• Practice
  • About 22 min
  • 5 practice questions

Atom models: Thomson, Rutherford's alpha scattering and Bohr's postulates

Explain why Thomson's model failed, interpret Rutherford's alpha-scattering results, calculate the distance of closest approach and relate impact parameter to scattering angle, and state Bohr's postulates.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe Thomson's watermelon model and why it cannot be stable.
  • Describe the Geiger-Marsden alpha-scattering experiment and Rutherford's conclusions.
  • Calculate the distance of closest approach and relate the impact parameter to the scattering angle.
  • Give the two failures of Rutherford's planetary model.
  • State Bohr's three postulates and connect the quantisation of angular momentum with de Broglie waves.

The idea of the atom is old: around 400 BC, the Greek thinkers Leucippus and Democritus suggested that dividing matter again and again must end in indivisible pieces. The word atom comes from the Greek for 'indivisible'. The electron showed that atoms do have parts. The question became: how are the positive and negative charges arranged inside an atom? Three models answered in turn, each fixing the failure of the one before.

Thomson's model: the watermelon atom

J. J. Thomson pictured the atom as a uniform sphere of positive charge, about 10⁻¹⁰ m across, with electrons embedded in it like seeds in a watermelon. The total positive charge equals the total negative charge, so the atom is neutral, and all the charges are at rest. Two problems sink it. First, a set of charges held at rest by electric forces alone can never be in stable equilibrium (Earnshaw's theorem), so such an atom would not be stable. Second, it gives no explanation for the sharp spectral lines emitted by hydrogen and other atoms.

Rutherford's alpha-scattering experiment

Geiger and Marsden, working on Rutherford's advice, fired alpha particles (positively charged helium nuclei) at a very thin gold foil. The alpha source, a radioactive material such as polonium, sat in a thick lead block with a fine hole; a lead screen with a second hole narrowed the beam. A zinc sulphide screen, movable from 0° to 180° around the foil, gave a flash of light wherever an alpha particle struck, and the flashes were counted through a microscope.

  • Most alpha particles went straight through the foil, undeflected.
  • Some were deflected through small angles.
  • A very small fraction were deflected through more than 90°.
  • A very few bounced almost straight back, through about 180°.

If Thomson's model were right, the spread-out positive charge could never turn a fast alpha particle back. Rutherford concluded that an atom is mostly empty space, with all its positive charge and almost all its mass packed into a tiny central nucleus about 10⁻¹⁴ m across. Since static charges cannot be stable, he proposed that the electrons revolve around the nucleus in circular orbits, like planets around the Sun. The scattering pattern his nuclear model predicts agrees closely with Geiger and Marsden's counts at every angle.

Distance of closest approach

An alpha particle (charge 2e) heading straight at a nucleus (charge Ze) slows down, stops for an instant and turns back through 180°. At its closest distance r₀ all its kinetic energy has become electrostatic potential energy: ½mυ₀² = (1/4πε₀)(2e)(Ze)/r₀, so r₀ = (1/4πε₀)(2Ze²/E_k), where E_k is the alpha particle's initial kinetic energy. The nucleus must be smaller than r₀, so this distance sets an upper limit on the nuclear size. Rutherford's estimates of nuclear radii ranged from about 10⁻¹⁴ m to 10⁻¹⁵ m.

Impact parameter and scattering angle

The impact parameter b is the perpendicular distance from the centre of the nucleus to the line of the alpha particle's velocity when it is still far away. Rutherford's analysis gives b = K cot(θ/2), with K = (1/4πε₀)(2Ze²/mυ₀²) and θ the scattering angle. A large b means a glancing pass and a small deflection; a small b means a near head-on approach and a large deflection; b = 0 gives θ = 180°.

Closest approach: r₀ = (1/4πε₀)(2Ze²/E_k). Impact parameter: b = K cot(θ/2): smaller b, larger deflection.

Why Rutherford's model fails

Instability. Classical electromagnetism says an accelerated charge radiates energy. An electron moving in a circle is always accelerating towards the centre, so it should radiate continuously, lose energy and spiral into the nucleus in a tiny fraction of a second. Atoms do not collapse. Wrong spectrum. A spiralling electron would emit radiation of continuously changing frequency, giving a continuous spectrum, but atoms emit sharp lines. The model also says nothing about how the electrons are arranged.

Bohr's postulates

Niels Bohr, also a student of Rutherford, kept the nucleus but added quantum rules for hydrogen and hydrogen-like atoms (one electron).

  1. Postulate 1: The electron moves around the nucleus in a circular orbit; the Coulomb attraction of the nucleus provides the centripetal force.
  2. Postulate 2: Only certain orbits, called stationary orbits, are allowed, and an electron in one of them does not radiate. In these orbits the angular momentum is a whole-number multiple of ħ = h/2π: mυr = nħ, n = 1, 2, 3 … (n is the principal quantum number).
  3. Postulate 3: The energy of an orbit is fixed (quantised). The atom emits or absorbs radiation only when the electron jumps between orbits, and the photon carries the energy difference: ΔE = E_final − E_initial = hν = hc/λ. The frequency depends on the energy levels, not on how fast the electron goes round.

