming education (the next unit), making a Constitution, merging more than 500 princely states, reconciling linguistic diversity with the needs of a nation-state, and forming a foreign policy in tune with democracy, sovereignty and fraternity. This lesson begins with partition, the subject of section 8.1.
The plan for partition
Attlee's statement of 20 February 1947 set June 1948 (the book says 30 June 1948) for British withdrawal, and Mountbatten replaced Wavell as Viceroy in March 1947. On 3 June 1947 Mountbatten announced his plan and brought the date of transfer of power forward to 15 August 1947, which the book says left a mere 72 days. Power was to pass to two dominions, India and Pakistan, and Bengal and Punjab were to be divided. The Congress accepted the plan at the AICC in mid-June 1947. Gandhi, who had strongly opposed division, now accepted it as unavoidable: he explained that the unending communal violence, with people across Punjab and Bengal taking part, had left him and the Congress without strength to resist it.
The idea was that the border would follow the religious majority of each village: Muslim-majority villages to Pakistan, Hindu-majority villages to India, with rivers, roads and mountains also used as markers. Minorities were expected to stay where they were as citizens. A village whose majority community did not touch the territory of 'its' country would stay with the country it was contiguous to. In Punjab there was a further complication: the Sikhs were recognised as a separate religious identity, and the Akali Dal declared that it would stay with India.
Radcliffe and the Boundary Commissions
Sir Cyril Radcliffe, a lawyer who, the book stresses, had no experience of India, arrived on 8 July 1947. He presided over two Boundary Commissions, one for Punjab and one for Bengal, each with two Muslim and two Hindu judges. They had about five weeks to classify villages as Hindu- or Muslim-majority using the 1941 census, which, the book says, is widely accepted to have given faulty results because it was taken during the Second World War. They were also limited by the need for contiguity and by Sikh demands that villages in West Punjab with Sikh shrines go to India. The reports were submitted on 9 August 1947, but the boundaries were announced only after power was transferred, so people celebrated independence without knowing the new map.
How the border was drawn (1947, as the textbook tells it)
- 3 June Mountbatten announces the plan; transfer of power advanced to 15 August.
- 8 July Radcliffe arrives to chair the Punjab and Bengal commissions.
- Village-by-village work Majorities judged from the 1941 census; contiguity and Sikh shrines considered.
- 9 August The award is submitted.
- After 15 August The boundaries are made public and carried out by the two dominions.
The award's figures
The Punjab and Bengal assemblies had resolved that West Punjab and East Bengal would go to Pakistan, joined by Sind, Baluchistan and the North-West Frontier Province. The book says Radcliffe's award 'contained all kinds of anomalies' and calls it 'an exercise without a method'. East Pakistan (which became Bangladesh in December 1971) was formed from eastern Bengal, Sylhet district of Assam, Khulna and the Chittagong Hill Tracts, while districts with large Muslim populations, such as Murshidabad, Malda and Nadia, stayed in India.
| Region | Area | Population | Minority share |
|---|---|---|---|
| West Punjab (to Pakistan) | 62,000 sq miles | 15,800,000, of whom 11,850,000 Muslims | About a quarter non-Muslim |
| East Punjab (to India) | 37,000 sq miles | 12,600,000, of whom 4,375,000 Muslims | More than a third Muslim |
| West Bengal (to India) | 28,000 sq miles | About 21.2 million (printed '21,200,00' in the book) | About a quarter Muslim, the book says |
| East Bengal (to Pakistan) | 49,400 sq miles | 39,100,000, of whom 27,700,000 Muslims | About 29 per cent Hindu |
Violence and migration
After partition, the book says, about 42 million Muslims lived in India and 20 million non-Muslims (Hindus, Sindhis and Sikhs) in Pakistan. Although Hindu-Muslim unity had been seen in the RIN revolt and the INA trials, the country now 'resembled a volcano'. Riots were worst in Punjab and Bengal; minorities on both sides lived in fear, and as police often stood by, more people fled. Gandhi stayed away from Delhi and fasted on 15 August 1947, which the book calls symbolic.
The book gives these figures. Between August and November 1947, about 4.5 million people moved from West Pakistan to India (to East Punjab and Delhi), and about 5.5 million Muslims left East Punjab, the United Provinces and Delhi for Pakistan; similar movement took place across the Bengal border. The historian Gyanendra Pandey records about 500,000 Hindu and Sikh refugees coming into Punjab and Delhi in 1947-48, and several thousand Muslims driven from their homes in Delhi to camps around the Red Fort and Purana Quila, with poor water and sanitation. Columns of refugees on foot (a kafila) and trains were attacked by mobs. The book says the dead can only be estimated, at 200,000 to 500,000, with 15 million displaced. It also prints a poem on partition by W.H. Auden and suggests the film Garam Hawa, the tele-film Tamas and Khushwant Singh's novel Train to Pakistan.
The book records that the assassination of Gandhi on 30 January 1948 showed the toll communalism took on the new nation. As late as 8 April 1950, Nehru and Liaquat Ali Khan signed the Delhi Pact to restore minorities' confidence on both sides, but it did not change conditions on the ground, and India also worked to rehabilitate refugees and train them in new skills. The book adds that partition posed a challenge to the Constituent Assembly: to draft a secular, democratic and republican constitution while Pakistan chose to become an Islamic Republic.
Worked example 1: checking the book's percentages
West Punjab: non-Muslims = 15,800,000 - 11,850,000 = 3,950,000; 3,950,000 ÷ 15,800,000 = 0.25, so a quarter. East Punjab: 4,375,000 ÷ 12,600,000 ≈ 0.347, about 35 per cent - 'more than a third'. East Bengal: non-Muslims = 39,100,000 - 27,700,000 = 11,400,000; 11,400,000 ÷ 39,100,000 ≈ 0.29, about 29 per cent.
Worked example 2: why the line caused hardship
Give three reasons from the book. First, time: about five weeks for the commissions. Second, data: an unreliable 1941 census and out-of-date maps. Third, secrecy: the award was made public only after independence, so millions did not know which country they were in. Together these left large minorities on both sides at a time of violence.
Partition, as the textbook records it: about 72 days from plan to transfer of power; borders drawn by Radcliffe in about five weeks from the 1941 census; an estimated 200,000-500,000 dead and 15 million displaced.
Key takeaways: Mountbatten's plan of 3 June 1947 divided Punjab and Bengal; Radcliffe's commissions drew the border hastily from the 1941 census, leaving large minorities on both sides; and partition was followed, as the book records, by mass migration, killings and refugee camps, which the Delhi Pact of 1950 tried but failed to undo.
Check your understanding
-
1. On which census were the Boundary Commissions to identify Hindu- and Muslim-majority villages?
- The 1931 census
- The 1941 census
- The 1951 census
- A new census taken in 1947
Show answer
Answer: B. The book says the commissions used the 1941 census, which is widely accepted to have been faulty because it was taken during the Second World War.
-
2. When did Radcliffe submit the award, according to the book?
- 3 June 1947
- 8 July 1947
- 15 August 1947
- 9 August 1947
Show answer
Answer: D. Radcliffe arrived on 8 July and the commissions submitted their report on 9 August 1947; the boundaries were made public only after 15 August.
-
3. Using the book's figures for East Punjab (12,600,000 people, 4,375,000 Muslims), about what share of its people were Muslims?
- About 35 per cent
- About 25 per cent
- About 50 per cent
- About 10 per cent
Show answer
Answer: A. 4,375,000 ÷ 12,600,000 ≈ 0.347, about 35 per cent, which the book describes as more than a third.
-
4. What did the Delhi Pact of 8 April 1950 between Nehru and Liaquat Ali Khan aim to do?
- Fix the Kashmir border
- Divide the assets of the army
- Restore confidence among minorities on both sides
- Create East Pakistan
Show answer
Answer: C. The book says the pact aimed to restore minorities' confidence and the hope of return, but it did not change the ground reality.
-
5. According to the book, what was the estimated number of people killed in the partition violence?
- About 15 million
- Between 200,000 and 500,000
- About 42 million
- Fewer than 10,000
Show answer
Answer: B. The book says the dead can only be estimated, between 200,000 and 500,000, with 15 million displaced. 42 million is the book's figure for Muslims remaining in India.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.