- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Industrial development: policy, public sector and liberalisation
Explain the Nehruvian strategy of heavy industry, the Industrial Policy Resolutions of 1948 and 1956, licensing under the 1951 Act, the growth and problems of the public sector, and the liberalisation of 1991 with its effects.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why India chose a heavy-industry, state-led model over the alternatives.
- Describe the 1948 and 1956 industrial policies, the 1951 licensing Act and later policy statements.
- Explain the rise of the public sector, its crisis by 1991, and the positive and negative effects of liberalisation.
Section 9.3 of the textbook explains how independent India built its industry, and how, after four decades, it changed course.
Choosing a model
The book notes that India could have grown through labour-intensive processing industries using its raw materials, or through the Gandhian model of village and cottage industries producing consumer goods to end rural poverty and unemployment. The government instead adopted the Nehruvian model: large-scale heavy industry, with the state setting up wholly owned units to produce steel and intermediate goods such as machines, chemicals and fertilisers. The social purpose, as the book puts it, was to restrict private capital, which was seen as exploitative and benefiting a small class of capitalists.
Industrial policy
| Year | Measure | Key point |
|---|---|---|
| 1948 | First policy statement | Four categories: strategic state monopolies (atomic energy, railways, arms); 18 industries under government control; mixed; private |
| 1951 | Industrial Development and Regulation Act | No new unit or expansion without a government licence |
| 1956 | Industrial Policy Resolution | Schedule A: state monopoly; Schedule B: state may start units, private sector may too; Schedule C: the rest |
| 1973 | Policy statement | Large houses encouraged into rural and backward areas |
| 1977 | Janata government's statement | Promotion of rural, village and small-scale industries |
| 1980 | Congress government's statement | Balanced growth |
| 1991 | Industrial Policy Statement | Licences and controls removed; liberalisation |
The book calls the 1956 Resolution the most definitive statement. Controls went beyond licensing: private-sector inputs like cement were rationed, permits were needed even to build a private house, and the making of consumer goods was severely restricted. This expressed the aim of reducing inequality in consumption, and also kept scarce resources like steel and cement for strategic industries. Coal mines, petroleum companies, banking and insurance were nationalised.
The public sector
According to the book, there were only 5 public sector enterprises in 1951 and 225 by 2012, with capital investment rising from ₹29 crore to ₹7.3 lakh crore. Two considerations drove this: ideologically, a socialistic pattern required state control; practically, heavy industry needed huge investment in 'long gestation' projects that the private sector of the 1950s could not or would not finance. Steel plants at Bhilai, Rourkela, Durgapur and Bokaro, and engineering units such as Bharat Heavy Electricals (BHEL) and Hindustan Machine Tools, were set up with technical help from Britain, Germany and Russia (the book places all of these in the 1950s; Bokaro was in fact set up later, in the 1960s). Units not tied to raw materials were placed in backward areas to reduce regional disparity: BHEL was set up first at Bhopal and later at Tiruchirappalli, Hyderabad and Haridwar. Public enterprises' profits also went partly to the central government.
Crisis by 1991
By 1991, the book says, the public sector faced severe problems. Overall it made a profit, but nearly half came from petroleum units and many units made continuous losses. The causes it lists:
- Expansion into non-strategic areas such as tourism, hotels and consumer goods (in the 1970s only public sector companies made television sets).
- Locations chosen for political rather than efficiency reasons.
- Construction delays and cost overruns, so units were over-capitalised.
- Administered prices that made little sense when public sector goods were inputs for private industry.
- Overstaffing beyond what the technology needed.
- Management by bureaucrats, leading to inefficiency.
The government began disinvestment of loss-making and non-strategic units in 1991. Even so, the book concludes that building long-term capacity through heavy industry succeeded in making India a modern industrial economy.
Liberalisation, 1991
Effects of liberalisation, as the textbook assesses them
-
Positive
- Goods and services available to the middle class and even lower-income families
- India more attractive for foreign investment
- States compete to improve ease of doing business
- A general air of prosperity in growth figures
-
Negative
- Wider income gaps between top and lower income groups
- Removal of ceilings on corporate salaries widened gaps
- Most new jobs in the informal sector
- Gaps between formal and informal sectors
The book notes that neither side is satisfied: advocates of a free economy want more market freedom, while left economists feel the state has abandoned its duty of ensuring social justice and welfare.
Worked example 1: growth of the public sector
Using the book's figures: enterprises grew from 5 to 225, that is 225 ÷ 5 = 45 times. Investment grew from ₹29 crore to ₹7.3 lakh crore. Since 1 lakh crore = 1,00,000 crore, 7.3 lakh crore = 7,30,000 crore; 7,30,000 ÷ 29 ≈ 25,172 times (in money terms, not adjusted for price rises).
Worked example 2: classifying an industry in 1956
Question: Under the 1956 Resolution, could a private firm set up a unit in a Schedule B industry? Step 1: recall Schedule A - state monopoly, no private entry. Step 2: Schedule B - the state could start new units, but private firms could also set up or expand units. Step 3: so yes, though it would also need a licence under the 1951 Act.
1948 policy - 1951 licensing Act - 1956 Resolution (Schedules A, B, C) - public sector growth - crisis and disinvestment from 1991 - liberalisation 1991.
Key takeaways: India chose state-led heavy industry over Gandhian and labour-intensive models; the 1951 Act and the 1956 Resolution set up a system of licences and state monopolies; the public sector grew rapidly but faced severe problems by 1991; and liberalisation in 1991 widened choice and investment while increasing inequality.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Act of 1951 required a government licence to set up or expand an industrial unit?
- Industrial Policy Resolution
- Industrial Development and Regulation Act
- States Reorganisation Act
- Companies Act
Show answer
Answer: B. The book calls the Industrial Development and Regulation Act of 1951 an important instrument for controlling the private sector through licences.
-
2. Under the Industrial Policy Resolution of 1956, Schedule A industries were:
- open only to the private sector
- small-scale and cottage industries
- a monopoly of the state
- industries in rural areas only
Show answer
Answer: C. Schedule A industries were under state monopoly; in Schedule B both state and private sector could set up units; Schedule C covered the rest.
-
3. According to the book, how many public sector enterprises were there in India in 1951?
- 5
- 18
- 225
- 50
Show answer
Answer: A. The book says there were only five public sector enterprises in 1951, rising to 225 by 2012.
-
4. Where was BHEL first set up, according to the book?
- Tiruchirappalli
- Haridwar
- Hyderabad
- Bhopal
Show answer
Answer: D. BHEL was first set up in Bhopal and later in Tiruchirappalli, Hyderabad and Haridwar, partly to reduce regional disparities.
-
5. Which of these does the book NOT give as a cause of the poor performance of public sector units?
- Overstaffing
- Location chosen for political reasons
- Competition from imports after 1948
- Management by bureaucrats
Show answer
Answer: C. The book lists non-strategic expansion, political location decisions, cost overruns, uneconomic administered prices, overstaffing and bureaucratic management. Import competition is not among them.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.