The de Broglie picture of postulate 2. An electron has a wavelength λ = h/mυ. In a stable orbit the wave must fit round the circumference a whole number of times and form a standing wave: 2πr = nλ. Substituting λ = h/mυ gives 2πr = nh/mυ, that is mυr = nh/2π = nħ, exactly Bohr's condition. An orbit holding, say, 3.3 wavelengths would make the wave cancel itself, so it is forbidden.

From one atom model to the next

  1. Thomson Positive sphere with embedded electrons; unstable, no spectral lines
  2. Rutherford Tiny massive nucleus, orbiting electrons; should collapse and give a continuous spectrum
  3. Bohr Stationary orbits with mυr = nħ; explains stability and hydrogen's line spectrum

Worked example 1: closest approach to a gold nucleus

A 5.0 MeV alpha particle heads straight towards a gold nucleus (Z = 79). Take 1/4πε₀ = 9 × 10⁹ N m² C⁻² and e = 1.6 × 10⁻¹⁹ C. Step 1: E_k = 5.0 × 10⁶ × 1.6 × 10⁻¹⁹ = 8.0 × 10⁻¹³ J. Step 2: 2Ze² = 2 × 79 × (1.6 × 10⁻¹⁹)² = 158 × 2.56 × 10⁻³⁸ = 4.04 × 10⁻³⁶ C². Step 3: r₀ = (9 × 10⁹ × 4.04 × 10⁻³⁶)/(8.0 × 10⁻¹³) = (3.64 × 10⁻²⁶)/(8.0 × 10⁻¹³) = 4.55 × 10⁻¹⁴ m, about 45 fm. The gold nucleus is smaller than this.

Worked example 2: de Broglie waves in an orbit

In the hydrogen atom the radius of the 3rd orbit is 4.76 Å. Find the de Broglie wavelength of the electron there, and its angular momentum (h = 6.6 × 10⁻³⁴ J s). Step 1: 2πr = nλ, so λ = 2πr/n = (2 × 3.14 × 4.76 Å)/3 = 29.9/3 = 9.96 Å. Step 2: L = nh/2π = (3 × 6.6 × 10⁻³⁴)/(2 × 3.14) = (1.98 × 10⁻³³)/6.28 = 3.15 × 10⁻³⁴ kg m² s⁻¹.

Key takeaways

  • Thomson's static model is unstable (Earnshaw's theorem) and cannot explain spectral lines.
  • Alpha scattering showed a tiny, positive, massive nucleus; r₀ = (1/4πε₀)(2Ze²/E_k) and b = K cot(θ/2).
  • Rutherford's orbiting electrons should radiate and spiral in, giving a continuous spectrum: both contradict experiment.
  • Bohr: stationary orbits with mυr = nħ, no radiation in them, and hν = E_final − E_initial for jumps; 2πr = nλ gives the same rule.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the alpha-scattering experiment, most alpha particles passed through the gold foil undeflected. This shows that:

    1. The atom is mostly empty space
    2. Gold atoms carry no charge
    3. Alpha particles have no mass
    4. Electrons are spread uniformly through the atom
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Most alpha particles meet nothing that can deflect them, so most of the atom must be empty space; the positive charge and mass are concentrated in a tiny nucleus.

  2. 2. An alpha particle aimed head-on at a nucleus with a smaller impact parameter than another alpha particle of the same energy will be:

    1. Deflected less
    2. Absorbed by the nucleus
    3. Deflected more
    4. Undeflected
    Show answer

    Answer: C. b = K cot(θ/2). As b gets smaller, cot(θ/2) gets smaller, so θ/2 and therefore θ get larger: a closer approach means a larger deflection, up to 180° for b = 0.

  3. 3. If the kinetic energy of the alpha particle is doubled, the distance of closest approach to a given nucleus becomes:

    1. Twice as large
    2. Four times as large
    3. One quarter
    4. Half
    Show answer

    Answer: D. r₀ = (1/4πε₀)(2Ze²/E_k), so r₀ ∝ 1/E_k. Doubling E_k halves r₀.

  4. 4. According to Bohr's second postulate, the angular momentum of an electron in the 4th orbit is (h = Planck's constant):

    1. 4h
    2. 2h/π
    3. h/8π
    4. 8πh
    Show answer

    Answer: B. mυr = nh/2π. For n = 4: L = 4h/2π = 2h/π.

  5. 5. Which observation could Rutherford's planetary model not explain?

    1. Large-angle scattering of alpha particles
    2. That the nucleus is positively charged
    3. The line spectrum emitted by hydrogen
    4. That most of the atom is empty
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The planetary model explained the scattering results. But an orbiting electron should radiate continuously and spiral inwards, giving a continuous spectrum, whereas hydrogen gives sharp lines. Bohr's postulates were made to fix this.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery