- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Land reforms: zamindari, tenancy and ceilings
Explain the three revenue systems of British India, the abolition of zamindari, tenancy reform, land ceiling laws including Tamil Nadu's, the Bhoodan movement, and the textbook's overall appraisal of land reform.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish the Permanent Settlement (zamindari), ryotwari and mahalwari systems.
- Describe zamindari abolition, tenancy reform and land ceilings, with the textbook's figures and the reasons they fell short.
- Give the book's appraisal of land reform in economic and social terms, and describe Bhoodan.
Section 9.1 of the textbook deals with land reforms and rural reconstruction. Under the Constitution, agriculture is a state subject, so each state passed its own laws. The basic form was common, but the details varied from state to state.
Three revenue systems of British India
| System | Where (as the book says) | Who paid revenue to the government |
|---|---|---|
| Permanent Settlement (zamindari) | Bengal and most of north India | The zamindar, an intermediary who collected rent from cultivators |
| Ryotwari | South India | The ryot (cultivator) directly |
| Mahalwari | Very small pockets | The village collectively |
Zamindars remitted a fixed sum to the government, but there was no legal limit on what they could demand from cultivators, and they generally extorted high rents. Public opinion saw them, the book says, as a decadent, extravagant and unproductive class living on unearned income. Abolishing zamindari was in the Congress manifesto even before independence.
Abolition of zamindari
Most provinces passed abolition laws even before the Constitution was framed. By 1949, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Madras, Assam and Bombay had done so; West Bengal, where the Permanent Settlement began, passed its act only in 1955. Land taken from zamindars went to tenants, with compensation fixed by the legislatures. When zamindars challenged the laws in court, Parliament passed the First Amendment (1951) and Fourth Amendment (1955) to the Constitution, which barred challenges to the takeover or to the amount of compensation.
Abolition was completed by 1956, and the book calls it possibly the most successful land reform. According to the textbook, about 30 lakh tenants and sharecroppers became owners of 62 lakh hectares, and the compensation actually paid was ₹16,420 lakhs - only about a quarter of what was due. Yet the reform achieved only part of its aim: many zamindars evicted tenants and kept land by claiming it was under their 'personal cultivation', so many landowners still held vast areas.
Tenancy reform
Nearly half of all cultivated land was under tenancy. Not all tenants were landless: small owners and even rich owners leased extra land. Rent was usually paid in kind and often amounted to 50% or more of the produce; agreements were customary, oral and rarely recorded, so tenants could be evicted at short notice. Tenancy reform had two objectives: to protect cultivators and to make land use more efficient, since neither owner nor tenant had reason or money to invest in the land.
- Regulate rent - laws fixed it at one-fourth to one-third of the produce, but because land was scarce and labour plentiful, real rents were simply paid 'under the table'.
- Secure the tenant's rights and make tenancy heritable - this failed because agreements were oral and unrecorded.
- Give tenants ownership of the land - landowners again claimed 'personal cultivation' and called tenants hired labourers.
The book concludes that tenancy reform could not work without an enforceable land ceiling, though measures in Kerala and West Bengal met with reasonable success.
Land ceilings
A land ceiling is the maximum land a person may legally own. Laws came after the 1950s; in Tamil Nadu the ceiling was first implemented in 1961. Until 1972 the unit was the individual 'landholder'; after 1972 it became the 'family', and landowners could claim that each member owned a part, keeping each share under the limit. Fixing ceilings was complex because land differed in quality (irrigated or dry, single or double crop), and exemptions for orchards, horticulture, grazing land, religious and charitable trusts and sugarcane plantations were used to evade the law, along with manipulation of land records. According to the book, only about 65 lakh hectares were taken over as surplus and given to about 55 lakh tenants. The book says dominant castes who were big landowners used their political power to dilute the legislation.
Bhoodan, the movement begun by Vinoba Bhave to persuade large landowners to give surplus land voluntarily, attracted much public attention.
The textbook's appraisal of land reform
-
Economic result
- No visible improvement in efficiency
- The dream of prosperous owner-cultivators stayed a dream
- Later growth came from technology and a freer land market
-
Social result
- Semi-feudal zamindari effectively abolished
- Peasants more politically aware of their rights
- Peasants empowered
Worked example 1: average land per tenant
Using the book's ceiling figures: 65 lakh hectares ÷ 55 lakh tenants = 65 ÷ 55 ≈ 1.18 hectares each - 'a little over 1 hectare per tenant', as the book says. For zamindari abolition: 62 lakh hectares ÷ 30 lakh tenants ≈ 2.07 hectares each.
Worked example 2: why rent control failed
Step 1: note the market - there were far more people wanting land to cultivate than land available. Step 2: a legal rent of one-fourth to one-third was below what tenants competing for land would pay. Step 3: so tenants agreed privately to higher rents, unrecorded. The book's lesson: price controls do not work when demand exceeds supply.
Zamindari abolition: the most successful land reform, completed by 1956. Tenancy reform and ceilings: largely evaded through 'personal cultivation' claims, family units and exemptions.
Key takeaways: zamindari was abolished by 1956 with the help of the First and Fourth Amendments; tenancy reform failed on rent, security and ownership because agreements were oral and land was scarce; ceilings were diluted by family units and exemptions; and the book judges land reform a social, not an economic, success.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under the ryotwari system, who paid the land revenue to the government?
- The zamindar
- The cultivator (ryot) directly
- The village as a whole
- The moneylender
Show answer
Answer: B. In ryotwari, found in south India, the cultivator paid directly. Zamindars paid under the Permanent Settlement, and the village collectively under mahalwari.
-
2. Which constitutional amendments, according to the book, stopped zamindars from challenging the takeover of land or the compensation?
- The First (1951) and Fourth (1955) Amendments
- The 42nd and 44th Amendments
- The Seventh Amendment only
- The First and Second Amendments of 1950
Show answer
Answer: A. The book says the First Amendment of 1951 and the Fourth Amendment of 1955 pre-empted zamindars' right to question the takeover or the compensation.
-
3. In Tamil Nadu, what changed in the land ceiling law after 1972?
- The ceiling was abolished
- Ceilings were applied only to temples
- The unit changed from the individual landholder to the family
- Sugarcane land lost its exemption
Show answer
Answer: C. Until 1972 the ceiling applied to a landholder; after 1972 the unit became the family, letting owners claim that each member held part of the land.
-
4. Why, according to the book, did laws making tenancy secure and heritable fail?
- Tenants refused ownership
- The courts struck them down
- Rents were already low
- Tenancy agreements were oral and unrecorded
Show answer
Answer: D. Agreements were made orally and not recorded, so tenants always lived with the risk that the landlord would resume the land.
-
5. Assertion (A): Zamindari abolition achieved only part of its original objective. Reason (R): Many zamindars evicted tenants and kept land by claiming it was under personal cultivation.
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. The book says abolition dismantled zamindari but many landowners kept vast tracts through 'personal cultivation' claims. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.